Renaissance
Ending With the Saints
Pater follows Aucassin’s choice of hell with a miracle about two friends. He calls the place that can hold both stories the House Beautiful.
The Renaissance (1893)Bunyan’s palace and Paul’s list of virtues give Pater language for his closing turn. The way he places a saint’s tale after a rebellious love story shows what it takes to bring them under one roof.
Orientation
At a Glance
- Pater makes a turnAucassin’s speech ends the discussion of rebellion. Pater begins the next paragraph with a single word, “But,” and makes room for saints in the Renaissance he describes.
- The language has Christian sourcesThe House Beautiful recalls the palace where Bunyan’s pilgrim lodges. Pater’s list of things worth reconciling echoes Paul’s invitation to think about whatever is lovely and good.
- A different kind of fidelity closes the chapterAmis and Amile stay together in death in the saint’s tale. The miracle places the friendship inside the life of a church.
- The harmony depends on what Pater puts togetherPater acknowledges the harshness of the earlier defiance and chooses a closing story where interests agree. The order lets the reader see how he constructs the harmony he values.
The Renaissance · Two Early French Stories, pp. 20–21, Aucassin’s defiance · Two Early French Stories, pp. 21–22, the House Beautiful · Two Early French Stories, note 51 · Two Early French Stories, p. 23, the friends reunited · Two Early French Stories, p. 23, the appointed guardians
Pater makes the turn with a single word, “But.” Right after Aucassin’s defiance, he writes, “But in the House Beautiful the saints too have their place.” Then he explains why the student of the Renaissance is luckier than the student of the Reformation or the French Revolution, since in tracing humanity’s rise “he is not beset at every turn by the inflexibilities and antagonisms of some well-recognised controversy.” Within “the enchanted region of the Renaissance,” he says, “there are no fixed parties, no exclusions,” and so, with Aucassin’s defiance still ringing, he announces, “Let me conclude then with a morsel from Amis and Amile, in which the harmony of human interests is still entire.”
His phrases come from two very Christian sources, and that’s telling. The House Beautiful recalls John Bunyan’s Pilgrim’s Progress, where a stately palace called Beautiful gives rest to the pilgrim on his hard road, a place kept by maidens named Discretion, Prudence, Piety and Charity. And when Pater says that in the Renaissance “whatsoever things are comely” are reconciled, he echoes Paul’s letter to the Philippians, which asks its readers to think about whatever is true, honorable, just, pure and lovely. So the aesthete builds his house of reconciliation out of a Puritan allegory and an apostle’s advice, which is itself a small act of the harmony he’s describing.
There are three ways to read the return, and the first is that it makes room for several kinds of fidelity. That reading fits the chapter well, since Aucassin is faithful to a lover, Amis and Amile are faithful to each other, and the saint’s tale gives that friendship a place in the service of God, and Pater wants all three loyalties under one roof. The story of the friends “seems, as we have it, to have been written by a monk,” he notes, and its title calls them saints and martyrs, so the friendship that put severe demands on the two men’s households ends up honored within the church of Saint Oseige. That’s a powerful image of different fidelities living together.
The second reading is that the return softens the defiance, and Pater nearly says so. He admits that in Aucassin and Nicolette “the note of defiance, of the opposition of one system to another, is sometimes harsh,” and he calls the closing passage a “morsel,” as if he were offering a gentler dish after a spicy one. Pater chooses to let the following scene set the last mood of the chapter. He gives the last word to a pious miracle, so the reader leaves the chapter with the coffins of two friends lying side by side in a church rather than with a young lord choosing hell.
The third reading is the most interesting, that the return exposes the work it takes to make different freedoms coexist. Look at how much Pater has to assert, given that he has just spent pages describing a medieval spirit of rebellion, with Abelard’s struggle, the Albigensian movement and the Franciscans’ poetry and mysticism among his examples, and now he tells us that within the Renaissance there are “no fixed parties, no exclusions.” That’s less a historical finding than a decision about how to look, and the phrase “let me conclude then” shows the decision being made in front of us. The harmony is real in Pater’s house because Pater is the one arranging the furniture, choosing which stories to hang on the walls and which to leave in the cellar.
He even admits the arranging has limits, since the wicked popes and loveless tyrants who patronized the Renaissance, he says, “lend themselves easily to disputations,” so controversy is waiting at the edges of his enchanted region, held back only by where he chooses to point the light. The figures who truly belong, he says, are those like “the painter of the Last Supper, with his kindred,” who “refuse to be classified.” Leonardo is Pater’s example of the artist whose work escapes an ordinary quarrel over parties and patrons. The House Beautiful can make room for very different lives, and Pater’s choice of whom to put at its center also gives his harmony limits.
I don’t think that makes the ending dishonest, since Pater is open about wanting reconciliation and about choosing his morsel. It does mean the harmony is an achievement and not a given, and the chapter’s structure shows the work, with defiance first, then the claim of room for all, then a carefully chosen story that fits the claim. A Christian reader may find real comfort in an ending where friendship becomes holy, and a skeptical reader may notice that the comfort is curated, and both are reading what’s actually on the page. The miracle is beautiful whichever way you take it, two coffins found side by side in the morning, and its beauty is exactly why Pater chose it as his final note.
So why return to a saint’s tale after Aucassin’s revolt? My answer is all three reasons at once, though not in equal measure. It makes room for several fidelities, which is the generous intention, it softens the defiance, which is the evident effect, and it exposes the work needed to make freedoms coexist, which is the lesson a careful reader takes away. Pater’s House Beautiful is a lovely place, and he’s honest enough to let us watch him build it, one deliberate choice at a time, from a Puritan’s palace, an apostle’s list and a monk’s miracle.
Test your understanding
Question 1 of 3
According to the article, how does the Christian origin of Pater’s imagery contribute to his argument?
Guided Inquiry
Questions for Socrates
Explore these questions with Socrates, with this Feature as your reading context.
- If Pater creates harmony by selecting and arranging particular stories, what would distinguish meaningful reconciliation from the mere concealment of conflict?→
- How can the saint’s tale honor loyalty to a friend, loyalty to a lover, and loyalty to God without erasing the tensions among them?→
- Does Pater’s openness about curating the ending strengthen the credibility of his House Beautiful, or does it make its harmony seem less convincing? Why?→