Renaissance

How Can a Work of Art Stay Calm in the Face of Pain?

Theocritus and Victor Hugo give Pater examples of steady attention to subjects that are anything but calm.

Pater’s discussion of tragedy helps separate the suffering in a story from the steadiness with which an artist can ask us to look at it.

Orientation

At a Glance

  • Conflict enters the Greek idealPater says the harmony of the Greek ideal needs a sharper note, and tragedy finds dignity in how conflict unfolds.
  • The Cyclops sings his painTheocritus keeps Polyphemus’s longing audible while letting his song become a way to bear it.
  • Hugo makes suffering visibleFantine’s bloody mouth and Gilliatt’s long vigil keep the pain in view even as the telling holds steady.
  • Serenity belongs to the treatmentAn artist can maintain composure while representing a person or event that offers little comfort.

Pater sets up the problem with a story about boredom, which is a weird place to start a theory of tragedy, but stick with him. The Greek ideal of a man “at unity with himself” is lovely, he says, but perfect harmony goes flat, so if people were to be saved from the ennui (the French word for that stale, sated boredom) of having everything, “it was necessary that a conflict should come, that some sharper note should grieve the existing harmony.” Then comes the claim this whole discussion hangs on, that “Greek tragedy shows how such a conflict may be treated with serenity, how the evolution of it may be a spectacle of the dignity, not of the impotence, of the human spirit.” The question is whether that’s possible at all, or whether calm about a disaster is just a nicer name for not caring.

Everything depends on where you put the serenity, in the people of the story, in the outcome, or in the telling, where the artist keeps a steady hand while everybody else falls apart. Winckelmann put it in the figures, since his whole taste was formed on the repose of statues, and that’s why, Pater says, “his conception of art excludes that bolder type of it which deals confidently and serenely with life, conflict, evil.” The grammar is telling, because the serenity belongs to the art that deals with conflict, and dealing is something the artist does.

Theocritus is the first test, since Pater says he “strikes often a note of romantic sadness,” and yet “what a blithe and steady poise, above these discouragements, in a clear and sunny stratum of the air!” Take the eleventh Idyll, which Theocritus addresses to his friend Nicias, a doctor, and which opens by saying there’s no medicine for love except the Muses. The patient is the Cyclops Polyphemus, hopelessly in love with the sea nymph Galatea, who sits on a rock singing to her about his cheeses and his flocks, wishing he’d been born with gills so he could swim down to her, until he tells himself to go milk the ewe he’s got instead of chasing the one that runs away. Galatea never comes, and whether the song cures him or just gets him through the afternoon, the hurt stays on the page, while the poise belongs to Theocritus, who tells it lightly and never mocks the pain.

Hugo is the harder test, and Pater picks him on purpose. In Toilers of the Sea (1866) the Guernsey fisherman Gilliatt spends weeks alone on a reef salvaging the engine of a wrecked steamer, fights off a giant octopus, and brings the engine home to win Déruchette, only to learn that she loves a young clergyman, so he arranges their wedding, sees them off on the ship Cashmere, and sits on a rock seat where the tide comes in, watching the sail until it vanishes at the same moment his head goes under. In Les Misérables (1862) Fantine sells her hair and then her two front teeth to a traveling quack for two gold coins, to meet a demand for money for her daughter’s supposed illness. When Marguerite comes in, Fantine smiles and shows her the money, with blood at the corners of her mouth. Pater asks what Winckelmann would have thought of “the bleeding mouth of Fantine.”

The other side deserves a real hearing, because there’s a serious case that serenity about suffering is a kind of anesthetic. Nietzsche gives the objection a point of departure in The Birth of Tragedy of 1872. He argues that the bright, clear figures of Sophocles are “luminous spots” produced to heal an eye hurt by staring into the terrible night of nature. The image makes serenity a response to injury. It raises the question of what such composure lets us continue to see. There’s a moral worry on top of that, since a critic who finds “a sense of beauty, as lively and transparent as that of a Greek” in a book about a poor woman having her teeth pulled for money is getting uncomfortably close to savoring her pain like a connoisseur.

I think Hugo survives the charge, and the reason tells you what serenity in the treatment really is. Hugo never calms Fantine down or tidies up her mouth, and instead he makes the blood visible in the scene with Marguerite, and the beauty Pater admires sits right beside the wound without covering it. Gilliatt is the subtler case, because there the character is serene himself, choosing his seat and keeping his eyes on the ship, and the prose stays as level as the rising water. That steadiness is a refusal to look away and a refusal to scream, the same thing you want from an emergency-room doctor whose calm voice tells you nothing about how bad the injury is and a great deal about whether somebody is paying attention to it.

Pater adds that Winckelmann missed this even in Greece, where “a sort of preparation for the romantic temper” was already at work. Greek religion had its “mournful mysteries of Adonis, of Hyacinthus, of Demeter,” and it remembered older gods who lost their thrones, since “Hyperion gives way to Apollo, Oceanus to Poseidon,” so that even the Olympians are “troubled with thoughts of a limit to duration, of inevitable decay, of dispossession.” The calm faces in the marble were never the whole story, and the religion behind them carried its losses the way a family can smile in every photo and still keep a lost child’s room exactly as it was. Winckelmann read the photographs and missed the room, which is the part of the Greek ideal that, as Pater puts it, “for his part Winckelmann failed to see.”

So conflict can be represented with serenity, as long as the serenity lives in the treatment and the wound stays visible. If the calm makes you stop seeing the injury, it’s an anesthetic and Nietzsche’s suspicion is earned, and if it lets you keep looking without flinching or wallowing, it’s the dignity Pater credits to tragedy. Winckelmann’s mistake was locating serenity in the statue’s face, which left him, in Pater’s account, poorly equipped for some wounded subjects, and Pater’s correction, moving it into the artist’s steady hand, is the right one, because it gives novels like Hugo’s a Greek license that they’ve fully earned.

Test your understanding

123

Question 1 of 3

According to the article, what is Winckelmann’s central mistake in understanding artistic serenity?

Choose one answer

Guided Inquiry

Questions for Socrates

Explore these questions with Socrates, with this Feature as your reading context.