Greek Antiquity

Four Founders for One Set of Mysteries

The Nereids, Kouretes, Muses, and Themis each receive credit for bringing rites to mortals.

Four hymns describe the origins of initiation through the powers they praise. The article puts their competing claims side by side and asks what being first means in a hymn.

Orientation

At a Glance

  • The Nereids show forth the Bacchic riteTheir hymn gives the sea goddesses priority in revealing the rite of Bakchos and Phersephoneia.
  • The Kouretes establish a rite among mortalsThe armed dancers receive their own claim to priority in the hymn that places them on Samothrace.
  • The Muses and Themis add two accountsThe Muses show rites to mortals, while Themis receives credit for revealing Bacchic rites.
  • Three hymns use the word firstThe article reads the repeated claim of priority as praise directed to the particular goddesses or gods being addressed.

Ask Americans where the first Thanksgiving happened and most will say Plymouth in 1621, but Virginia’s Berkeley Plantation holds a festival of its own on the strength of a day of thanks its settlers kept in 1619, and St. Augustine in Florida points to a meal shared with the Timucua in 1565. Every place that wants to be the beginning has a story to prove it, and the Orphic hymns have the same problem with their own rites. Four hymns say that someone first gave the mysteries to mortals, and the someone changes every time, so the edition’s note at the Nereids hymn sums it up as “Four aetiologies of the rite, none aware of the others.” The question is whether a single book of mysteries can hold four beginnings without contradicting itself.

It helps to set the four side by side, because the differences are as telling as the overlap. The Nereids get the boldest claim, “for you were the first to show forth the august rite / of well-hallowed Bakchos and of holy Phersephoneia,” and the Kouretes, the armed dancers who in this hymn live on Samothrace, hear “you too were the first to establish the rite among men.” The Muses are credited more modestly as the goddesses “who showed forth to mortals the rites that initiates perform,” without the word first, while Themis gets it outright, “for you first revealed the consecrated rites to mortals, / crying euhoi to the lord through the Bacchic nights.” The notes add a detail that rules out the easy fix, which is that none of these lines carries an apparatus entry, so there’s no manuscript trouble to blame and no editor’s hand to undo.

A harmonizer can make a decent case that these are roles in one story rather than rival origins. The verbs differ, since the Nereids and the Muses showed forth, Themis revealed and the Kouretes established, and you could build a division of labor out of that, with Themis as the law behind the rite, the one who “taught the lord Phoibos the giving of ordinances,” the Kouretes as the founders who set it up, the Nereids as the ones who first put it on display and the Muses as its teachers. The objects differ too, a single rite in two places and plural rites in the other two, so you might say the hymns are describing different pieces of one larger whole, the way a cathedral can have an architect, a builder and a first bishop.

The trouble is the word first, which three of the four claims use and which doesn’t share well. Two founders can’t each be the first, and the claims overlap where it counts, since the Nereids’ rite is the rite of Bakchos and Phersephone and Themis’s rites are kept through the Bacchic nights, which puts them on the same ground. It’s tempting to hear the Kouretes’ too as a polite nod to other founders, but it reads more naturally as adding the founding to the list of services in the line before it, where they ward off the dangers of sailors. The note on the Kouretes calls rival claims of this kind “a commonplace” and adds that the Nereids’ claim has no company it can find outside this book, “which makes XXIV, not this hymn, the odd one.”

The ancient world was full of such claims, and the writers who collected them made no effort to reconcile them either. Diodorus gives initiation rites to the Idaean Daktyls, whom Strabo identifies with the Kouretes, and he credits the Samothracian mysteries to Iasion, while the most famous claimant of all is one these hymns never name in that role. In Aristophanes’ Frogs the dead Aeschylus says that Orpheus taught us the rites and taught us to keep our hands from killing, and Diodorus adds that Orpheus studied with the Daktyls and was the first to bring rites and mysteries to the Greeks. So the hymn book that circulated under Orpheus’s name, which opens with the singer telling his pupil “Learn now, Musaeus, a rite of sacrifice wholly august,” hands the founding of the rite to four other parties and never once claims it for him.

Christians live with a version of this every Sunday, because the four Gospels begin in four different places, Mark at the Jordan with John the Baptist, Matthew with a genealogy, Luke with a priest serving in the Temple and John with the Word in the beginning. In the second century Tatian wove them into a single narrative, the Diatessaron, and Syriac churches read it for generations, until fifth-century bishops, Theodoret among them, gathered up the copies and put the four separate Gospels back in their place. The church decided that four beginnings were worth more than one tidy one, because each was a witness speaking in its own voice. A harmony is easier to read, but it puts the editor’s seams where the witnesses had their own.

A hymn book, though, has a simpler reason to keep its four beginnings, which is that nobody sings it all at once. Each hymn is spoken to one power at one moment, with its own incense, and while it lasts the power addressed is the one that matters most. The scholar Max Müller noticed the same habit in the Vedic hymns, where each god in turn is praised as though he were the highest, and he coined the word henotheism for it. First in these hymns works like that, as a title of honor offered to the power in front of you, and Themis’s hymn goes straight on to say “for from you come the honours of the blessed and the holy mysteries,” which is praise on the same scale and every bit as exclusive.

My verdict is that these are distinct accounts and not a single story with a cast list, since the shared word first and the shared Bacchic rite rule out a tidy division of labor, but the collection holds them without strain because a hymn’s first is praise spoken to the god being addressed, true for as long as that hymn is being sung. The worshippers who used this book thanked the sea, the dancers of Samothrace, the Muses and Themis in turn, and they never needed to settle who came first. What they never did, oddly, is give the credit to the singer whose name the book carries, and that may be the most Orphic thing about it, since a singer who hands the founding to the gods is saying the rite was never a human invention.

Test your understanding

123

Question 1 of 3

Why does the author ultimately reject the proposed “division of labor” among the Nereids, Muses, Kouretes, and Themis?

Choose one answer

Guided Inquiry

Questions for Socrates

Explore these questions with Socrates, with this Feature as your reading context.