Philosophy
Forget the Face
Chaerephon’s joke about a beautiful body gives Socrates a way to turn the conversation toward the soul.
The Platonic Dialogues: CharmidesChaerephon praises Charmides’ face and then announces that the boy’s body makes the face irrelevant. It’s a comic escalation, and it echoes the first steps of a ladder Plato describes in another dialogue.
Orientation
At a Glance
- The vanishing faceChaerephon praises Charmides’ face, then says the boy’s figure would make him seem faceless. The second compliment overtakes the first.
- Another kind of lookingSocrates borrows the language of undressing and asks to examine Charmides’ soul through conversation.
- Diotima’s ladderThe Symposium describes a movement from love of one body toward beauty in other bodies, souls, practices, knowledge, and finally beauty itself.
- An unsteady climbA glimpse inside the boy’s cloak upsets Socrates’ composure. He has to return to the conversation he proposed.
Chaerephon can’t help himself, and Plato gives us the whole exchange in three quick lines. “Well, Socrates, what do you think of the young man? Hasn’t he a lovely face?” he calls across the room, and Socrates answers, “Extraordinarily.” Then, without missing a beat, Chaerephon tops his own compliment with “And yet if he were willing to strip,” adding, “you’d think he had no face at all, his figure is so perfectly beautiful,” and the Greek word for that is aprosōpos, literally “faceless.” It’s the ancient equivalent of praising someone’s smile and then adding that you really need to see him at the beach.
The line is funny because it’s an escalation that cancels its own starting point. A second ago the face was the whole show, and now it’s nothing, wiped out by something even more spectacular, so the compliment devours itself, and the rest of the room chimes in with the same verdict, as if everyone were trying to outdo the last thing said. That’s the structure of attention in this opening scene, which never rests on what it’s just admired, because every admiration that seems complete immediately discovers something else that demands to be looked at, the way a scroll through a feed never stops at the post you just liked.
Then Socrates does the exact same thing one level higher. He grants that the boy would be unbeatable “if he has just one little thing more,” namely a soul that is well made, and proposes that they look at that before they look at the body. If the body can make the face disappear, Socrates is suggesting, the soul can make the body disappear, and he even borrows Chaerephon’s verb for undressing to say so. Chaerephon’s joke turns out to be the template for Socrates’ whole program, and the only change is the direction of the next step.
Plato wrote out the full version of this climb in the Symposium, where the priestess Diotima describes the ladder of love. A lover starts by loving one beautiful body, then realizes the same beauty shows up in all beautiful bodies and relaxes his obsession with the one, and then comes to value beauty in souls above beauty in bodies, after which he moves on to beautiful practices and laws, then to knowledge, and finally to beauty itself. Diotima’s point is that each rung teaches the lover to see the one below as smaller than he thought, so that what once seemed like everything comes to look like one example among many. In the Charmides we get the bottom of that ladder acted out in a gym, with Chaerephon going from face to body and Socrates stepping onto the next rung, from body to soul.
There’s a real difference between the two steps, though. Chaerephon’s escalation is more of the same kind of thing, since he goes from seeing part of a body to imagining all of it, and his eyes are still doing all the work. Socrates’ step is a change of kind, from something you can see to something you can only hear, because you can’t look at a soul, you can only talk to it, which is why his version of stripping turns into a conversation instead of a longer stare. It’s also why the soul can’t be rated the way Chaerephon rates the body, by calling across a room, since nobody can shout a verdict on someone’s soul from twenty feet away.
The scene is honest about how wobbly those first rungs are. Socrates proposes the soul-first plan with total confidence, and then the boy sits down next to him, Socrates catches a glimpse inside the cloak, and the body comes roaring back so hard that he says he “was on fire.” So the ladder isn’t an escalator that carries you up once you step on it. Socrates climbs a rung in words and slips off it in practice a few minutes later, and he has to climb back up the only way the next rung allows, by starting to talk. The narrator who just proposed to look at the soul first is the same man who then devotes his most vivid sentences to what he saw inside a cloak, so Plato isn’t pretending the climb is easy even for Socrates.
That makes the face that disappears a small lesson about where attention goes and how hard it is to keep it there. Diotima’s account in the Symposium makes the climb sound orderly, almost serene, while the Charmides shows what the bottom of the ladder actually feels like in a crowded room with a beautiful teenager on the bench. Restless attention keeps escalating no matter what, and the only question is whether it escalates toward more of the same body or toward something you can’t see, which is the choice Socrates makes and has to keep making. There’s something reassuring in that for the rest of us, since the dialogue doesn’t expect anyone to leave the body behind in a single leap.
My verdict is that Chaerephon accidentally points the scene in the right direction. His joke shows how admiration keeps reaching past whatever it has just praised, and Socrates simply aims that reach at the soul instead of at more skin. The Charmides keeps the body in plain view the whole time, which is Plato being honest about how hard the climb really is, and it reminds us that the first step up the ladder of love may begin with a guy in a gym shouting that the new kid is so hot you’d forget he had a face.
Test your understanding
Question 1 of 3
According to the article, how does Socrates transform the pattern established by Chaerephon’s compliment?
Guided Inquiry
Questions for Socrates
Explore these questions with Socrates, with this Feature as your reading context.
- If admiration repeatedly reaches beyond its current object, what might determine whether it moves toward “more of the same” or toward a different kind of value?→
- Why might conversation be a better way to encounter a soul than observation, and what limits might conversation itself have?→
- Does Socrates’ lapse after proposing to examine the soul weaken his philosophical ideal, or make that ideal more credible? Why?→