Philosophy

How Would You Spot a Real Doctor?

Socrates asks who can judge a doctor’s claims and actions. His examples elsewhere in Plato suggest a different question a patient or a city might be able to answer.

A license and a sound diagnosis are two different kinds of evidence. What can people outside medicine learn about the person who supplies the diagnosis?

Orientation

At a Glance

  • What the doctor test asksSocrates’ examiner must judge whether a doctor speaks truly and acts rightly about health and disease. Critias agrees that this examination requires medicine.
  • The layperson’s evidenceA person outside medicine can have grounds for trusting a clinician without being able to check a diagnosis. Goldman distinguishes several indirect kinds of evidence a novice can consider.
  • Other Platonic testsIn the Laches, Socrates asks who taught the proposed advisers and whether they can show successful work. In the Gorgias, he imagines asking candidates for public medical work whom they’ve helped.
  • Why the signs have limitsA credential is evidence of an assessment someone else made. A record of apparent success can also be misleading, so neither does the same work as an expert examination.

Socrates sets out the test in a few quick steps. Whoever wants to examine a doctor must examine him in what is healthy and diseased, “in what is said or done in this way, whether the things said are said truly and whether the things done are done rightly.” Then he asks, “Could anyone, then, follow either of these without medicine?” Critias answers, “Certainly not.” On the terms they’ve agreed to, judging the doctor that way takes a doctor, “and so not the temperate man either; for then he would be a doctor in addition to being temperate.”

As a claim about judging medical truth on its merits, that’s hard to dispute. To check whether a diagnosis is well founded or whether a treatment was the right one, you have to understand the body, the disease and the options. That’s the point of having people with the relevant expertise review a colleague’s work. Think of asking a hospital’s billing department to decide whether a surgeon carried out a procedure correctly. The staff could have an excellent grasp of the paperwork and still be unable to answer the question.

But people without medical training choose doctors all the time, and there’s a difference between making a choice on evidence and guessing. A medical degree, a license and a recommendation from another clinician give different kinds of reasons for trust. The philosopher Alvin Goldman asks how a novice can choose between experts who disagree. He considers, among other things, what other experts think, whether the speakers have interests that might affect their testimony, and what their track records show. His question is how much a novice can reasonably infer from such evidence.

Plato suggests some indirect tests elsewhere. In the Laches, Socrates asks the people advising two fathers on their sons’ education to name their teachers if they had any, or to show that they’ve helped make people better. In the Gorgias, he imagines himself and Callicles considering public medical work and asking one another whether they can name anyone they’ve helped recover from an illness, slave or free. These are questions an examiner can ask before trusting someone with public work. What the answers establish still depends on the quality of the evidence.

That gives us a distinction worth carrying back to the Charmides. To check a particular diagnosis is to make a judgment about medicine. To recognize a trustworthy sign of competence is to make a judgment about evidence for trusting a person. Think of the difference between checking a surgeon’s license and checking the reasoning behind the operation. The license can give you grounds for confidence before the surgeon has said anything about your case. The operation still has to be justified on its own merits.

The indirect signs have a catch, though, and it brings us back toward Socrates. A credential records a judgment by people or institutions charged with assessing a practitioner. A reputation may reflect the judgments of patients and colleagues, and the two groups can have different things to go on. Even recovery rates can mislead if one doctor takes much harder cases than another. The signs have value because there is something behind them, and it can take medical knowledge to tell what a given sign is worth.

That helps explain why the dialogue keeps its attention on the direct test. The question is whether a pure knowledge of knowledge could judge the doctor by recognizing knowledge itself. The layperson who asks for a credential or finds out what other doctors think has a different strategy. She knows she’s relying on other people’s judgment and tries to work out whose judgment is relevant. Critias’ temperance was supposed to make that borrowing unnecessary.

My verdict is that Socrates is right about what it takes to examine a diagnosis, and that the examination is only one kind of judgment about expertise. A layperson can learn why a particular doctor has earned trust without being able to check the doctor’s medical reasoning. That route depends on evidence from people who know something about medicine. The patient who knows where to look for that evidence has a resource the bare power Critias proposes has yet to explain.

Test your understanding

123

Question 1 of 3

What central distinction does the article draw between evaluating a diagnosis and evaluating a doctor’s credentials?

Choose one answer

Guided Inquiry

Questions for Socrates

Explore these questions with Socrates, with this Feature as your reading context.