Philosophy
How Much Must an Outsider Know?
Between ignorance and mastery, there are things an informed outsider can judge.
The Platonic Dialogues: CharmidesSocrates asks what it takes to assess a doctor as a doctor. Aristotle and a modern experiment in physics help us see what people outside a profession can learn to do.
Orientation
At a Glance
- The examination Socrates proposesJudging the doctor’s statements and treatment in a particular case requires knowledge of health and disease.
- What an outsider can recognizeKnowing where a field begins and ends helps a reader see when someone is speaking beyond their expertise.
- Aristotle’s educated listenerAristotle gives the educated listener a way to assess how an expert presents an explanation, even when judging its conclusions takes more knowledge.
- A modern test in physicsAfter years of studying a research community, Harry Collins could discuss its technical questions in a way many physicist judges couldn’t distinguish from a practitioner’s answers.
Charmides 170b–e, 171a–c · Apology 22d–e · Aristotle, Politics III.11, 1282a1–23 · Aristotle, Parts of Animals I.1, 639a1–15 · Harry Collins and Robert Evans Interactional Expertise · Harry Collins An Imitation Game, p. 9
Socrates draws a sharp line. Whoever wants to look into medicine, he says, “must look into it in the things in which it is found.” To assess what a doctor says and does about health and disease, you need medical knowledge. That’s a plausible demand for the kind of examination Socrates has in mind. It leaves a question about the judgments people make all the time without practicing medicine. What can you know about a field from outside it?
For a start, you can know something about its boundaries. It doesn’t take medical training to tell that a doctor giving investment advice is speaking about something beyond medicine. In the Apology, Socrates reports that the craftspeople he questioned knew things he didn’t. He also thought some of them took their skill as a reason to claim wisdom about much larger matters. You can ask whether somebody is speaking within their field even when you’d need their help on questions inside it.
Aristotle sees a place for a more educated kind of outsider. In the Politics, he distinguishes the ordinary practitioner, the master of the craft, and the person educated in medicine who can also judge. In Parts of Animals, he says an educated listener can assess how an explanation is presented. There’s room to judge the method of an account even when the truth of its conclusions is harder to check. In the political discussion he also asks whether citizens can judge some things from the standpoint of people who use or depend on them.
Harry Collins and Robert Evans call one kind of understanding interactional expertise. A person can learn the language of a field well enough to take part in its technical discussions without doing the work that its practitioners do. Collins tried this in a written test about gravitational-wave physics after years of studying that community. He and a physicist answered the same questions. In his account of the first test, seven of nine physicist judges said they couldn’t tell the answers apart. The example gives us a sense of how much someone can learn through sustained conversation.
What can someone in that middle ground do? A careful reader can learn the shape of an argument, ask what would count against it, and check whether the view they’re hearing is widely shared in the field. A patient who’s spent years learning about a condition can ask an informed question about a proposed treatment. Whether the treatment is right in that particular case may take knowledge the patient doesn’t have. The question can still help bring the reason for the decision into view.
This middle ground matters to the Charmides. Critias wants a kind of knowledge that can assess expertise while dealing only with knowledge in general. An informed outsider can ask the questions we’ve been imagining because they’ve learned something about a field, its subject, and what its practitioners take as evidence. That’s already more than Critias’s definition allows. It suggests a modest version of the judgment he wants, one that grows out of learning enough to recognize where we need help.
The Socrates of the Apology offers a picture of that kind of questioning. He goes to people who know things he doesn’t and takes their knowledge seriously. When their confidence goes beyond their craft, it gives him a reason to ask how far their knowledge goes. A person can do that without being able to practice their craft. There’s a difference between asking someone how they got to a conclusion and claiming to have settled the matter for them.
My verdict is that the medical example in the Charmides works as a test of Critias’s sweeping claim. If you want to assess a doctor’s decisions as a doctor would, you need the knowledge those decisions call for. There are still plenty of things an outsider can learn to recognize and ask about. Aristotle and Collins help put that space into view. The first useful question may be how much we know already, followed closely by what we’d need to learn to judge this case.
Test your understanding
Question 1 of 3
According to the article, what best distinguishes an informed outsider from Critias’s proposed knowledge of knowledge in general?
Guided Inquiry
Questions for Socrates
Explore these questions with Socrates, with this Feature as your reading context.
- How should we decide when an outsider has learned enough to question an expert responsibly, rather than merely overestimating their own understanding?→
- If a patient can expose the reasoning behind a treatment decision without being able to determine whether the treatment is correct, what kind of knowledge has the patient gained?→
- Does recognizing that an expert has gone beyond the boundaries of their craft require some knowledge of the neighboring field as well? Why or why not?→