Philosophy
Is Knowledge the Whole Story of Happiness?
Socrates tests whether knowledge is enough to make us happy. Priam’s losses and Aristotle’s account of friendship make it easier to see what the question leaves open.
The Platonic Dialogues: CharmidesThe Charmides separates the knowledge that makes our other skills beneficial from a complete account of what a good life requires.
Orientation
At a Glance
- A life without error is the first proposalSocrates recalls the hope that genuine knowledge would let a household or city avoid mistakes and that its people would therefore be happy.
- Other goods can matter tooAristotle uses Priam to consider how disaster can affect a good life. He also treats friends as indispensable.
- The dialogue tests what knowledge can doSocrates grants that the genuine experts would improve health and safety. He still asks whether acting knowledgeably would make people happy.
- Knowledge of good and bad has a special roleThe speakers give that knowledge the work of making the other crafts beneficial. How friendship, health, and circumstances contribute to happiness is still a separate question.
Charmides 153a–c, 171d–172a, 173b–c, 173d–174a, 174a–d · Euthydemus 279c–e, 280a–b · Aristotle, Nicomachean Ethics 1.9 (1100a), 1.10 (1100b), 8.1 (1155a) · Martha C. Nussbaum Luck and Ethics
The search begins with the grand picture Socrates and Critias had agreed to entertain. If temperance let us know what we know and don’t know, then “we would live our lives without error,” a household or city run by temperance “would be bound to be run well,” and those so disposed “must necessarily do finely and well in every action, and those who do well must be happy.” Eventually the question narrows to which knowledge contributes most to happiness. Health and safety appear as gains an expert can secure. The speakers leave a larger question about what else a life depends on.
Aristotle puts some of those other things into view. He points to Priam, the king of Troy, as someone whose disasters prevent us from simply calling him happy. A good person can bear reversals nobly, and the reversals still affect his life. Aristotle also says no one would choose to live without friends even if he had every other good. Martha Nussbaum takes up this Greek concern with the good life’s exposure to luck in The Fragility of Goodness.
In another conversation, Plato’s Socrates pushes the power of knowledge further. In the Euthydemus, he argues that wisdom is good fortune, since flute-players are the most fortunate at flute-playing and pilots the most fortunate at sea, and he concludes that wisdom everywhere makes people fortunate. That’s about as close to saying that knowledge is the whole story as a philosopher can get, and if the Charmides shared it, the objection about luck and relationships would land squarely. Being in the hands of a skilled pilot gives a passenger reason for hope. There’s still a question about what a pilot can do when a storm comes up.
But the wording of the Charmides is more careful than that. What Socrates tests is Critias’ claim that knowledge of a certain kind would be enough, that living without error would by itself mean doing well and being happy. He grants that a world of genuine experts would act and live knowledgeably, and then says that whether “by acting knowledgeably we would do well and be happy, this, my dear Critias, we cannot yet learn.” His refusal leaves room to ask what else a good life needs.
Socrates first asks, “Then which, most of all?” Later he says “but only this one, the knowledge of good and bad.” The stronger wording gives this knowledge a unique role in the argument. Without it, a doctor can still heal and a cobbler can still make good shoes. Socrates’ point is that their successes need judgment about how they will be used. That leaves open whether the judgment can take the place of all the other things a life needs.
It’s also worth noticing what the dialogue shows while the argument talks. Socrates returns from the fighting at Potidaea and is met by friends eager to hear who has come home safely. A guardian is proud of his ward, and the ward wants to come back for the charm. The scene includes relationships and circumstances the argument about the kinds of knowledge never tries to explain. When the speakers turn to happiness, the reader has already seen some of the things a life depends on.
The framing does leave some questions about luck and relationships open. A reader who takes the last pages as a complete theory of happiness will have to supply a great deal. The speakers begin with a particular proposal about knowing enough to avoid error. Their reply tells us something about what it takes to use knowledge well.
My verdict is that the Charmides finds a limit to what expertise can secure. Its account of what makes the crafts beneficial helps explain why happiness would take more than acting knowledgeably. The reader can still ask how much a wise person needs from friends, from the body, and from circumstances no amount of wisdom can control.
Test your understanding
Question 1 of 3
Why does the article treat Socrates’ conclusion in the Charmides as more cautious than his argument in the Euthydemus?
Guided Inquiry
Questions for Socrates
Explore these questions with Socrates, with this Feature as your reading context.
- If knowledge of good and bad guides the use of every craft, what further reasons might there be to doubt that this knowledge alone guarantees happiness?→
- How should the relationships and vulnerable circumstances shown in the dialogue’s dramatic setting affect our interpretation of its argument about happiness?→
- Can a person remain happy through severe reversals if they respond nobly, or must happiness partly depend on conditions beyond character and wisdom?→