Renaissance

Dante Lends Hellenism Its First Light

The sky Dante sees on leaving Hell gives Pater an image for what antiquity meant to Winckelmann. The light at the other end of the poem complicates the comparison.

Venus, four stars and a Roman guardian greet Dante in Purgatory. Pater borrows that dawn to describe Greek clarity, while Dante has another kind of light in reserve.

Orientation

At a Glance

  • Darkness changes the experiencePater says the brilliance of Greek art can be felt especially strongly by someone coming from a world they experienced as dark or restrictive.
  • What Dante sees firstAt the start of Purgatorio, clear air and the colour of sapphire give way to Venus and four bright stars.
  • An ancient figure in a Christian poemCato of Utica appears as the guardian of Purgatory, his face lit by stars often read as the four cardinal virtues.
  • Light further onDante’s later vision of intellectual light filled with love gives Pater’s contrast between medieval heat and Greek light a limit.

Pater sets the scene of Winckelmann’s first years in Rome with a comparison. “Dante, passing from the darkness of the Inferno, is filled with a sharp and joyful sense of light, which makes him deal with it, in the opening of the Purgatorio, in a wonderfully touching and penetrative way.” Then he states the general principle behind the comparison. Hellenism, “which is the principle pre-eminently of intellectual light,” has “always been most effectively conceived by those who have crept into it out of an intellectual world in which the sombre elements predominate.” That’s true of the Renaissance, Pater says, and it’s true of Winckelmann, whose “repression, removed at last, gave force and glow to Winckelmann’s native affinity to the Hellenic spirit.”

The darkness had been established from the essay’s very start. Pater describes Winckelmann’s youth in “the tarnished intellectual world of Germany” and “the dusky precincts of a German school,” and says that “Passing out of that into the happy light of the antique, he had a sense of exhilaration almost physical.” The essay is built on that contrast, a long gray apprenticeship followed by a sudden brightness, and Dante’s journey from the bottom of Hell to the open sky of Purgatory gives it a shape every educated reader would recognize. You know the feeling from ordinary life, the moment of stepping out of a dark theater into a summer afternoon, when the light seems almost too much to bear.

The opening of the Purgatorio deserves to be read closely, because Pater chose it with care. As Dante comes out “fuor de l’aura morta,” out of the dead air that had saddened his eyes and his heart, he sees “Dolce color d’orïental zaffiro,” the sweet color of eastern sapphire, gathering in the serene face of the sky. Dante’s word for that face is sereno, the same quality of serenity that Pater will later find in Winckelmann’s handling of Greek art. The first heavenly body he notices is Venus, “lo bel pianeto che d’amar conforta,” the lovely planet that encourages love, making the whole east laugh, and then he sees four stars never seen except by the first people, which commentators have long read as the cardinal virtues of prudence, justice, fortitude and temperance.

Then comes the most remarkable detail of the whole canto. The guardian of Purgatory, the first figure Dante meets after leaving Hell, is Cato of Utica, a pagan Roman and a suicide, with his face lit by the four stars. So the Christian poem’s first breath of fresh air is full of pagan light, the planet of the love goddess, the virtues the ancient philosophers taught, and a Roman hero standing at the gate. Pater’s comparison is better than an analogy, since the passage he names is already a Christian imagination making room for the light of antiquity, which is exactly what he says Winckelmann did.

Pater then divides the powers of the ages with unusual precision. In a parenthesis he says that “our modern culture may have more colour, the medieval spirit greater heat and profundity, but Hellenism is pre-eminent for light.” Each age gets its own virtue, and each is a real power rather than a failing. Modern culture has color, the nuance and richness of feeling that came after the Renaissance, the Middle Ages have heat and depth, the burning faith and inward intensity of Dante’s own world, and the Greeks have light, clarity of outline and serenity of mind, the quality the Germans call Heiterkeit, which Pater later uses for Winckelmann’s serenity and which in German also describes a cloudless sky. Pater keeps the three powers distinct because he wants each age to feel like a different climate rather than a better or worse version of the same one.

Pater’s later pages complicate the map in an interesting way. He contrasts the spiritualist, who “is satisfied as he watches the escape of the sensuous elements from his conceptions,” as “the dyed garment bleaches in the keener air,” with the artist who “steeps his thought again and again into the fire of colour,” and he warns of “the greyness of the ideal or spiritual world.” Greek light, on this account, is neither the spiritualist’s bleached gray nor the modern artist’s fevered color, but the clear daylight in which sensuous things can be seen distinctly. Dante’s first look out of the pit offers Pater a way of making that contrast felt.

The Christian poem, though, doesn’t stop at that light, and here the comparison overflows Pater’s map. As Dante enters the Empyrean in Paradiso, canto XXX, he sees intellectual light full of love. Pater’s phrase for Hellenism has an echo here in a Christian vision. So the medieval spirit had its own intellectual light, and it placed that light above the dawn of natural virtue rather than below it. Pater’s division is a useful map of what Winckelmann felt, but Dante’s poem suggests that heat and light needn’t be rivals, since its highest light burns with love. The first dawn better suits the change Pater wants us to feel. It is the moment when a person who has lived in darkness first sees what a different kind of light can reveal.

My verdict is that Pater’s comparison lets a Christian poem express the experience of reaching a pagan ideal because the passage he chooses already does that work, welcoming Venus, the cardinal virtues and Cato into the first light after Hell. His division of powers, color for the moderns, heat for the Middle Ages and light for the Greeks, gives each age its due and explains why Hellenism shines brightest for those who come to it out of darkness. And the poem he borrows quietly reminds us that it had a light of its own further up the mountain, which makes Dante both the perfect guide for Winckelmann’s emergence and a gentle check on Pater’s tidy map.

Test your understanding

123

Question 1 of 3

Why does the author consider Pater’s comparison between Winckelmann and Dante more than a simple analogy?

Choose one answer

Guided Inquiry

Questions for Socrates

Explore these questions with Socrates, with this Feature as your reading context.