Greek Antiquity

From Mixed Through Everything to Ruling Everything

Three reasons in the hymn to Hera move from living by the air to being ruled by the goddess mixed through it.

The hymn calls Hera the wife of Zeus and gives her another basis for rule. Its linked reasons move through dependence on air, participation in everything, and sovereignty.

Orientation

At a Glance

  • The hymn gives reasonsThree successive lines begin with the Greek word gar, meaning “for”, and explain how the titles relate to each other.
  • Nothing lives apart from HeraThe first reason connects the goddess with the conditions that make life possible.
  • She shares in all thingsThe second reason says that Hera is blended with the air and takes part in everything.
  • Her presence gives her powerThe last reason makes her mistress of all, and the article reads that claim as a consequence of her presence throughout the world.

Orphic Hymns, XVI.1–10, with the notes on XVI.1, 6 and XVI.5–7; X.9

Most of the hymns in this collection are long strings of titles with a request at the end, but in the middle of the hymn to Hera something different happens. Three lines in a row begin with gar, “for,” the little Greek word that introduces a reason. “For apart from you nothing at all has known the nature of life; / for you share in all things, blended with the august air; / for you alone have power over all and are mistress of all.” The edition’s note calls it “the closest thing to an argument in the block,” and adds, with a slight raise of the eyebrow, that what it argues is that nothing lives without air, “which the hymn treats as a reason to pray.” It’s worth following that argument step by step, because it does more than it seems to.

The first step is dependence, and it’s the easiest of the three to grant. Nothing has ever known the nature of life apart from Hera, which, if Hera is the air, simply means that nothing breathes without air and nothing lives without breathing. That’s a claim any Greek would grant, and it puts every living thing in her debt at a stroke. Notice that the reason given for calling on her isn’t a past favor or a sacrifice already made, the way the priest Chryses in the Iliad reminds Apollo of all the thighbones he has burned for him, since the reason here is her nature. You call on Hera because you can’t live a single minute without her, which is a more fundamental claim on a worshipper than any record of past gifts.

The second step is participation, and it’s the hinge of the whole chain. “You share in all things,” koinōneis, “blended with the august air,” so she isn’t only what living things depend on, she’s inside everything, mixed through it the way water is mixed into wine. The word is the same family as the one the hymn to Nature used for the opposite claim, that Nature is “alone sharing with none,” and the contrast is sharp. Nature stands apart as the source of everything, while Hera is present in everything as an ingredient, so the two hymns give two quite different pictures of how a god can be universal, standing behind the world or running all through it.

The third step is rule, and it’s the one that needs explaining. “You alone have power over all and are mistress of all,” and the question is how the poem gets there from mixing. The answer, I think, is that whatever is present in everything has a hold on everything from the inside. An old Greek thinker, Anaximenes, is reported to have said that just as our soul, being air, holds us together, so breath and air encompass the whole world, and the same intuition runs through the Stoics, for whom a fine breath pervading all bodies is what holds them together. Something that holds every body together from within is, in the most literal sense, in charge of it. Anyone who has lived with roommates knows the person who controls the Wi-Fi runs the house, and the air is the world’s Wi-Fi.

What makes the chain interesting is what it replaces. Line 2 has already given Hera her royal status in the traditional way, “Hera queen of all, blessed bedfellow of Zeus,” queen because she is the king’s wife. The note observes that apart from that title and the marriage phrase, “nothing in the hymn touches Hera’s myths,” no jealousy, no Herakles, no quarrels on Olympus. And the argument of lines 5 to 7 grounds her rule somewhere else entirely, in her presence in all things. By the time you reach “mistress of all,” her power no longer depends on her husband at all, since it follows from what she is.

The line that closes the argument keeps the picture moving. She is “shaken with airy rushings throughout the stream,” so the air that pervades everything is also in constant motion, gusting and flowing, which fits a mistress who is everywhere at once and never still. Then comes the request, and it’s strikingly modest after so much reasoning, “may you come with favour, rejoicing, with a fair face.” The worshippers don’t ask for anything specific, no harvest or health or safe voyage, and instead they ask the goddess who is already in every breath to be present kindly, which makes sense, because you can’t really ask air to come, only to come gently.

That modesty is part of why the argument works as prayer rather than as a lecture. A philosopher who proved that the air rules everything would stop there, satisfied, but the hymn uses the proof as a reason to address the air as a person and ask for her goodwill. A Christian reader may hear an echo in Paul’s speech at Athens, where he tells the philosophers that in God “we live, and move, and have our being,” quoting a Greek poet to make the point. In both cases the claim that a divine presence runs through everything is not the end of thought but the start of a relationship, a reason to speak to that presence rather than only about it.

My verdict is that the three clauses make a real argument, short but complete, moving from dependence to participation to sovereignty, and that its key step is the second one, where being mixed through everything becomes the ground for ruling everything, because what holds all things together from within has power over all of them. The chain quietly moves Hera’s queenship from her marriage to her nature, so that she rules as the air rather than as Zeus’s wife, and the hymn then turns its own proof into a humble request, asking the power in every breath simply to come with a fair face.

Test your understanding

123

Question 1 of 3

Why does the author call participation the “hinge” of the hymn’s argument?

Choose one answer

Guided Inquiry

Questions for Socrates

Explore these questions with Socrates, with this Feature as your reading context.