Greek Antiquity

Dike Sits on Zeus’s Throne

Dike looks down from Zeus’s throne and comes down on those who grasp for more.

Dike sits on Zeus’s throne in the hymn and beside him in Hesiod. The article reads the change of position as a change in the authority she exercises.

Orientation

At a Glance

  • The preposition places Dike on the throneThe edition notes that the Greek seats the goddess on Zeus’s throne itself.
  • Hesiod gives her a place beside ZeusIn the Works and Days, Dike sits next to her father and tells him how mortals have wronged her.
  • The throne gives her a wide viewThe hymn has Dike look down from heaven on the lives of mortals of many tribes.
  • Dike acts on what she seesThe goddess comes down on those who grasp for more and rouses justice against them herself.

Orphic Hymns, LXII.1–4, 8–9, with the note on LXII.2–3

The second line of the hymn to Dike makes a striking claim about where the goddess sits. She is the one “who also sits upon the sacred throne of Zeus the lord / and looks down from heaven on the life of mortals of many tribes.” The edition’s note on these lines insists on the grammar. With the case the Greek uses, “she sits on the holy throne of Zeus, not beside it.” The seat of the king of the gods is her seat too, and from it she looks down on the whole human world.

The note sets this against Hesiod, and the contrast is the key to the hymn. In the Works and Days, Hesiod says that whenever anyone wrongs Dike with crooked words, she sits beside her father Zeus and tells him of the unjust minds of men, so that the people pay for the folly of their kings. Hesiod’s Dike is a maiden, daughter of Zeus, honored and revered by the gods of Olympos, and her power is that she has the ear of the king of the gods. The note sums up the difference in a single sentence. Hesiod has her “seated beside her father when she is wronged and telling him of unjust men,” while “this hymn seats her on the throne itself and gives her the looking down rather than the reporting up.”

Position in these images is a way of stating authority. A figure who sits beside a king is an adviser, a confidante, someone with the king’s ear, and Hesiod’s Dike has influence but not power, since she must tell Zeus and wait for him to act. A figure who sits on the throne exercises the king’s power directly. The hymn’s Dike does not need to report, because she sees for herself from the highest seat in heaven, and the note adds that “line 8 has her act on what she sees without referring it to anyone,” so the position and the action match.

The image is something like the difference between a chief of staff and a president. The chief of staff may know everything and have great influence, but decisions go through the person in the chair, while the person in the chair simply decides. Hesiod’s Dike is the indispensable adviser, and the hymn’s Dike sits in the chair. Sophocles has a middle version, calling Dike the one who shares Zeus’s seat by ancient laws, and the hymn goes further than either of them in giving her the throne itself. Pindar uses a similar word for Themis, calling her the one who sits beside Zeus, guardian of strangers, so the place beside the throne was the usual honor for the goddesses of right, and the throne itself was not.

What does the placement give her to see and do? From the throne she “looks down from heaven on the life of mortals of many tribes,” the widest possible view, and from there she bears down on the unjust as an avenger. In line 8 she comes down on those who crave the larger share and “rouse justice against the unjust,” so the action follows straight from the seeing, with no delay for a report and no need for Zeus’s permission. The participle for bearing down is a word for pressing with weight, so her judgment falls on the unjust from above, with the weight of the seat she occupies. Plato quotes an ancient saying that Justice always follows God as the avenger of those who abandon the divine law, and the hymn goes further still, putting her in the god’s own seat rather than in his train. The throne gives her both the view and the authority to act on it.

The note adds a contrast from the opposite direction. Sophocles has Antigone appeal to the Dike who dwells with the gods below, a justice rooted in the underworld and the rights of the dead, and the note calls this “a contrast to this hymn’s placing, not a support for it.” Antigone invokes that Dike when she refuses Creon’s decree in the name of the unwritten and unfailing laws of the gods, which no human edict can override, so justice there belongs with the dead whom she insists on burying. Greek thought could place justice below, beside Zeus or on his throne, and each placement says something different about where justice comes from. The hymn’s choice puts it at the very top, sharing the seat of the highest god.

The Bible thinks of justice and the throne together in a different but related way. Justice and judgment are the habitation of thy throne, the psalmist says to God, mercy and truth shall go before thy face, so justice is the foundation on which the throne stands, and another psalm repeats that righteousness and judgment are the habitation of his throne. And in the Revelation of John the risen Christ promises, To him that overcometh will I grant to sit with me in my throne, even as I also overcame, and am set down with my Father in his throne. To sit on the Father’s throne is to share his authority fully, which is exactly the sense the hymn gives to Dike’s seat.

My verdict is that the hymn signals Dike’s authority through position, seating her on Zeus’s throne rather than beside it, and that this placement gives her both the widest view of human life and the power to act on what she sees without referring it to anyone. Set against Hesiod’s Dike, who sits beside her father and reports, and Sophocles’ Dike, who dwells below, the hymn’s Dike is justice enthroned, not an adviser to the ruler of the world but a sharer in his rule.

Test your understanding

123

Question 1 of 3

What is the article’s central interpretation of Dike sitting on Zeus’s throne rather than beside it?

Choose one answer

Guided Inquiry

Questions for Socrates

Explore these questions with Socrates, with this Feature as your reading context.