Philosophy
Doctors Who Make You Immortal
A Thracian belief about the dead lends an unusual credential to a remedy for a headache.
The Platonic Dialogues: CharmidesSocrates mentions, almost in passing, that the Thracian doctors are said to make people immortal. Is that a grand credential, a red flag, or a wink, and how much of it is Socrates actually signing on to?
Orientation
At a Glance
- A rumor in passingSocrates says the doctors are said to make people immortal. He leaves the claim hanging and goes straight on to what the doctor taught him about the soul.
- The Getae and ZalmoxisHerodotus says the Getae believed that those who died went to Zalmoxis. Plato uses a related Greek word for the doctors’ reputed ability to make someone immortal.
- Prestige or warning?The rumor can make the remedy sound impressive, especially after Critias has promised a doctor. Its outlandishness can also remind readers to keep their judgment in reserve.
- What the charm treatsThe doctors’ reputation proves little about the remedy. It does bring the soul into focus, the part of a person whose survival Socrates argues for in the Phaedo and Phaedrus.
Charmides 155a–b, 156d–157a · Herodotus 4.93–96 · Phaedo 64a–67b, 105e–107a · Phaedrus 245c · Republic 617d–620d
The line is easy to skim past, tucked into the middle of a sentence about something else. Socrates says he learned his charm from “one of the Thracian doctors of Zalmoxis, who are said even to make one immortal,” and then moves straight on to the doctor’s teaching about the soul. Nobody in the room asks about the immortality part, and Socrates never mentions it again, but a claim like that doesn’t sit quietly in a sentence, and it raises a fair question about what it’s doing there and whether Socrates believes it.
Herodotus gives us a clue to what the phrase might have brought to mind. He describes the Getae of Thrace using a Greek verb closely related to Plato’s. In his account they believe that the dead go to Zalmoxis. In Socrates’ story, the doctors are credited with making someone immortal. Herodotus also passes on a story he heard from Greeks on the Black Sea, that Zalmoxis had once been a slave of Pythagoras who went home and taught his people about life after death, and Herodotus suspends judgment on the story while saying he thinks Zalmoxis lived long before Pythagoras. A reader who knows Herodotus has already seen a storyteller keep this particular legend at arm’s length.
One way to read the line is as grandeur, a way of making the charm sound impressive. It’s an exotic credential, the ancient equivalent of saying you learned your technique from a monk in the mountains whose students are said to live forever, and it gives the remedy a glow it wouldn’t have if Socrates had picked it up from the doctor down the street. For a young man with a headache who’s been promised an introduction to a doctor, a little mystique goes a long way. The appeal is familiar from whatever ancient secret is being advertised online this week.
The opposite reading treats it as a red flag. Any claim to make people immortal sounds like the label on a miracle supplement, and the dialogue has already shown us a ruse, so a careful reader might take the line as a signal not to swallow the Thracian’s story whole. That reading gets some support from the way Socrates phrases it, since he says only that they “are said” to make one immortal, which keeps the claim at the level of rumor, the way a careful journalist writes “reportedly” instead of vouching for something himself. Socrates, of all people, knows how to say something without signing his name to it.
A third reading sees a playful boundary, a little frame that marks the story as a story. Fairy tales begin with “once upon a time,” and a tale about faraway healers who can make you immortal can give us the feeling that we’re in the land of travelers’ yarns. That fits the improvisational feel of the whole scene, where Socrates has already agreed to play doctor at Critias’ request, and it lets the serious teaching inside the frame stand on its own merits rather than on the reputation of the people who supposedly taught it. On that reading, the teaching can stand even if the legend falls away.
The distinction the line forces on us is between reporting and endorsing. Socrates reports the reputation, but he never says he believes it, and nothing in the rest of the dialogue depends on it, since the case for the charm turns on the idea that the soul comes first. That’s typical of him, the habit of passing along what people say while keeping his own judgment in reserve, and a reader who treats “are said” as an endorsement has read more into the sentence than Socrates put there. It’s the difference between saying a restaurant is said to be the best in town and saying you’ve eaten there.
And yet the rumor Socrates chose to repeat isn’t a random one. The soul is what the Thracian’s charm is supposed to treat, and its survival is a serious question elsewhere in Plato. In the Phaedo, Socrates describes philosophy as a preparation for death and goes on to argue that the soul cannot perish. In the Phaedrus, he begins his argument with the claim that all soul is immortal. A doctor whose whole method is to treat the soul first is, in a sense, a doctor for the part of you that could survive death, so the joke about immortality carries a real philosophical charge underneath it. Plato even ends the Republic with the myth of Er, in which souls choose their next lives, another place where the care of the soul has consequences beyond a single lifetime.
My verdict is that the line is mostly a wink, a bit of exotic framing reported at arm’s length, and Socrates is careful never to vouch for it. The rumor also points toward the soul’s survival, a question Plato takes seriously elsewhere, so the wink can carry a second meaning. The immortality claim doesn’t prove anything about the charm, but it reminds us what kind of medicine this is, one aimed first at the part of a person that other dialogues say could go on after death. That’s a good deal more than a headache cure.
Test your understanding
Question 1 of 3
Why does the article emphasize Socrates’ wording that the doctors “are said” to make one immortal?
Guided Inquiry
Questions for Socrates
Explore these questions with Socrates, with this Feature as your reading context.
- What standards should readers use to distinguish a speaker’s report of a belief from an endorsement of it?→
- Can an extravagant or doubtful story strengthen a serious teaching by framing it memorably, or does it inevitably weaken the teaching’s credibility? Why?→
- If the charm’s teaching can stand after the immortality legend falls away, what role does the legend still play in shaping how readers understand the care of the soul?→