Philosophy

Flawless and Still Lost

Socrates imagines a world where every doctor, pilot, and prophet knows their work. Would all that expertise make us happy?

Socrates grants that genuine experts would make us healthier and safer. His dream asks what further knowledge would help us decide how to use those advantages.

Orientation

At a Glance

  • A dream of genuine expertiseSocrates imagines that anyone claiming a skill can be tested. Pilots, doctors, and generals who only pretend to know their work would be found out.
  • The practical gains are realSocrates grants that we’d be healthier, safer at sea and in war, and better equipped. He even lets genuine prophets see what’s coming.
  • A voyage still needs a purposeA pilot who can bring a ship safely to port has shown skill at navigation. Deciding whether the voyage is worth taking calls for a different judgment.
  • The question Critias must answerCritias eventually names knowledge of good and bad. That answer lets Socrates ask what kind of knowledge makes the rest of our abilities beneficial.

Charmides 171d–172a, 173a–c, 173c–174a, 174a–d · Homer, Odyssey 19.562–567 · Aristotle, Nicomachean Ethics 1.5 (1096a)

Socrates calls it his dream. He isn’t sure whether it came through the gate of horn, where Penelope says true dreams come from in the Odyssey, or the gate of ivory, which lets through dreams that mislead us. In it temperance rules us completely, so that no one who claimed to be a pilot “but was not, would deceive us, nor would any doctor or general or anyone else escape our notice who pretended to know what he did not know.” The result is a world run entirely by genuine experts. Socrates goes on to list everything he’s willing to grant such a world. His uncertainty about the gate gives us reason to listen carefully when he gets to happiness.

The list of grants is generous, since we would be “healthier in body than we are now,” we would “come through safe when in danger at sea and in war,” and our “equipment and clothing and our footwear, all of it,” would be expertly made, “because we would be using genuine craftsmen.” Then Socrates adds prophecy as a bonus, granting that temperance could weed out the fake prophets and leave us with true ones as “foretellers of the future.” He even sums up with a full concession, saying that the human race “would act and live knowledgeably, I grant,” since temperance would keep ignorance from slipping in to work beside us.

Then comes the break. Socrates says, “But that by acting knowledgeably we would do well and be happy, this, my dear Critias, we cannot yet learn.” Earlier, at 172a, the argument had moved from acting without error to doing well to being happy in two quick steps. Here Socrates slows it down. After granting so much, he still asks whether a life free of technical mistakes would be a good one.

Aristotle makes a similar point about wealth. In the Nicomachean Ethics he says wealth can’t be the good we’re looking for because it’s useful for getting something further. Health and safety matter in their own right, and we also value them for what they let us do. What a collection of advantages can’t tell you is which purposes are worth serving, any more than a perfect set of kitchen knives tells you what’s for dinner.

Each craft has its own standard for what counts as an error. The pilot knows how to bring the ship safely to port. Deciding whether the voyage is worth making calls for a different judgment. A world without technical error could still sail perfect courses to bad destinations and win wars that shouldn’t have been fought. A general can win a battle while leaving the justice of the war an open question.

A company can run every process flawlessly and still be making a product nobody should buy. A life can be expertly managed in every department and still be aimed at nothing that makes it worth living. Socrates’ dream describes a civilization of superb employees with no one in the room whose job is to ask what the company is for.

That’s also why the dream includes the prophets, which might seem like an odd addition. Prophecy adds something ordinary experts can’t offer, knowledge of what’s coming. Knowing what will happen tells you the consequences of your choices. Judging whether those consequences would be good for you is a further question. Prophecy is also where the conversation goes next. Socrates turns at once to a man who knows past, present, and future and asks which of his kinds of knowledge makes him happy.

My verdict is that Socrates’ refusal at 173d is the hinge of the dialogue’s final argument. Every genuine expert on his list can help us avoid a particular kind of error. Even their combined skills leave a question about what’s worth pursuing. When Critias finally names knowledge of good and bad, the conversation can ask directly how that judgment would help us use the other kinds of knowledge well.

Test your understanding

123

Question 1 of 3

Why does the author treat Socrates’ refusal at 173d as a turning point?

Choose one answer

Guided Inquiry

Questions for Socrates

Explore these questions with Socrates, with this Feature as your reading context.