Renaissance
Does an Image Fail When It Points Beyond Itself?
Pater says the Venus of Melos contains its meaning in its form. Fra Angelico’s painted light makes him look for a world beyond what he sees.
The Renaissance (1893)The difference between a statue and a cell fresco looks like a ranking in Pater’s argument. His description of the fresco shows how strongly a work can affect a viewer by suggesting more than it shows.
Orientation
At a Glance
- A self-contained statuePater argues that the Venus of Melos expresses its whole spiritual meaning through the visible figure.
- A fresco made for a cellThe Coronation at San Marco belongs to a program of frescoes made for a setting of individual prayer.
- What Pater sees in the lightMoonlight, linen and snow come to Pater as he looks at the fresco, showing how much its suggestion gives him to describe.
- Different resourcesPater himself recognizes how painting can use atmosphere and colour to suggest associations that sculpture can leave unstated.
The Renaissance · Winckelmann, pp. 133–134, Fra Angelico and the invisible · Winckelmann, note 304 · Winckelmann, p. 134, the Venus of Melos · Winckelmann, note 305 · Winckelmann, pp. 137–138, different powers of painting and sculpture · Winckelmann, p. 138, sculpture and form
Pater stages a matchup here, and it isn’t a fair fight, because he picks the referee. In one corner he puts Fra Angelico’s fresco of the Coronation of the Virgin in San Marco in Florence, where “In some strange halo of a moon Jesus and the Virgin Mother are seated, clad in mystical white raiment, half shroud, half priestly linen,” and Mary, “corpse-like in her refinement,” bends to receive her crown with “the light lying like snow upon her forehead.” In the other corner stands the Venus of Melos. The verdict comes fast, since works like Angelico’s “are inadequate to the matter they clothe; they remain ever below its level,” while the Greek statue gives you everything it means in what you see. The question worth asking is whether suggesting a world beyond the eye is a failure of art or something the painted image does uniquely well.
The Greek side deserves its full case first, and Pater makes it well. The Venus, Pater says, “is in no sense a symbol, a suggestion, of anything beyond its own victorious fairness,” and “The mind begins and ends with the finite image, yet loses no part of the spiritual motive,” because the meaning “saturates and is identical with” the form. This resembles Hegel’s account of symbolic, classical and romantic art. In Pater’s examples the relation between idea and visible shape changes from one to the next. Pater’s example of the first kind, the “many-breasted Diana of Ephesus,” makes the point beautifully, since the details send him looking for a meaning outside the visible figure. Whether the image loses by doing that is precisely what is at issue.
But Pater concedes the fact that changes the scoring. Angelico’s fresco didn’t express its subject fully “even for Angelico,” because for him every visible detail was “only the symbol or type of a really inexpressible world,” and “he would have shrunk from the notion that what the eye apprehended was all.” So the gap between what’s shown and what’s meant is intended. The fresco is in cell nine at San Marco, in the convent dormitory. Below the coronation, six saints kneel with their attention directed in different ways. In a place made for prayer, a fresco could give the viewer a starting point for an act of attention that went beyond its surface.
Christian thinking about images had said as much for centuries. The Second Council of Nicaea says that honour shown to an image passes to the person represented. That principle gives an image a job beyond holding the eye. In the San Marco frescoes, spare settings and small groups give such attention room. On those terms, an icon that kept your attention entirely on its own surface would be the failure.
The most persuasive evidence, though, is Pater’s own sentence. Look at what the fresco did to him, since it made him reach for a moon, a shroud, a priest’s linen, a corpse and snow, and then for the Book of Revelation, whose figure has hair tanquam lana alba et tanquam nix, like white wool and like snow. That’s a writer being sent somewhere by a picture, in a way a devotional image can invite, and the passage on the “inadequate” fresco is one of the most haunting things in the chapter. The image worked on its critic precisely by being more than the critic could pin down.
The Venus, meanwhile, is a shakier witness than Pater lets on. The Louvre dates the Hellenistic marble to about 150–125 BCE and records its discovery on Melos in 1820. That date puts pressure on treating one ideal moment of Greek art as the sole condition of its effect. And the missing arms make it natural to ask what she might have held or done. Even Pater’s model of the self-contained figure reaches us with details a viewer can only imagine.
Pater’s later pages actually supply the answer to his own question. Sculpture, he grants, “has no backgrounds, no sky or atmosphere, to suggest and interpret a train of feeling,” while “Painting, music, and poetry, with their endless power of complexity, are the special arts of the romantic and modern ages.” A painter can surround figures with light, set them in a moonlike halo and make white cloth glow like snow, and those are the means Angelico uses to point past his figures. The suggestion of an unseen world can be done with resources particular to painting, and a medium’s native strength can’t fairly be scored as its defect.
My verdict is that suggesting the inexpressible becomes a limit only when an image turns into a code, when its signs need a key and nothing in its visible means does the pointing, which is the trouble with the overcharged Ephesian goddess. When the light, the white and the posture themselves send you onward, as in Angelico’s fresco, the gap between what’s seen and what’s meant is the painting’s achievement. Pater needed the fresco to lose for his argument about Greek art to work, and his prose quietly gave it the win anyway.
Test your understanding
Question 1 of 3
Why does the author argue that the gap between what Angelico’s fresco shows and what it means should not automatically count as a failure?
Guided Inquiry
Questions for Socrates
Explore these questions with Socrates, with this Feature as your reading context.
- If an artwork intentionally directs attention beyond itself, what standards should we use to judge whether it succeeds?→
- How does Pater’s evocative description of Angelico’s fresco support or undermine his claim that the work is inadequate?→
- Can an artwork ever be fully self-contained, or does every viewer inevitably bring imagination, context, and interpretation beyond what is visibly present?→