Renaissance
How an Assumption Fell Under Suspicion
A Florentine altarpiece was suspected of carrying its patron’s unorthodox beliefs. Pater made the story a key to Botticelli’s art, although another painter made the picture.
The Renaissance (1893)The donors’ faces were scratched out, but the angels still admit more than one reading. The history of Botticini’s altarpiece shows how much a patron’s reputation can shape what viewers see.
Orientation
At a Glance
- Palmieri’s poem gives the soul an earlier lifeThe Florentine writer imagines souls as angels who stayed neutral in Lucifer’s revolt. They enter human bodies and face another choice on earth.
- The picture came under suspicionThe altarpiece was covered for a time and the donors’ faces were scratched out. Those acts tell us how the work was received, even though the imagery leaves room for more than one reading.
- Botticini painted the altarpieceVasari assigned it to Botticelli. The National Gallery gives it to Francesco Botticini, who also illustrated a manuscript of Palmieri’s poem.
- Pater uses the story as a possibilityHe asks what the story can help a viewer notice even if it is false. The neutral angels give him a way to describe the air of loss he finds in Botticelli’s figures.
The Renaissance · Sandro Botticelli, pp. 39–40, Palmieri and the suspected painting · Sandro Botticelli, note 94 · Sandro Botticelli, note 95 · Sandro Botticelli, note 96
Pater introduces the story as a counterweight to Dante’s orthodoxy. Botticelli, he says, was far from accepting the scheme that refers all human action to purgatory, heaven and hell, and “One picture of his, with the portrait of the donor, Matteo Palmieri, below, had the credit or discredit of attracting some shadow of ecclesiastical censure.” Palmieri, “the reputed author of a poem, still unedited,” had imagined “the human race as an incarnation of those angels who, in the revolt of Lucifer, were neither for Jehovah nor for His enemies.” The picture was suspected of embodying that dream, “and the chapel where it hung was closed.” Pater adds, with scholarly care, that “two dim figures move under that name in contemporary history.”
He was right about the two figures, since there were two humanists of almost the same name, Matteo Palmieri of Florence, who died in 1475, and Mattia Palmieri of Pisa, who worked for the papal curia. The painting in the National Gallery belongs to the Florentine. It is more than seven feet high and twelve feet wide, and was made for Palmieri’s funeral chapel in the church of San Pier Maggiore, and he and his wife, Niccolosa de’ Serragli, kneel at either end of the empty tomb, which the apostles surround and which is filled with lilies. Above, Christ blesses the crowned Virgin from the center of a golden dome, and below spreads a landscape with the Arno, the cathedral dome of Florence, Fiesole and Palmieri’s own farm and villa.
The edition’s note supplies the change that matters most. The National Gallery attributes the painting to Francesco Botticini, not Botticelli, and Vasari was the source of the old attribution. The note says plainly that this is consequential for Pater, who uses the story to interpret Botticelli’s other figures. But the new attribution brings a twist of its own, because the Gallery records that Botticini had illustrated the manuscript of Palmieri’s poem, usually called Città di vita, the City of Life, in 1465. The painter already knew the poem before making the altarpiece. That makes a connection plausible while leaving the nature of the connection open.
What would count as evidence that the painting embodies the poem? You would want a contract or a program from the donor, a contemporary witness who saw the heresy in the image, or something in the iconography that an orthodox Assumption wouldn’t contain. What we actually have is later testimony, since the Gallery records that the faces of Palmieri and his wife were scratched out, that access to the picture was barred for a time after his death, when suspicion of the poem ran highest, and that it was sometimes covered with a veil. Those actions show that some viewers treated the picture as suspect. They leave open which details those viewers thought carried the poem’s teaching.
The iconography is the interesting test, and it turns out to cut both ways. Around the Virgin the angels are arranged in three great rings, seraphim and cherubim nearest Christ, then the middle orders, then the archangels and angels, and saints and prophets are set among them. A reader of Palmieri could see human souls taking their places in the ranks of angels and think of the poem, in which the soul descends from heaven, takes a body and freely chooses between heaven and hell. But it was also perfectly orthodox teaching, going back at least to Augustine’s Handbook, chapter 29, that the redeemed would fill the places in heaven left empty by the fallen angels, so the same image fits both readings.
That’s how a familiar Assumption becomes suspect, by contagion rather than content. Nothing in the picture had to change for its meaning to darken, because the donor’s reputation flowed into it, and a viewer who knew the rumors about the poem saw the poem everywhere, while a viewer who didn’t saw a standard vision of heavenly glory. Pater recognizes exactly this possibility, writing that the picture “may have been only one of those familiar compositions” called glorias, a painted vision of the blessed, which “somehow” came to be suspected. That somehow is the honest center of the story, and the picture outlasted the chapel it made notorious, since the church itself was pulled down after an accident in 1783.
Pater also knows the limits of his use of it. “True or false,” he writes, “the story interprets much of the peculiar sentiment with which he infuses his profane and sacred persons, comely, and in a certain sense like angels, but with a sense of displacement or loss about them,” the “wistfulness of exiles.” He offers the legend as a key to a mood, not as a fact about Botticelli’s beliefs, and he says so in two words. The new attribution removes even the link between the legend and Botticelli’s hand, so what remains is Pater’s image of neutral angels in exile, which now has to stand on its own as a critic’s metaphor.
My verdict is that the painting became suspect through biography rather than iconography, since its imagery fits orthodox doctrine as easily as Palmieri’s heresy, and the damage to the donors’ portraits shows how closely the picture’s reception followed Palmieri’s reputation. The attribution to Botticini cuts the story off from Botticelli while making the poem and painting more plausibly connected. Pater, to his credit, never claimed more than he could show, and his “true or false” lets the story survive the loss of its evidence, as a parable for the uncertain figures he loved, with the reader warned in advance that a parable is all it is.
Test your understanding
Question 1 of 3
Why does the revised attribution to Francesco Botticini complicate rather than simply destroy the proposed connection between the painting and Palmieri’s poem?
Guided Inquiry
Questions for Socrates
Explore these questions with Socrates, with this Feature as your reading context.
- What kinds of evidence would allow us to distinguish a genuinely unorthodox visual program from an orthodox painting made suspicious by its donor’s reputation?→
- How does the painting’s reception illustrate the power of biography and rumor to alter the perceived meaning of an artwork without altering the artwork itself?→
- When, if ever, is it legitimate for a critic to use a historically uncertain story as a metaphor for interpreting an artist’s work?→