Renaissance

Dignity After Copernicus

Pater gives up Pico’s picture of a world centered on Earth. What happens to the dignity he found in it?

Pater sees a claim about human worth inside a cosmology he rejects. Copernicus, Kant and Nietzsche give us different ways to test whether that claim can stand on its own.

Orientation

At a Glance

  • A theory Pater partly gives upPater rejects Pico’s picture of the cosmos and still values what it allowed Pico to say about humanity.
  • The center can be a low placeIn the medieval model described by Lewis, heavy things fall to Earth at the center, while nobler things are imagined above it.
  • Two kinds of importanceKant distinguishes our smallness in the universe from the worth he finds in our capacity to act according to moral law.
  • Worth without a cosmic addressThe modern language of inherent dignity shows how a claim about human worth can be made without appealing to our position among the stars.

Pater doesn’t soften the problem at all, and he states Pico’s picture flatly. “For Pico the earth is the centre of the universe,” he writes, with the sun and moon and stars circling it “like diligent servants or ministers,” and human beings placed in the midst of it all. That picture fell apart over the century after Copernicus published his book on the revolutions of the heavenly spheres in 1543, and Pater, writing in 1871, knew it was gone. Yet he adds a sentence that carries the whole discussion. “False as its basis was, the theory had its use.” That’s a concession and a claim at once, since it admits the foundation is rotten while insisting that something built on it is still worth keeping.

The worry is easy to state, and Freud stated it famously in 1917, when he listed three great blows to human self-love. The first was cosmological, when Copernicus made Earth a planet that orbits the Sun, the second biological, when Darwin placed humans among the animals, and the third psychological, his own claim that the ego isn’t master in its own house. If human dignity meant being the lord at the center whose servants circle him, then the first blow should have finished it off, and Pico’s speech should read today like a royal proclamation from a kingdom that no longer exists.

The picture is more interesting than that, though, because the medieval center was never simply a throne. C. S. Lewis pointed out in The Discarded Image that in the old model the earth sat at the bottom of the universe, the place where heavy and corruptible things settle, with everything nobler arranged above it, and Dante put hell at the very center of the earth. Lewis even coined a word for it, calling the medieval model anthropoperipheral rather than anthropocentric, since it set humans at the margin looking up. Pico’s own speech has God place Adam in the middle of the world so that he can look around more easily at everything in it, which makes the center a vantage point and not a crown.

Some accounts of human importance did appeal to Earth’s position. Pater pictures the stars as servants turning around a master, a role the new astronomy gave us little reason to claim. Pico had already challenged a different idea about our place in the heavens. In his last years he wrote against the use of astrology to predict human affairs. Any dignity that rested on our being the purpose of the cosmos, or on our size and placement in it, went down with the crystal spheres, and nobody should mourn it too much, since it was always a little vain.

What survives is the dignity that never depended on location in the first place, and Kant drew the line more cleanly than anyone. At the end of his Critique of Practical Reason in 1788 he wrote that two things fill the mind with ever-new admiration and awe, the starry heavens above and the moral law within. The first, he said, annihilates his importance as an animal creature in a universe of countless worlds, while the second raises his worth infinitely as an intelligence, a person who can give himself a law. That’s the separation Pater’s sentence is groping toward, with worth by size and position crushed by astronomy and worth by reason left entirely untouched.

Pater gives us the knife for the separation in his own account of why the theory mattered. Pico’s dignity, he says, “was supposed to belong to him, not as renewed by a religious system, but by his own natural right,” and its proclamation “was a counterpoise to the increasing tendency of medieval religion to depreciate man’s nature.” Look at what natural right excludes, since it rules out dignity conferred by grace or by rank, and by the same logic it rules out dignity conferred by an address in the cosmos. If worth belongs to human beings by their nature, then moving the earth changes nothing about it, and the cosmology was only the stage scenery for a claim that never needed the stage.

The other side has a sharp reply, and Nietzsche made it in 1887, writing that since Copernicus humanity seems to have been sliding faster and faster away from the center into nothingness. On this view a dignity with no place in the cosmos has to be asserted rather than found, a label we pin on ourselves in an indifferent universe, and that is a fair objection. Pico had God’s gift to ground his claim, and Kant had his theory of reason, so natural right still needs some account of nature that makes it more than a slogan. Pater doesn’t supply one, and the reader is entitled to notice that his knife cuts cleanly only if you already believe there’s something there to cut out.

My verdict is that a rejected cosmology can sustain a lasting idea of dignity once you separate dignity of place from dignity of nature, and that Pater’s phrase about natural right is exactly the right tool for the separation. The servants-and-master picture died, as it deserved to, and the claim that worth belongs to human beings as such, not granted by church, rank or cosmic address, has a modern counterpart in the preamble of the Universal Declaration of Human Rights in 1948, with its “recognition of the inherent dignity” of every member of the human family. That document says nothing at all about where the earth sits, which is the best evidence that it never needed to.

Test your understanding

123

Question 1 of 3

How does the article use C. S. Lewis’s account of the medieval cosmos to complicate the idea that Earth’s central position made humanity supreme?

Choose one answer

Guided Inquiry

Questions for Socrates

Explore these questions with Socrates, with this Feature as your reading context.