Renaissance
Freedom Grown in the Church’s Own Garden
Abelard’s learning grows from inside the Church. Pater’s later example of Aucassin puts that idea under pressure.
The Renaissance (1893)Pater describes some medieval freedoms as possibilities already present in Christianity and others as revolt against its boundaries. Abelard’s theological method and Aucassin’s choice of company in the afterlife test how far a single account can stretch.
Orientation
At a Glance
- Freedom from inside the systemPater says Abelard reached ways of thinking and living that exceeded the Church’s prescribed limits. He also suggests that the possibilities were present within Christianity.
- Abelard reads authorities togetherIn the prologue to Sic et Non, Abelard sets out how to read apparently conflicting authorities. He asks readers to examine language and context before deciding what the conflict means.
- Pater also describes revoltLater in the chapter Pater describes imaginative and sensual rebellion. He places Franciscan mysticism and Joachim’s vision of a new age beside more openly defiant examples.
- Aucassin tests the distinctionAucassin chooses the company he loves even if it means hell. His answer tests whether Pater’s account of freedom growing within the Church can also explain open refusal.
The Renaissance · Two Early French Stories, pp. 10–11 · Two Early French Stories, pp. 20–21 · Two Early French Stories, note 47 · Two Early French Stories, note 48 · Two Early French Stories, p. 22
Pater’s first picture of the conflict is surprisingly gentle. The Renaissance, he says, is a movement “in which, in various ways, the human mind wins for itself a new kingdom of feeling and sensation and thought, not opposed to but only beyond and independent of the spiritual system then actually realised.” The phrase “not opposed to but only beyond” is doing a lot of work, because it says the new freedom isn’t a war on Christianity but an expansion past its current borders. And he adds a still more striking clause about Abelard, that he “reaches out towards, he attains, modes of ideal living, beyond the prescribed limits of that system, though in essential germ, it may be, contained within it.”
Pater locates the conflict not between Christianity and paganism but inside the Church, between two kinds of people. On one side are “the merely professional, official, hireling ministers of that system, with their ignorant worship of system for its own sake,” and on the other “the true child of light, the humanist, with reason and heart and senses quick, while theirs were almost dead.” The vocabulary is biblical, since the hireling is the bad shepherd of John’s Gospel who runs when the wolf comes, and the children of light are the faithful in Paul and in Luke. Pater is criticizing the Church’s officials in the Church’s own language, which already suggests that the freedom he has in mind grows from inside.
The history backs this up to a surprising degree. Abelard was a cleric and later a monk, trained in the cathedral schools of the Church, and his method of setting conflicting authorities side by side was a tool for theological inquiry. In the prologue to Sic et Non, he asks readers to examine the wording and the circumstances before deciding whether authorities truly disagree. The institution condemned him twice, once making him burn his own book on the Trinity, but setting authorities alongside one another remained part of scholastic theology. Peter Lombard’s Sentences gathered authorities into a system and often supplied resolutions where Abelard left the work of interpretation to readers. The two books show related tools being used for different ends.
Now turn to Pater’s later account, a dozen pages on, and the tone changes completely. One of the strongest characteristics of the medieval Renaissance, he says there, was “its antinomianism, its spirit of rebellion and revolt against the moral and religious ideas of the time.” The edition’s note explains that the word comes from the Greek for “against” and “law.” People, Pater says, were driven “beyond the bounds of the Christian ideal,” and their love became “a strange rival religion,” the return of Venus from her hiding place in the mountain. That sounds a long way from “not opposed to,” and the shift in tone is too large to be an accident of phrasing. The same medieval spirit that was quietly growing past a fence on one page is storming the gate on another.
Does the distinction between an institution and its unused possibilities explain this later rebellion too? Partly, and the examples Pater gives show how far it reaches. He names the Franciscan order, with its poetry and mysticism, as “from the point of view of religious authority, justly suspect,” and he names Joachim of Fiore, a Calabrian abbot whose vision of an age of the Holy Spirit Pater reads as a promise that law would pass away. Both are Christian through and through, a saint’s order and an abbot’s prophecy, and both press against the Church’s official structures using the Church’s own deepest ideas, so for them the distinction works perfectly. Francis’s order took Gospel poverty as an ideal, and Joachim read the Trinity as a pattern for history.
But Pater’s star example breaks it, since his most famous expression of the rebellious spirit is Aucassin, the young hero of Aucassin and Nicolette, who, threatened with hell if he takes Nicolette as his mistress, says he’d rather go to hell with the good scholars, the fine knights and the fair courteous ladies than to paradise with the worn-out old priests at the altar. That isn’t an unused possibility of the Church but a cheerful preference for the other side, a love that would rather be damned in good company, and no amount of germ-within-the-system talk turns it into a hidden Christian potential.
So Pater really runs two models of the medieval Renaissance, and the book slides between them. In one, the freedom is the Church’s own seed growing past the fence its officials built, and it fits Abelard, Francis and Joachim. In the other, the freedom is a rival religion, Venus returning from exile, and it fits Aucassin, Tannhäuser and the pagan gods hiding in disguise. Pater even tips his hand when he says the Franciscans were “justly” suspect from authority’s point of view, which concedes that from inside the system some of this freedom really did look like opposition, and maybe was.
My verdict is that intellectual freedom can and often does grow from within the system it exceeds, and that Pater’s distinction between an institution and its unused possibilities is one of the best ideas in the chapter, illustrated by the continuing use of related methods in scholastic theology. But the distinction explains only half of his later account of medieval rebellion. The other half is a genuine revolt of the senses, a rival love with its own gods, and Pater, who is drawn to both halves, never quite decides which one his Renaissance really is. A Christian reader can take real comfort from the first model, which finds the seeds of freedom in the faith itself, while noticing that Pater keeps the second model close at hand for the moments when he wants the old gods back.
Test your understanding
Question 1 of 3
Which distinction best captures the two models of the medieval Renaissance that the article finds in Pater?
Guided Inquiry
Questions for Socrates
Explore these questions with Socrates, with this Feature as your reading context.
- If freedom grows from ideas already present within a tradition, at what point—if any—does its development become opposition to that tradition?→
- How does Pater’s use of biblical language to criticize Church officials complicate the boundary between religious faith and rebellion?→
- Does the coexistence of Pater’s two models make his account inconsistent, or does it offer a more accurate picture of intellectual and cultural change?→