Renaissance

How a Mirror Lets Painting Rival Sculpture

Vasari tells of a lost Giorgione in which water, armor and a mirror show a single figure from several sides at once.

The Renaissance debate over painting and sculpture gives Pater a way to explain what a painter can do with a passing arrangement of light.

Orientation

At a Glance

  • The sculptors’ claimA statue gives a viewer new views as they walk around it, while a conventional portrait holds to one viewpoint.
  • A painter’s replyIn Vasari’s account, Giorgione sets water, armor and a mirror around the figure so several views appear together.
  • Two versions of the storyPaolo Pino tells an earlier version with an armored Saint George, while Vasari describes a nude man.
  • Why the instant mattersPater singles out the brief alignment of figure, light and reflecting surfaces as an example of what paint can preserve.

In the middle of a list of things Giorgione’s school could catch on the wing, Pater slips in a strange one, “some momentary conjunction of mirrors and polished armour and still water, by which all the sides of a solid image are exhibited at once, solving that casuistical question whether painting can present an object as completely as sculpture.” He’s thinking of a story Vasari told in 1568. Vasari sets the debate while Verrocchio was making his bronze horseman for Venice, in the 1480s, when Giorgione would still have been young. In the story, some sculptors say you can walk around a statue and see every side. Giorgione answers that a painting can give you several sides at a single glance.

Then, according to Vasari, he went ahead and proved it in paint. He painted a nude man with his back to the viewer, at whose feet lay a clear pool reflecting his front, while on one side a burnished breastplate he’d taken off reflected one profile and on the other side a mirror reflected the other. No such picture survives. Paolo Pino told an earlier version in 1548 in which an armored Saint George stands at the edge of a clear spring and two mirrors show the rest of him. But the idea was famous enough that Venetian painters kept answering it, and Savoldo’s portrait of a man in armor, now in the Louvre, sets two mirrors behind its sitter so you see his back and his side along with his face.

The quarrel behind the story had a name, the paragone, Italian for “comparison,” the long Renaissance contest over which art was nobler, and in 1547 the Florentine scholar Benedetto Varchi even polled the leading artists on it. Sculpture’s best argument was the one Vasari’s sculptors made, that a statue has all its sides, so it gives you the whole body while a painting gives you a single flat view. It’s a real advantage, the same one a 3D model has over a photograph, and painters needed an answer that didn’t involve pretending their pictures were solid. Bronzino, one of the artists who answered Varchi, later painted the court dwarf Morgante on both sides of a single canvas, front and back, as if to make painting’s case by brute force.

Giorgione’s answer is clever because it makes reflected light part of the composition. A real mirror mounted beside a statue changes with the room and the viewer. A painter can choose which view appears in the water, which in the armor and which in the glass, then hold all three in place.

Pater’s word “momentary” is the key to why he cares. The painter arranges the reflections for a particular point of view. In the world of the picture, stirred water or a shift of the man’s weight could change the alignment. Sculpture gives you all the sides in time, one after another as you walk around it, while the painting gives them all at once by stopping time at the single moment when everything aligns. That’s why the anecdote sits in a list with “instantaneous motion,” the lacing-on of armor and the fainting lady, since for Pater the essence of Giorgione is catching an instant that nature never holds still.

It also fits what Venice was, a city built on water and full of glass. Its lagoon reflects every palace upside down, its glassmakers were famous for mirrors, and its soldiers came home in polished plate, so a Venetian painter reaching for reflections was reaching for the most ordinary things in his world. A version of Savoldo’s mirrored portrait now in the Royal Collection was formerly attributed to Giorgione. Whatever its origin, the story imagines a painter making use of surfaces familiar in Venice.

Michelangelo gives the sculptors’ side a hearing in his letter to Varchi. He says he used to rank sculpture higher because painting was judged better when it approached relief. After reading Varchi, he accepts that the two arts can be considered equivalent because they share an aim. Reflections don’t give you a body, only more pictures of one, and a mirror image of a man’s front is still a flat image you can’t put your hand around. On that view Giorgione’s trick is a party piece that changes the rules of the bet instead of winning it, swapping “can you show the whole body” for “can you show many views of it.”

I think that change of question is the real victory, though, and Pater sees it. The anecdote gives painting its own kind of completeness. Reflected light holds many aspects of the figure in one instant. So the mirror doesn’t make a painting compete with sculpture on sculpture’s terms. It moves the contest onto painting’s ground, where the prize is the moment, and in that sense Pater’s “solving” is a little too strong while his “momentary” is exactly right, since the solution exists only for the instant the water is still. That’s a fair image of Giorgione’s whole art as Pater sees it, a beauty that depends on everything holding still for one breath.

Test your understanding

123

Question 1 of 3

According to the article, what is the main advantage a painter gains by arranging reflections rather than placing actual mirrors beside a statue?

Choose one answer

Guided Inquiry

Questions for Socrates

Explore these questions with Socrates, with this Feature as your reading context.