Philosophy

Good for Everyone, Whoever Wins

Socrates asks who benefits when the truth becomes clearer. His answer leaves room for the person whose claim had to be corrected.

In the wrestling school, a refutation can cost someone standing. Socrates asks Critias to consider the good that both of them could take away.

Orientation

At a Glance

  • A good both can shareSocrates asks Critias to consider how both speakers could benefit if the inquiry makes the matter clearer.
  • Jefferson’s candleJefferson compares sharing an idea to lighting another person’s candle from your own. Both people can have the light.
  • The audience makes a differenceSocrates says Critias hides his perplexity before the company. A correction can be valuable even when receiving it in public is difficult.
  • A benefit for later readersThe dialogue leaves temperance undefined, but readers can still learn which assumptions made the proposed account difficult to defend.

Charmides 154b–c, 166c–d, 166d–e, 169c–d, 175b–d · Gorgias 505c–e, 505e–506c · Thomas Jefferson, letter to Isaac McPherson 13 August 1813

Critias thinks he’s being set up to lose. Socrates has asked what temperance knows, and Critias accuses him of trying to refute him while letting go of the subject. Socrates asks whether it’s a common good “that each of the things that are should become plain, as it really is.” Critias agrees. Then Socrates asks him to answer as things seem to him and attend to what happens to the argument, whoever is being refuted. For that request to work, they have to agree about what would be worth taking away from the encounter.

Imagine two colleagues looking over a calculation before it goes into a report. One points out that a column was added twice. The person who spotted it gains something, since they now understand how the error arose. The person who made the mistake gains something too, especially if there’s still time to correct it. If the person who spotted it can show how to check the sum, both of them can follow the correction and use it later. What either colleague learns is still available to the other.

Thomas Jefferson gives this idea a physical image in an 1813 letter to Isaac McPherson. He’s writing about exclusive claims to inventions. A person can light a candle from mine, he says, and receive light without darkening my flame. He’s talking about the way an idea can pass from one person to another. The image fits a truth discovered in conversation, too. If you learn why the sum is wrong, your understanding leaves mine intact. You may be able to show a third person where the error was, and the knowledge can travel farther than the first exchange.

Now picture the same correction with the person’s reputation on the line. The useful information is exactly the same. Its public arrival changes what the person who made the mistake has to reckon with. Socrates says Critias catches his perplexity like a yawn, then covers it up because he’s accustomed to being admired and feels ashamed before the company. We have Socrates’s account of the moment. The story he tells lets us see why a correction could be valuable to both people and still be difficult for one of them to welcome.

Socrates makes a similar appeal in the Gorgias. Callicles has asked him to question somebody else, then suggests he could go through the argument by himself. Socrates says it’s a common good to make clear what’s true and what’s false. He invites the listeners to challenge him if he agrees with himself about something mistaken. He even tells Callicles that if Callicles refutes him, he’ll count him as his greatest benefactor. The others can do something for the inquiry even when one partner has stopped answering in the usual way.

There’s a harder test of the candle image. A correction may take away a belief without giving the person a complete answer to put in its place. That’s what happens in the Charmides. By the end Socrates and Critias can see difficulties with their proposed account of temperance, but the conversation hasn’t told them what temperance is. Someone reading the dialogue can still benefit from seeing where they got stuck. It can save the next person from relying on an assumption that looked safe the first time through.

Socrates has already said that he examines the argument for his own sake and perhaps for his friends. The form of the dialogue makes that second possibility easy to imagine. Socrates speaks to someone outside the conversation he’s recounting. We’re allowed to hear what he says to that listener, including his own account of where the inquiry came apart. We can try the reasoning for ourselves even though we were never in the wrestling school. The benefit he imagines in speaking with Critias can extend beyond the company that watched them.

The striking thing about Socrates’s appeal is how early it comes. Critias has just accused him of picking a fight. The argument still has a long way to go before either of them can see what the inquiry will yield. Socrates asks Critias to leave room for a good they could share when they find it. They don’t get all the way to the answer they want, but their failure has become something a reader can examine. That much light has made it out of the room.

Test your understanding

123

Question 1 of 3

What does the article identify as the central tension in Critias’s response to correction?

Choose one answer

Guided Inquiry

Questions for Socrates

Explore these questions with Socrates, with this Feature as your reading context.