Renaissance
From a Cardinal’s Hands to a Mother’s Knees
Rossellino attends to a cardinal’s hands and feet. Michelangelo gives Christ’s body the same close attention while leaving room for the mother to look up.
The Renaissance (1893)Pater finds a tradition of tender looking in a Florentine tomb and Michelangelo’s Pietà. The details that carry grief also complicate his claim that the grief is hopeless.
Orientation
At a Glance
- The epitaph holds two kinds of distinctionThe young cardinal’s tomb remembers his appearance and his modesty. Pater sees that pairing in the care Rossellino gives to the body and its clothing.
- Looking closely becomes a form of pityPater imagines Florentines leaning over the dead until their features seem quiet. He connects that attention with Michelangelo’s treatment of a grieving mother.
- An upward gesture changes the questionIn the Colonna Pietà design, Mary raises her hands while Christ’s body remains directly before her. The movement leaves room to read a response beyond grief.
- The comparison crosses regionsMasaccio’s skeleton belongs to Florence, and Rogier’s grieving figures belong to a northern tradition. Their works show how easily the kinds of looking Pater separates can coexist.
The Renaissance · The Poetry of Michelangelo, pp. 64–65, Florence and the Portuguese cardinal · The Poetry of Michelangelo, note 164 · The Poetry of Michelangelo, note 165 · The Poetry of Michelangelo, pp. 65–66, pity and the drawing at Oxford
In August 1459 a young prince of the Portuguese royal house, James of Lusitania, a young cardinal, died while staying in Florence, and a chapel was made for his tomb at San Miniato al Monte, up on the hill across the river. His epitaph, Pater notes with some delight, “dares to say” insignis formâ fui et mirabili modestiâ, which means I was remarkable in appearance and of wonderful modesty. That’s a bold thing to carve on a tomb, since it boasts about a dead man’s looks in the same breath as his humility, and Pater uses it to open one of his most moving arguments, about how Florentines of the fifteenth century learned to look at the dead.
The chapel brought the work of several Florentine artists into one small room. Antonio Rossellino carved the tomb in the early 1460s, and Pater praises his “care for the shapely hands and feet, and sacred attire,” the young man lying on his bier as if asleep, every fold of his vestments worked out. Luca della Robbia covered the ceiling with glazed terracotta roundels of the four cardinal virtues around the dove of the Holy Spirit, the Pollaiuolo brothers painted the altarpiece, and the whole ensemble became, in Pater’s words, “the strangest and most beautiful thing in that strange and beautiful place.” It’s death treated as an occasion for beauty, with nothing hidden and nothing grim.
Pater’s explanation is that great Florentines from Dante to Savonarola were preoccupied with death and thought that preoccupation dignifying, and that the sorrows of their time kept it vivid. He mentions la bella Simonetta (the beautiful Simonetta), who died young and was “borne to the grave with uncovered face,” and then he gives the key image. “They must often have leaned over the lifeless body, when all was at length quiet and smoothed out,” and seen that after death “only the abstract lines remain, in a great indifference.” Close, patient attention to a beautiful dead face is the habit he’s tracing, and he thinks it ends in pity.
That pity, he says, reaches its height in Michelangelo, whose favorite subject is the Pietà, “the pity of the Virgin Mother over the dead body of Christ, expanded into the pity of all mothers over all dead sons.” He describes “a drawing of his at Oxford, in which the dead body has sunk to the earth between the mother’s feet, with the arms extended over her knees.” A related design is the Pietà for Vittoria Colonna, known in Michelangelo’s finished Boston drawing and in later versions. In that design Christ stands between Mary’s knees with his arms supported, while she raises her hands and looks upward.
That raised gesture is where Pater’s account starts to wobble. He calls Michelangelo’s treatment of the subject “a hopeless, rayless, almost heathen sorrow,” mere pity and awe “at the stiff limbs and colourless lips.” Yet the mother in that very design is looking upward, which can be read as an appeal beyond the body before her, and the marble Pietà in Saint Peter’s, carved when Michelangelo was in his twenties, shows a Christ so unmarked and serene that grief and calm sit together. The sorrow in these works is deep, but “hopeless” is Pater’s word, and the figures keep pointing past the body he wants them to stop at. A mother who looks up can seem to be asking for something, and that expectation is exactly what Pater’s word “rayless” leaves out of the picture.
The other half of his claim is that this tender pity was distinctively Florentine. He contrasts it with “the Danse Macabre of many French and German painters,” with “the grim inventions of Dürer,” and with the gloom of Rhine villages and crowded medieval Paris, and the contrast has something to it. The Dance of Death at the Holy Innocents cemetery in Paris and the cadaver on Cardinal Jean de La Grange’s monument at Avignon make death visible in very different ways. Next to that, Rossellino’s sleeping cardinal really does look like a different idea of death.
But Florence had its skeletons too, and some of them were famous. In Santa Maria Novella, Masaccio painted the Trinity in the 1420s with a skeleton lying on a tomb below it and an inscription that says, more or less, I was once what you are, and what I am you will be. And the north had its tenderness, since Rogier van der Weyden’s Descent from the Cross, shows the Virgin collapsing in a faint that mirrors the pose of her dead son. Both cities knew the macabre and the pitiful, so the real Florentine signature lies in which one they built their monuments around, and in a habit of finding the dead body beautiful before mourning it. Florence preferred to carve its dead asleep rather than rotting, but it never stopped reminding itself what lay under the marble.
So here’s my verdict on the line Pater draws. He has found a genuine line of descent, from Rossellino’s lovingly carved hands to the arms of Christ lying across his mother’s knees, and it’s a line of looking closely and tenderly at a body after death. He overstates it twice, though, once by making it uniquely Florentine when Florence painted skeletons and Flanders painted pity, and once by calling Michelangelo’s version hopeless when his mothers keep raising their eyes. The tradition he describes is pity that looks hard at the dead without looking away, and in Michelangelo’s hands it never stops looking up as well.
Test your understanding
Question 1 of 3
Why does the author think Mary’s upward gaze complicates Pater’s description of Michelangelo’s sorrow as “hopeless” and “rayless”?
Guided Inquiry
Questions for Socrates
Explore these questions with Socrates, with this Feature as your reading context.
- What features of a monument might make death appear beautiful without minimizing its reality or sorrow?→
- How does the contrast between looking closely at the dead body and looking upward shape the article’s interpretation of pity?→
- When does identifying a regional artistic tendency become an unfair claim of cultural uniqueness?→