Greek Antiquity

How Kronos Became the Forethinker

Prometheus enters the hymn to Kronos through a shared language of intricate and crooked counsel.

The hymn calls Kronos “august Prometheus” after giving him the cunning familiar from Hesiod. Abel’s Greek also leaves room to hear the word as a title for someone who thinks ahead.

Orientation

At a Glance

  • The name is a surpriseHesiod gives Kronos and Prometheus separate stories, yet the hymn addresses Kronos as august Prometheus.
  • The epithets prepare itThe words for intricate and crooked counsel recall the language Hesiod uses for Prometheus.
  • The Greek can be read as a titleAbel’s lower-case printing allows a reader to hear forethinker as well as the Titan’s name.
  • The end looks forwardThe singers ask the god who thinks ahead to grant a blessed and blameless end of life.

Orphic Hymns, XIII.1–2, 5, 7–10, with the notes on XIII.7 and XIII.9

Line 7 of the hymn to Kronos runs through a list of titles and then lands somewhere nobody expects, “birth, diminisher of growth, husband of Rhea, august Prometheus.” Kronos and Prometheus are both Titans, but in Hesiod they’re different people with different stories, Kronos the son of Gaia and Ouranos who castrated his father and ate his children, Prometheus the son of Iapetos who stole fire for mortals and was chained for it. The collection is full of sudden identifications, Night called Kypris, Nature called Dike, Pan called “the true horned Zeus,” and the edition’s note lists those very examples, but it points out that this one is different, because “this one is prepared,” set up in advance by the words around it.

The preparation is a matter of diction, and it’s neat. In line 2 Kronos is poikiloboulos, “of intricate counsel,” and that is an epithet Hesiod gives to Prometheus in the Theogony, in the very line where Zeus binds him in chains. In line 9 he is ankylomētēs, “crooked-counselled,” which the note explains is “Kronos’s formulaic epithet in Homer, where it is his alone,” while in Hesiod it is shared with Prometheus, in the Theogony and again in the Works and Days. So the hymn brackets the name with one of Prometheus’s words before it and one word the two Titans share after it, and by the time “Prometheus” arrives, the ground has been laid so that the name feels like the next step rather than a leap.

That’s how epithets work in this kind of poetry, and it’s worth seeing why. A formula like “crooked-counselled” travels with a figure the way a nickname travels with a person, and when two people share a nickname, conversations start to blur them, the way two friends who both get called Doc end up having each other’s stories told about them. The hymn has a third cunning word for good measure, “Kronos of intricate speech,” at line 5, so three compounds of cleverness cluster around the name, and the poem even opens by calling him “father of the blessed gods and of men also,” which is Homer’s standing formula for Zeus. In this hymn, epithets move freely, and the identification rides on that freedom.

The Greek page adds a detail the English can’t show. Abel prints the word in lower case, promētheu, so on the Greek page it can be read as a common noun, “forethinker,” as easily as a proper name. The name was transparent to Greek ears anyway, since promētheia is forethought, and Aeschylus makes a joke of it in Prometheus Bound, where the brute Kratos tells the chained Titan that the gods call him Forethinker falsely, because now he needs a forethinker himself to get out of those chains. So the hymn’s word sits right on the line between name and description, and “august Forethinker” is a fair way to hear it alongside “august Prometheus.”

What the identification means beyond that is the open part, and the hymn really does leave it open. You could take it as a statement about providence, Kronos as the planning mind behind the world, and Plato had already offered a reading of the name in the Cratylus that makes Kronos pure, unmixed intellect, which would make forethought his natural work. You could take it mythically, since both Titans outwit the order above them, Kronos ambushing his father with a sickle and Prometheus tricking Zeus over the sacrificial portions, and both end up bound. Or you could take it as a matter of benefaction, since Hesiod’s golden race lived like gods when Kronos was king and Prometheus gave mortals fire, so both stand at the start of human good fortune.

The note on line 9 catches one more thing that matters for any of those readings. The hymn sets “crooked-counselled” right beside “most excellent,” and the note observes that it does so “without softening either,” so crooked counsel is praised outright as part of the god’s excellence. That’s a little startling to modern ears, where calling someone crafty is a compliment with an edge, but Greek poetry admired cunning in its heroes and gods alike, and the hymn treats a twisty mind as a form of greatness. Whatever Kronos is being identified with, it’s the cleverness he shares with Prometheus, and the hymn has no interest in apologizing for it.

The closing prayer gives the identification a quiet payoff. The worshippers ask, “hearing the suppliant voice / may you send an end of life ever blessed and blameless,” and that’s an apt thing to ask of a forethinker, the one who sees ahead. Aeschylus’ Prometheus boasts that he stopped mortals from foreseeing their own deaths and planted blind hopes in them instead, which makes him the Titan who took foreknowledge of the end away from humans so they could live. Asking the august Forethinker for a good end puts the matter back in the hands of the one who sees what mortals can’t, and lets them get on with living while he looks ahead.

My verdict is that the diction gives the identification a solid poetic foothold, two of Prometheus’s Hesiodic epithets and a third cunning compound set around the name, with Abel’s lower case letting the word be heard as forethought as well. The theological scope, though, stays modest unless the reader brings more. What the hymn identifies is a quality, intricate and crooked counsel praised as excellence, and Kronos is called Prometheus because he thinks like him. Anyone who wants Kronos as providence or as mind has good ancient company for it, but has to supply it from Plato and the philosophers, since the hymn itself stops at the title and lets the Titan behind it hover.

Test your understanding

123

Question 1 of 3

Why does the article describe the hymn’s identification of Kronos with Prometheus as “prepared” rather than sudden?

Choose one answer

Guided Inquiry

Questions for Socrates

Explore these questions with Socrates, with this Feature as your reading context.