Renaissance
Families Formed Across Centuries
Pater draws artistic families through shared qualities and affinities of feeling.
The Renaissance (1893)Winckelmann belongs to an earlier age in spirit, and Blake and Hugo help Pater explain Michelangelo centuries later. These pairings shape the book’s range by tracing affinities that a chronology or list of pupils would miss.
Orientation
At a Glance
- Belonging crosses datesPater includes Winckelmann because his enthusiasm makes him kin to Renaissance humanists.
- Pupils can miss the inheritanceMichelangelo’s followers copy his strength while overlooking the sweetness Pater finds in his predecessors.
- Later works can change an earlier readingBlake and Hugo bring aspects of Michelangelo into view, just as his art helps Pater understand theirs.
- Affinities need a basisThe comparisons are persuasive when they identify a quality shared across the works, such as strength held together with sweetness.
The Renaissance · Preface, Winckelmann belongs in spirit to an earlier age · Michelangelo, why the predecessors matter · Michelangelo, Blake and Hugo as his true sons · Winckelmann, the continuity of European culture · Winckelmann, Goethe encounters a passionate life · T. S. Eliot, Tradition and the Individual Talent · International Walter Pater Society, the editions of The Renaissance
The Preface explains Winckelmann’s presence in the book with a claim about belonging. He comes “in the eighteenth century,” but he “really belongs in spirit to an earlier age,” because his enthusiasm for the things of the intellect and the imagination puts him “in sympathy with the humanists of a previous century.” It’s a strange way to justify a chapter, since Winckelmann never met those humanists and learned nothing from them directly. Pater is placing him by temperament, the way you might say someone born in 1990 is really a child of the sixties, and the whole book’s range depends on placements of that kind.
The Michelangelo essay makes the method explicit, and it adds a twist. Pater says Michelangelo “must be approached, not through his followers, but through his predecessors,” earlier Tuscan artists such as the painter Luca Signorelli and the sculptor Mino da Fiesole. His professed disciples are excluded from the family, since they “are in love with his strength only, and seem not to feel his grave and temperate sweetness.” He even names their chief sign, “Theatricality,” a quality “as little attributable to Michelangelo as to Mino or Luca Signorelli.” So teaching isn’t enough to make someone family, and the people who studied under Michelangelo or copied his manner turn out to be strangers to him in the one way that matters.
Then Pater reaches forward across three centuries, which is the boldest move in the essay. The “strange interfusion of sweetness and strength,” he says, isn’t found in Michelangelo’s followers, “but it is found in many of those who worked before him, and in many others down to our own time, in William Blake, for instance, and Victor Hugo, who, though not of his school, and unaware, are his true sons.” The word “unaware” is the key to the whole idea, since Blake and Hugo didn’t set out to imitate Michelangelo, and Pater doesn’t claim they did, so the family is formed not by inheritance but by resemblance, like a musician who never heard an old blues record but sounds more like its singer than any of his students.
The Winckelmann essay shows how such a family can still involve real transmission, though not of the classroom kind. Winckelmann’s Hellenism reaches Goethe, Pater says, “not as in a book or a theory, but more importunately, because in a passionate life, in a personality.” What passes between them is a type of life, and Pater gives the family a literal child when he describes the art of the nineteenth century as the offspring of Goethe’s marriage of Faust and Helena, the beautiful boy Euphorion. The genealogy runs through personalities and marriages of spirit, not through lessons. Winckelmann himself, Pater says, was “infinitely less than Goethe,” and his importance lies partly in that contact, which makes him a parent valued for his child.
The same essay states the principle behind all this. “The history of art has suffered as much as any history by trenchant and absolute divisions,” Pater says, and the deeper view is the one “which preserves the identity of European culture,” in which “the Renaissance was an uninterrupted effort of the middle age, that it was ever taking place.” If the Renaissance is always happening, then its members can turn up in any century, and a family tree drawn by temperament is the natural way to map it. That’s how a book that starts in twelfth-century France can end in eighteenth-century Rome without feeling like a random anthology.
Pater also insists that these relations run both ways. Blake and Hugo, he says, “help us to understand him, as he in turn interprets and justifies them,” so the sons explain the father as much as the father explains the sons. That resembles an idea T. S. Eliot set out in his 1919 essay on tradition, that the great works of the past form an order among themselves which every genuinely new work slightly rearranges. In Pater’s version, reading Hugo changes how you see the Medici tombs, and seeing the tombs changes how you read Hugo, which is a claim about how influence works in the reader’s mind rather than in the history of workshops. The idea is familiar today from the way listeners discover an old band through a new one and then hear the new one differently, but Pater was making the point about Michelangelo in 1871.
The obvious danger is that kinship of feeling has no limits. If anyone can be anyone’s true son, the family tree turns into a mood board, and a critic can link whatever he likes. Pater’s safeguard against that danger is specificity, and he applies it carefully. Michelangelo’s family isn’t defined by “strength,” which his theatrical disciples had in abundance, but by a particular combination, strength with sweetness, “pleasure with surprise,” and only artists with both qualities get in. Winckelmann’s place depends on a named passion, the love of the intellect and the imagination “for their own sake.” The kinship is persuasive exactly where the shared quality is named precisely enough to exclude someone. Without a named quality, kinship becomes whatever the critic happens to feel, and Pater mostly avoids that trap.
So the book’s historical range takes its shape from relations of feeling rather than lines of instruction, a family drawn by temperament across centuries in which students can be strangers and strangers can be sons. The method works when Pater names the combination that defines a family and checks it against artists who fail it, and it would collapse into fancy without that check. At its best it does something a history of schools and pupils can’t, which is to show why a twelfth-century tale, a Florentine tomb and a nineteenth-century poem can belong in one book.
Test your understanding
Question 1 of 3
Why does Pater argue that Michelangelo should be approached through his predecessors rather than his professed followers?
Guided Inquiry
Questions for Socrates
Explore these questions with Socrates, with this Feature as your reading context.
- If direct instruction can produce artistic “strangers” while resemblance can produce “true sons,” what should count as the strongest evidence of artistic kinship?→
- How does viewing the Renaissance as an ongoing effort rather than a sharply bounded period change the way a history of art might be organized?→
- When later artists help readers reinterpret earlier ones, is that best understood as influence, interpretation, or a different kind of relationship? Why?→