Renaissance

Detained in Bologna for Want of a Wax Seal

An entry rule brought Michelangelo to a halt in Bologna. His stay gave him work on a shrine earlier sculptors had left incomplete.

Condivi tells of a fine, a host and evening readings from Dante. Pater follows the story to the older sculpture that helped form Michelangelo’s eye.

Orientation

At a Glance

  • A missing seal stops the journeyCondivi says the young Michelangelo entered Bologna without the red wax seal required of strangers. Aldovrandi intervened and took him into his household.
  • Pater gives the stay a literary lifeHe imagines Michelangelo repaying his host by reading Italian poetry. Condivi names Dante, Petrarch and Boccaccio.
  • San Petronio offers earlier modelsJacopo della Quercia gave the Creation of Adam and other Genesis episodes compact bodies and emphatic gestures. Pater asks us to see them alongside Michelangelo’s later work.
  • The education included a commissionAt the shrine of Saint Dominic, Michelangelo supplied figures for a monument several sculptors had already worked on. His contact with their work was practical.

If you’ve ever been pulled aside at a border because a stamp was missing from your passport, you’ll sympathize with the nineteen-year-old Michelangelo. On entering Bologna in 1494, according to his biographer Condivi, every stranger entering the city had to have a seal of red wax pressed onto his thumbnail, and Michelangelo, who didn’t know the rule, was caught without one and fined fifty Bolognese lire, which he didn’t have. Pater retells the story, and he uses it to make a large claim, that this small bureaucratic accident gave Michelangelo a year among the early sculpture that “suggested much of his own grandest work.”

The trip began with a ghost, or at least with a dream of one. “He believed in dreams and omens,” Pater writes, and “one of his friends dreamed twice that Lorenzo, then lately dead, appeared to him in grey and dusty apparel.” Condivi names the friend as Cardiere, a musician in the Medici household, and describes the dead Lorenzo differently, wearing nothing but a torn black cloak over his naked body and ordering Cardiere to warn his son Piero that he would be driven out of Florence. Pater’s grey and dusty figure is gentler, more a revenant from the tomb than a ragged prophet, which fits the essay’s taste for faded things. Either way Michelangelo took the warning seriously, and in the autumn of 1494, shortly before Piero de’ Medici really was driven out, he left Florence with two companions.

So he arrived in Bologna with no seal and no money, and here the accident turned lucky. A local magistrate, Gianfrancesco Aldovrandi, one of the city’s ruling council of Sixteen, heard the case and freed him, Condivi says, “chiefly because he was a sculptor,” and then took him home. Michelangelo stayed with Aldovrandi a little over a year, and in the evenings he read aloud from Dante and Petrarch, and sometimes Boccaccio. Pater turns that into a grateful guest “rewarding his hospitality by readings from the Italian poets whom he loved,” which is about as charming a picture of a houseguest earning his keep as you’ll find anywhere.

Pater is a good deal less charmed by the city itself. “Bologna, with its endless colonnades and fantastic leaning towers, can never have been one of the lovelier cities of Italy,” he sniffs, which is a bold thing to say about a place whose historic porticoes are represented by twelve groups on UNESCO’s World Heritage List. But he immediately turns to what the city held, because “about the portals of its vast unfinished churches and its dark shrines” lie works by “the early Tuscan sculptors, Giovanni da Pisa and Jacopo della Quercia,” which he calls “things as winsome as flowers,” before concluding that “the year which Michelangelo spent in copying these works was not a lost year.”

One of those churches is San Petronio, whose brick front still stops halfway up, never cased in the marble it was meant to have. Around its central doorway Jacopo della Quercia carved, between the 1420s and his death in 1438, a series of small reliefs from Genesis, with sturdy, heavy-limbed figures pressed close to the surface, Adam rising from the ground, Eve drawn from his side, the pair driven from the garden and set to work. The edition’s note points readers to them, and you can feel how these compact, muscular bodies, telling the first chapters of the Bible in a few big gestures, might stay in the mind of a young sculptor who would one day paint those same chapters on a vault in Rome.

What Michelangelo actually made in Bologna confirms that the year wasn’t lost. The shrine of Saint Dominic in the church of San Domenico had been begun in the 1260s by the workshop of Nicola Pisano, and its crowning figures were being carved by Niccolò dell’Arca when he died in March 1494, leaving gaps. Aldovrandi helped secure the work. The three figures associated with Michelangelo are a kneeling angel with a candlestick, Saint Petronius and Saint Proculus. Condivi names the angel and Petronius and records thirty ducats for those two. Pater names Giovanni da Pisa, while the shrine’s early carving is associated with Nicola Pisano and his workshop.

This Bologna year is the evidence behind one of Pater’s central claims about Michelangelo, that “he must be approached, not through his followers, but through his predecessors,” through the sculptors of the fifteenth century rather than the giants of Saint Peter’s. There’s even a bitter postscript that proves how fragile those later monuments could be. Michelangelo came back to Bologna in 1506 to cast a huge bronze statue of Julius II for the front of San Petronio, right above Jacopo’s doorway, and the bronze was later destroyed. Jacopo’s small reliefs still surround the doorway.

So my verdict is that Pater is right to treat the accident as an education, even if a few of his details are loose. The ghost wore black in Condivi, the wax went on a thumbnail rather than a whole thumb, and the name Pater gives should be distinguished from the workshop responsible for the shrine, but the shape of the story holds, from the panic, the fine and the rescue by a stranger to a year of reading Dante and carving beside the older masters. A border stamp nobody remembered to mention sent Michelangelo to exactly the sculptures he needed, and that’s one of the luckiest bits of bad luck in the history of art.

Test your understanding

123

Question 1 of 3

How does Pater’s negative description of Bologna contribute to his larger argument about Michelangelo’s year there?

Choose one answer

Guided Inquiry

Questions for Socrates

Explore these questions with Socrates, with this Feature as your reading context.