Philosophy

Is Health Always Good for You?

Good shoes can take you somewhere you shouldn’t go. Socrates thinks even good health raises a similar question about where you’re headed.

Medicine can restore health by its own standards. The Charmides asks what makes that success a benefit to the person whose health is restored.

Orientation

At a Glance

  • Health is the hard caseCritias agrees that medicine can make people just as healthy without knowledge of good and bad. Socrates still asks what makes that result beneficial.
  • A benefit can depend on useThe Meno asks how health, strength, beauty, and wealth can help on some occasions and harm on others. Right use makes the difference in that argument.
  • The dialogue returns to the whole personAt the start of the Charmides, the Thracian doctor says treatment should begin with the soul. The later argument asks what bodily health does for a person’s life as a whole.
  • The ordinary case still mattersA difficult example can show that health’s value depends partly on circumstances. The essay asks why being healthy is nevertheless so reliably good for us.

Charmides 156e–157b, 173b–c, 174b–d · Laches 195c–d · Gorgias 511e–512b · Meno 87e–88a · Thucydides 6.31, 7.87 · Aristotle, Nicomachean Ethics 1.8 (1099a–b)

When Socrates asks whether medicine would make us “any less healthy” without the knowledge of good and bad, Critias says “No less,” and Socrates concludes that each craft’s result being done “well and beneficially” would be gone. With shoes that’s easy to accept, since a well-made pair of boots can carry a burglar to his next job as comfortably as they carry a nurse to her shift. With health it’s harder, because health isn’t a product you hand to someone and walk away from, it’s a condition of the person himself, and the obvious objection is that a healthy person is better off than a sick one no matter what else is true of him.

Other dialogues press the point in sharper examples. In the Laches, Nicias distinguishes what doctors know about health and disease from the judgment that recovery will be better for a particular patient. In the Gorgias, Socrates describes a pilot who has brought his passengers safely home and walks along the shore without boasting. He doesn’t know whom he has helped by saving them. Both examples make us ask what the person will be able to do with the life the craft has helped preserve.

The Meno states the general principle behind those examples. Health, strength, beauty and wealth, Socrates says there, sometimes benefit people and sometimes harm them, and what makes the difference is whether they’re used rightly, which depends on wisdom. On this view health is a resource, enormously valuable in the right hands, but its value for a particular person depends on what that person does with it, the way a full tank of gas is good if you’re driving somewhere worth going and less good if you’re driving off a cliff.

Imagine an Athenian who wanted to sail for Sicily in 415 BC but fell sick just before the fleet left. Thucydides describes the expedition’s departure as a magnificent spectacle and records that few of the many who went eventually came home. He doesn’t tell the story of this particular man. It’s easy to see, though, how an illness that had seemed a piece of bad luck could turn out to have kept someone alive.

The other side deserves a real hearing. Most of us would rather be healthy than sick, even without knowing what we’ll do with our health. Aristotle argues that good action is difficult without some favorable circumstances and resources. The cases in the Laches and Gorgias are severe enough to make the usual preference for health or safety questionable. That leaves room for a strong presumption in favor of both in ordinary life.

The Charmides has its own resources for this debate, and they come from its opening. The Thracian doctor taught that everything, “bad and good alike, for the body and for the whole human being, starts from the soul and flows from there,” and that once temperance is present in the soul, “it is easy then to provide health” for the rest of the body. Socrates presents this as the doctor’s account of treating the whole person. The end of the dialogue echoes it when Socrates asks us to consider how bodily health fits into a life that goes well.

So which is it, an unconditional good, a resource whose use matters, or a case the argument doesn’t fully explain? The resource view fits best with Plato’s other dialogues and with the Thracian doctrine, and the counterexamples show that health’s value really can depend on circumstances. But the argument in the Charmides treats health too much like shoes, as just one more craft product, without explaining why health is good so reliably that most people never need the other knowledge to see its value. It establishes that health can fail to benefit, and leaves unexplained why that failure is so rare. Shoes are good for whoever wears them only now and then, depending on where he walks, while health is good for whoever has it nearly all the time, and an account of benefit ought to explain that difference.

My verdict is that health is a resource with an unusually strong presumption in its favor. We can imagine cases where having it helps put a person in danger, as with the man who might otherwise have stayed home from Sicily. The dialogue gives us a way to see why that can happen. It leaves us with a question about why health, unlike most things a craft can supply, comes so close to being good for everyone who has it.

Test your understanding

123

Question 1 of 3

According to the article's reading of the Meno, what ultimately determines whether health benefits a person?

Choose one answer

Guided Inquiry

Questions for Socrates

Explore these questions with Socrates, with this Feature as your reading context.