Renaissance

How Many Pictures Make a Temperament?

When a picture changes attribution, a critic’s account of the painter faces a test.

Botticelli’s melancholy and Giorgione’s distinctive mood depend on which pictures count as evidence. Pater’s idea of the Giorgionesque shows how a perceptive account of style can survive a changed attribution.

Orientation

At a Glance

  • The corpus mattersA claim about a painter’s temperament depends on which pictures can securely be attributed to that painter.
  • A story loses its authorityThe National Gallery gives Palmieri’s altarpiece to Botticini, so its alleged heresy cannot establish Botticelli’s intentions.
  • A stronger test of styleTitian’s Concert still looks Giorgionesque, which makes it evidence of a shared style rather than proof of Giorgione’s hand.
  • A critical distinction survivesPater distinguishes the artist’s surviving work from the wider influence and atmosphere he calls the Giorgionesque.

The Preface makes temperament the heart of criticism twice over. The critic needs “a certain kind of temperament, the power of being deeply moved by the presence of beautiful objects,” and what he’s moved by, again and again, is the temperament of an artist, a distinctive cast of feeling that shows up across a body of work. But a body of work is only as solid as its list, and the list is set by attribution. If a picture you used as evidence turns out to belong to someone else, then either the temperament you found survives the loss, or you found something that was never the painter’s at all. It’s a bit like judging a songwriter’s style from a playlist that turns out to include a few covers by other bands, where everything depends on which tracks were really hers.

Botticelli is the gentler test, because his list is long and mostly settled. Pater uses a picture with the portrait of its donor, Matteo Palmieri, and the story that it was suspected of heresy, to interpret the “peculiar sentiment” of Botticelli’s figures, which he describes as “the wistfulness of exiles” running “through all his varied work.” The note records that the National Gallery now gives that picture to Francesco Botticini. That sounds like a disaster for the argument, but look at how Pater uses the picture, which is to color a quality he’d already found elsewhere, in the Madonnas and in the Venus. “True or false,” he writes, the story “interprets much” of that sentiment, so the picture was a lens and not the foundation.

That gives a first rule of evidence worth stating plainly. A temperament inferred from many securely attributed works is robust to losing one of them, the way a scientific result that survives the removal of one data point is more trustworthy than one that collapses without it. Botticelli’s melancholy can still be tested against securely attributed Madonnas and mythological pictures. In those works, faces and postures can support the reading without the story of the Palmieri altarpiece. What it does remove is the heresy story’s authority, since a tale about another painter’s picture can’t tell you what was in Botticelli’s head. The Palmieri story was always the weakest kind of evidence anyway, since a legend about a picture tells you what people said about it, not what the painter put into it.

Giorgione is the hard test, because his list is tiny and kept changing. Pater reports that of “six or eight famous pictures” once given to Giorgione, “only one is certainly from Giorgione’s hand,” and that one was The Concert in the Pitti Palace, which he calls “undoubtedly Giorgione’s,” and which the Uffizi now gives to Titian. The Gallerie dell’Accademia, meanwhile, recognizes The Tempest as a Giorgione. Neither judgment supports treating Pater’s list as a permanent set of evidence. A temperament inferred from one picture is only as good as that picture’s label, and here the label changed in both directions, which is about as clear a warning as connoisseurship ever gives.

Pater, to his credit, saw the danger and built a concept to survive it. He separates “the real Giorgione and his authentic extant works” from the “Giorgionesque,” which he calls “an influence, a spirit or type in art,” active in painters “so different as those to whom many of his supposed works are really assignable.” That’s a quiet admission that what he’s describing isn’t one man’s temperament but a shared style, a school, something that belongs to a group of painters working near each other in Venice. The concept lets him keep his description of the pictures while giving up the claim that they reveal a single personality. In effect he moves the temperament from a man to a place and a moment, from Giorgione to Venice in the first years of the sixteenth century, and his phrase that Giorgione becomes “a sort of impersonation of Venice itself” says as much.

That points to a second rule, and it’s where the contrast between accepted and reassigned pictures earns its keep. If a reassigned picture shows the supposed temperament just as strongly as the accepted ones, the critic has reason to test whether the quality is shared across the period or workshop. A single counterexample can expose the weakness of the attribution without settling the whole question of style. So a disputed picture is the best experiment a critic gets, a natural control case, and Pater’s Giorgione chapter, read this way, shows the Giorgionesque surviving in Titian’s Concert, which suggests it was a school quality all along.

Someone could reply that this is too strict for the kind of criticism Pater practices. His aim was never a legal attribution but an account of an impression, and an impression is real whoever painted the picture, so the beauty of The Concert doesn’t evaporate when the label changes. That’s true, and Pater says something like it about the Louvre Holy Family, whose charm survives its reassignment. But the claim that a quality expresses a temperament is a claim about a person, and claims about persons need evidence about which works are theirs. Pater’s own Preface asks the critic to trace an impression to its source, after all, and a wrong name is a wrong source.

So how many pictures does it take to make a temperament? There’s no magic number for it, but there are conditions that any count has to meet. The works must be several and securely attributed, the quality must be visible in them rather than in stories told about them, and it must be stronger in the painter’s own works than in those of his circle. By those standards Botticelli’s melancholy holds up and Giorgione’s personal temperament doesn’t, and Pater’s own invention of the Giorgionesque is the best evidence that he knew the difference.

Test your understanding

123

Question 1 of 3

Why does the reassignment of the Palmieri altarpiece not destroy the article’s case for Botticelli’s melancholy?

Choose one answer

Guided Inquiry

Questions for Socrates

Explore these questions with Socrates, with this Feature as your reading context.