Renaissance

Fruit That Wouldn’t Fool a Bird

Luca della Robbia gives his glazed fruit the colors of real fruit, then softens them. Pater finds the art of the garland in that small change.

Pliny’s painted grapes and Palissy’s cast creatures give two ways to think about convincing imitation. Luca’s fruit follows another logic, drawing attention to its form while leaving room for what it frames.

Orientation

At a Glance

  • A painting can fool the eyePliny’s Zeuxis paints grapes that attract birds. Parrhasius wins by painting a curtain that fools the painter himself.
  • Luca lets the fruit look madePater notices that Luca uses recognizable colors and softens them slightly. His fruit keeps its form without becoming a trick of the eye.
  • A garland gives attention back to its centerThe wreath on René of Anjou’s coat of arms surrounds another subject. Its shapes and colors can honor that subject without taking over.
  • Glazed clay can go much furtherPalissy made casts of plants and animals to turn plates into lifelike scenes. The comparison shows how many different effects a ceramic glaze can produce.

Some of the most famous grapes in art survive only in Pliny’s Natural History. Zeuxis paints them so convincingly that birds fly down to the display. His rival Parrhasius then beats him with a painted curtain that fools Zeuxis himself, and the whole idea of art as a magic trick played on the eyeball gets its origin myth. Luca della Robbia, who spent most of the fifteenth century in Florence turning clay into glazed sculpture, made a lot of fruit too, and I’d bet my lunch that no bird ever went for one of his lemons. Pater thinks that’s exactly the point, and he packs the reason into one quiet sentence about his garlands.

“Luca loved the forms of various fruits, and wrought them into all sorts of marvellous frames and garlands, giving them their natural colours, only subdued a little, a little paler than nature.” Read it slowly, because it doesn’t say what you’d expect from the rest of the essay, where Luca’s color is mostly a matter of white figures on a flat blue ground that nobody would mistake for skin or sky. Here Pater says the fruit gets its natural colors, which means that in the garland Luca pays close attention to familiar colors, and the whole art of it lives in the qualifier that follows. The colors are “subdued a little,” and then, as if he wants to be sure we register how small the adjustment is, Pater says it again with “a little paler than nature,” which is the tiniest possible margin and a margin all the same.

You can see what he means in one of the grandest of Luca’s garlands to survive, the coat of arms (the Italian word is stemma) made for King René of Anjou and now in the Victoria and Albert Museum in London, which is about eleven feet across. Its border is a wreath of fruit, leaves and pine cones in several colors. The scale alone was a technical challenge. The V&A notes that the clay was cut into pieces to fit the kiln, then reassembled after firing. That’s a real palette, and it matters, because it shows the softness of the fruit wasn’t forced on a workshop that only owned two colors, so the oranges could have been louder if anyone had wanted them louder.

So why hold back, and the answer starts with the words Pater picks, because these are “frames and garlands,” things whose job is to go around something else. A frame has the odd task of being looked at without being looked at, a bit like a film score that drops a few decibels whenever an actor speaks, and a garland at full natural strength would start shouting over the Madonna or the coat of arms it’s supposed to honor. The fruit circles the heraldic design as a wreath. The arrangement lets it suggest plenty without asking us to look at each piece as if it were for sale. Paling the colors keeps the fruit in that register, where an orange stands for abundance and good fortune instead of inviting you to check whether it’s ripe.

The best way to see what Pater’s “little” protects is to look at an artist who refused it. The French potter Bernard Palissy made platters crawling with snakes, lizards, frogs and fish, using casts taken from real specimens, all set in glossy colored glazes so that each dish looks like a pond frozen mid-wriggle. In 1851 the Minton firm showed a revival called “Palissy ware” at the Great Exhibition in London, and over the following decades glazed lizards and fish slithered across a great many Victorian sideboards, so Pater’s readers had a Victorian example of how far glazed clay could take naturalistic ornament. It’s an amazing trick and also a little much, because at full strength the glaze stops being a pleasure and turns into a dare, the dish daring you to put a potato down next to the snake.

The della Robbia shop itself eventually drifted toward the louder option. The glazed garland around the Bartolini Salimbeni arms, attributed to a younger Luca della Robbia, crowds its border with fruits, plants and seedpods in vivid colors. It’s gorgeous, and it’s also a farmers’ market, with every item asking for your attention at the same volume, so the frame stops framing and turns into the main event.

There’s one more reason the paleness works, and Pater tucks it into the start of his sentence, where Luca “loved the forms of various fruits” before a word is said about their colors. Luca was a sculptor before he was anything else, a man whose life Pater says had no excitement “except what belongs to the trial of new artistic processes,” and for a sculptor the pleasure of a lemon is its swelling, dimpled shape and the way a pine cone’s scales catch the light one ridge at a time. Strong color can make the eye stop at a patch of orange. A softer tone gives the modeling and its small shadows more room to guide the eye around the fruit. The glaze gives the fruit a shine and a permanence that no real orange ever had, but the paling keeps the hand of the modeler visible underneath it.

So I think Pater’s phrase is the best description anyone has written of these garlands, and it also works as a rule worth keeping, which says that art may borrow nature’s colors as long as it pays a small tax on them. Zeuxis paid no tax at all and fooled the birds, and the later workshop paid so little that its garlands look like harvest festivals, while Luca paid just enough and got in return a kind of fruit you can enjoy without wanting to eat it. That’s the whole difference between ornament and a grocery display, and it’s why I’d hang one of Luca’s wreaths over a doorway long before the Bartolini garland, since his fruit leaves room for whatever it surrounds.

Test your understanding

123

Question 1 of 3

Why does the author consider the King René coat of arms evidence that Luca deliberately softened the fruit’s colors?

Choose one answer

Guided Inquiry

Questions for Socrates

Explore these questions with Socrates, with this Feature as your reading context.