Renaissance

Is Bacchus Dreaming or About to Fall Over?

Michelangelo lets the god’s body sway while his gaze drifts toward the cup. Pater takes that drifting attention seriously enough to call it inspired sleep.

Condivi and Shelley both notice signs of drunkenness in the marble. Pater’s dreamer comes into view when we look at the face alongside the precarious stance.

Orientation

At a Glance

  • The figure never quite steadies itselfBacchus raises his cup and shifts his weight onto one leg. A satyr behind him steals grapes while the god’s attention drifts.
  • Condivi and Shelley see intoxicationCondivi describes the eyes as those of a heavy drinker. Shelley found the face brutal and dissolute.
  • Pater concentrates on the faceThe slightly parted lips and distant gaze suggest an attention turned inward. Pater connects the expression with Michelangelo’s interest in inspired sleep.
  • The old categories can overlapIn the Phaedrus, Socrates gives Dionysus one kind of divine madness. The comparison leaves room to read the figure’s unsteadiness beside its absorbed expression.

In the Bargello in Florence there’s a naked young god nearly seven feet tall, tipping a wine cup up toward his face, with vine leaves and grapes in his hair and a bunch of grapes dangling from his other hand, which a small goat-legged satyr behind his leg is quietly eating. He stands with his weight on one leg, his belly soft, his knees loose, his body leaning just a little farther than looks safe, and his eyes don’t seem to focus on anything. Pater looks at this figure and sees not “the mirthfulness of the god of wine, but his sleepy seriousness, his enthusiasm, his capacity for profound dreaming,” and adds that “no one ever expressed more truly than Michelangelo the notion of inspired sleep, of faces charged with dreams.”

First a small correction, because Pater says Michelangelo made the statue “on returning to Florence,” and he didn’t. The Bacchus belongs to his first stay in Rome, around 1496 and 1497. A study of the commission identifies Cardinal Raffaele Riario as the original patron and questions the familiar claim that he rejected the result. The work was later in the collection of the Roman banker Jacopo Galli, where it could be seen among ancient sculpture. The Medici bought it in 1572, and it reached the Bargello in 1871.

The case for a drunk starts with Michelangelo’s own camp. Condivi describes the face as merry and the eyes as “squinting and lascivious, like those of people excessively given to the love of wine,” which is about as far from inspired sleep as you can get. Shelley, in his notes on sculpture in Florence, calls the face drunken, brutal and dissolute. He wanted the serene young god of Greek statues, and Michelangelo had given him a party guest at two in the morning.

The body backs up the drinkers, since the satyr adds a small, steady shape near the base while the god appears to sway. The contrast gives the theft of the grapes an extra visual joke. Vasari admired the mixture of a youth’s slenderness with the soft roundness of a woman’s flesh, and the figure can look ready to sway again when you move around it.

The case for the dreamer rests on the face, and here I think Pater sees something Condivi and Shelley miss. The eyes aren’t really squinting with appetite so much as drifting, the lips are slightly parted, and the head tilts toward the cup as if the god were listening to it rather than drinking it. Nothing in the face is merry, and nothing is brutal either, because the expression is vacant in the way a face goes vacant when its owner has gone somewhere inside, which is exactly what Pater means by “faces charged with dreams,” and it’s the same withdrawn look he finds in Michelangelo’s sleepers and in the languid Adam on the Sistine ceiling.

The choice also changes our relation to the statue. If he’s simply drunk, we’re spectators at a little comedy, or a sermon on excess, standing outside the scene and judging. If he’s dreaming, we’re shut out in a different way, because a dreamer doesn’t know we’re there, and the only creature paying attention to anything is the satyr intent on his grapes. Michelangelo carved him fully in the round, so you have to walk all the way behind him to discover the thief at his feet, and the walk only confirms the point. Either way the god ignores us completely, which may be the most unsettling thing about him, since most statues of gods are built to look back at you.

Pater’s best word is “enthusiasm,” and it quietly dissolves the either-or. In Greek the word meant having the god inside you, and in Plato’s Phaedrus 265b, Socrates associates Dionysus with the madness of rites. The passage gives us a way to imagine divine inspiration alongside the unsteady body, though Socrates is speaking about ritual rather than describing this statue.

So my verdict is that the Bacchus is both, a body that’s plainly drunk carrying a face that’s plainly somewhere else. Shelley read the legs and missed the face, while Pater read the face and politely ignored the legs, and Michelangelo carved the moment where the wine has done its work and the dream begins. Inspired sleep, in this statue, isn’t the alternative to intoxication but where intoxication ends up, and the satyr eating the grapes behind his back is the only one in the room who’s still sober.

Test your understanding

123

Question 1 of 3

How does the author ultimately reconcile the competing interpretations of Bacchus as drunk and as dreaming?

Choose one answer

Guided Inquiry

Questions for Socrates

Explore these questions with Socrates, with this Feature as your reading context.