Greek Antiquity

Floor, Limit, Beginning

The hymn gives Nereus a place at the bottom of the sea and names him the beginning of all things.

A line moves from floor and limit to beginning. The roots of the deep help make the transition from a place that supports the world to a power that could come before it.

Orientation

At a Glance

  • Floor and limit mark a positionThe two opening nouns place Nereus at the bottom of the sea and at a boundary of the earth.
  • Roots carry two ideasThe hymn has already given him the roots of the deep, joining the lowest part of a thing to the place it grows from.
  • An older god of the waterHomer’s Okeanos and Hesiod’s account of Nereus offer different ways to imagine the priority of a sea power.
  • Beginning remains openThe line can suggest origin, seniority, or the supporting foundation on which other things depend.

Orphic Hymns, XXIII.1–4, with the note on XXIII.4

The hymn to Nereus begins at the bottom of everything. He is the god who holds “the roots of the deep, the dark-gleaming seat,” and three lines later he is given a string of three nouns with no adjective attached, “floor of the sea, limit of the earth, beginning of all things.” In Greek they are pythmēn, peras and archē, and the edition’s note puts the puzzle in two short sentences, “The words are spatial and the last is not, and the hymn does not choose.” A floor is a place and a limit is a place, but a beginning is a time, or an origin, or a principle, and the line moves from one to the other without a pause.

The first two nouns are straightforward geography, but each carries a little extra. Pythmēn is the bottom of a vessel or the base of a thing, the seabed that holds the whole weight of the water above it, and Homer uses the same word for the base of the sacred olive on Ithaca where Odysseus and Athena sit down to plot, so even the word for floor has a whiff of the tree’s stock about it. Peras is a limit or edge, and calling the sea-floor the “limit of the earth” imagines the land running down under the waves until it reaches its lowest boundary, the place where earth ends and the deep begins. Together they place Nereus at the very bottom and the very edge, the god of the lowest point in the world, where solid ground gives out and the sea rests on what’s left.

The first line has already prepared the slide into priority, though, with its image of roots. Nereus holds “the roots of the deep,” rhizas, and roots are both the lowest part of a plant and the part it grows from. That double meaning is the hinge of the whole passage. Something at the bottom, holding everything up, is naturally thought of as the foundation, and a foundation is easily thought of as the origin, what was there first and what everything else depends on. In the image of roots, position and priority are already the same thing, and the line of three nouns simply spells out the step.

Greek thought had good precedent for making the deep water a beginning. Homer twice calls Okeanos the origin of the gods and of all things, and Aristotle reports that Thales, the first philosopher, held that water was the principle of everything, archē, the very word the hymn uses. So “beginning of all things” for a sea god wasn’t a wild claim, it was drawing on both poetic and philosophical tradition. A Greek listener could hear in the hymn’s archē either Homer’s ancestral ocean or Thales’ watery first principle, and the hymn gives no signal which to prefer, which is exactly what the note means by saying it doesn’t choose.

Nereus himself brings a third kind of priority, the seniority of age. In Hesiod he is the eldest child of Pontos, the sea, the truthful old man of the deep, and later stories call him the Old Man of the Sea. So “beginning of all things” could also pick up his place as the senior figure of the sea’s family, first born and oldest, which is a priority of birth rather than of cosmic origin or principle. The hymn has three ways of being first available, foundation, origin and seniority, and its single word lets all three ring together, the way a bell struck once sounds several notes at the same time.

What remains open is how those ideas relate, and the hymn genuinely leaves it open. If Nereus is the beginning of all things in the sense of origin, he would be older than the gods who, in Hesiod, are his parents, which is a contradiction the hymn simply doesn’t address. If he is the beginning in the sense of foundation, the line makes good sense, since everything rests on the bottom, but then “beginning” is really another word for “floor.” And if he is the beginning as principle, like Thales’ water, the hymn is borrowing philosophy for a god it otherwise treats in mythological terms, so each reading works, and none is ruled out by anything the hymn says.

A Christian reader has a psalm that holds position and priority together in a similar way. Psalm 104 praises the God “who laid the foundations of the earth, that it should not be removed for ever,” and then says, “Thou coveredst it with the deep as with a garment,” so that the deep waters lie over the foundations at the beginning of the world. The psalm keeps God distinct from the foundations he laid, which the hymn does not do with Nereus, but both texts picture the bottom of the world as the place where the story starts, the deepest point and the first moment imagined together.

My verdict is that the line expands a description of position into a claim of priority through the bridge of the roots in its first line, since what holds the bottom of the world is easily heard as what came first and what everything rests on. The hymn draws on three kinds of firstness, foundation, cosmic origin and family seniority, and it lets one word, archē, carry them all without explaining how they fit, including the awkward fact that an origin of everything would be older than his own parents. That openness is the line’s strength, giving a sea god the full weight of the deep without pinning him to a single doctrine.

Test your understanding

123

Question 1 of 3

Why does the author treat the image of “roots” as the hinge of the hymn’s movement from place to priority?

Choose one answer

Guided Inquiry

Questions for Socrates

Explore these questions with Socrates, with this Feature as your reading context.