Renaissance

Faint Hearing and the Smallest Interval

Music helps Pater describe both the Medici figures’ uncertainty and a Venetian painting’s precision.

For Pater, Michelangelo’s tomb figures suggest thoughts too faint to name, while a Giorgionesque picture can ask for the sharpest attention. Music explains both experiences because its form cannot be pulled apart from what it expresses.

Orientation

At a Glance

  • Titles leave something outPater finds the names of Michelangelo’s four reclining figures too definite for the feelings they suggest.
  • Form carries the meaningThe Giorgione essay uses music to explain how the subject and expression of an artwork can become inseparable.
  • Two kinds of listeningThe tombs lead Pater toward uncertainty, while the Venetian pictures reward attention to the smallest gesture or interval.
  • One principle fits bothAn indefinite form can express uncertainty as exactly as a carefully timed gesture can express a passing moment.

The first appeal to music comes in the sacristy of San Lorenzo. The four reclining figures on the Medici tombs are traditionally called Night and Day, Dawn and Dusk, and Pater says those titles are “far too definite for them,” since the figures “concentrate and express, less by way of definite conceptions than by the touches, the promptings of a piece of music, all those vague fancies, misgivings, presentiments, which shift and mix and are defined and fade again.” Here music stands for meaning that won’t settle into a concept, the kind of feeling a melody can carry without ever saying what it’s about. The note on the figures explains that Night and Day lie below Giuliano, Duke of Nemours, and Dawn and Dusk below Lorenzo, Duke of Urbino, so the titles carry a tidy program of time and mortality, and Pater’s complaint is that the program is too neat for what the marble actually does.

The second appeal comes six years later, in the Giorgione essay of 1877, and it’s the most famous sentence Pater wrote. “All art constantly aspires towards the condition of music.” He explains why at once, saying that in music’s “consummate moments, the end is not distinct from the means, the form from the matter, the subject from the expression; they inhere in and completely saturate each other.” Here music stands for something that sounds almost like the opposite of vagueness, a perfect fit between what a work is and what it says, so exact that you can’t pry the two apart. And the paintings he offers as examples are full of music as a subject, players tuning instruments, people listening by water or in the twilight, as if the school had made its own ideal into its favorite theme.

The two essays even contain two kinds of listener. The Michelangelo passage ends by imagining the spirit after death as “a thing with faint hearing, faint memory, faint power of touch,” a hearing so dim it barely registers anything. The Giorgione essay shows people in paintings listening “to detect the smallest interval of musical sound,” and says that in this school “life itself is conceived as a sort of listening.” One kind of hearing is fading out, and the other is straining to catch the finest difference, which is about as far apart as two experiences of sound can get.

But underneath, the two claims share a root, and it’s the refusal to paraphrase. The Medici figures can’t be summed up by their titles, and the Giorgione essay opens by attacking “the mistake of much popular criticism,” which treats poetry, music and painting as “translations into different languages of one and the same fixed quantity of imaginative thought.” In both places, music is Pater’s name for meaning that lives only in its medium and dies when you translate it into a sentence. At the level of theory, then, the two passages describe the same power of art. That’s the deepest continuity between the two essays, and it’s why Pater keeps reaching for music whenever a description starts to feel like a translation.

At the level of experience, they ask different things of the viewer. Before the Medici figures, Pater asks you to let thought drift into what he calls “vague and wistful speculation,” the way you might let an ambient piece wash over you on a long night drive while your mind turns to big questions. Before a Giorgionesque picture, he asks for alertness to “profoundly significant and animated instants,” a gesture or a look into which a whole story has condensed, the way you’d follow every entry in a string quartet. Both are ways of listening to music, and almost nobody does both at the same time. The difference matters in practice, because a viewer who brings the wrong kind of listening will miss the work, finding the Medici figures merely gloomy if he waits for a decisive instant, or finding Giorgione’s people merely pretty if he lets his mind drift.

The dates suggest a development in Pater’s own thinking. In the essay first published in 1871, music chiefly helps Pater describe suggestion. In the 1877 essay it also supplies a more general account of the fit between form and subject. The later essay discusses pictures full of musical scenes, while the earlier one turns to tomb sculpture, so the change may owe as much to what he was looking at as to any change in his theory. It would be easy to say the later essay simply replaced the earlier one, and that by 1877 vagueness no longer counted as a musical quality at all. But the Michelangelo passage has a subject that makes the two ideas meet.

The subject of the Medici chapel, as Pater reads it, is uncertainty about what happens after death, “dumb inquiry over the relapse after death into the formlessness which preceded life,” with hope “based on the consciousness of ignorance.” The figures’ vagueness isn’t a failure of definition, it’s a form fitted exactly to a vague subject. By the strict standard of 1877, then, the Medici figures achieve the condition of music, since their indefinite shapes and their indefinite matter “inhere in and completely saturate each other.” The faint hearing is the subject, and the form hears it faintly.

So the two appeals to music describe one power of art and two experiences of listening. The power is fusion that resists paraphrase, the experiences are drifting and acute attention, and which one a work asks for depends on what it’s about. A work about the edge of knowledge should sound like the edge of hearing, and a work about a perfect instant should sound like a perfect interval, and in that sense the Medici figures and the school of Giorgione are two cases of the same law, which Pater found once by feeling and stated later by thinking.

Test your understanding

123

Question 1 of 3

What underlying principle does the article identify as common to Pater’s discussions of the Medici figures and Giorgione’s paintings?

Choose one answer

Guided Inquiry

Questions for Socrates

Explore these questions with Socrates, with this Feature as your reading context.