Renaissance
Daisies from a Tapestry, a Body from Ingres
Pater sees medieval decoration around a Venus drawn with the clarity of Ingres. The mismatch helps him describe a classical ideal becoming new again.
The Renaissance (1893)Daisies, drapery and a deliberately graceful contour carry different histories in Botticelli’s Venus. Pater values the painting for letting those histories show at the same time.
Orientation
At a Glance
- Different periods meet on one canvasPater sees a Greek subject, medieval draperies and a figure that reminds him of the nineteenth-century painter Ingres.
- The flowers keep their own patternThe cloak’s scattered flowers recall the repeated designs of late medieval textiles. Their flat arrangement sets off the continuous outline of Venus.
- A perfect line can stretch a bodyBoth Botticelli and Ingres alter the proportions of their figures for the sake of a contour. That helps explain what Pater might mean by calling Ingres’s nudes faultless.
- A first impression keeps its accentFor Pater, the mixture makes it possible to imagine a painter meeting an ancient ideal with eyes trained in a different tradition.
The Renaissance · Sandro Botticelli, the Gothic draperies and Ingres · Note 103, Botticelli’s Venus · Note 104, Ingres and the classical nude · Botticelli’s Birth of Venus, Uffizi · Ingres’s Venus Anadyomene, Musée Condé · Ingres’s nudes, Louvre exhibition
Pater’s sentence about the Birth of Venus reads at first like a playlist on shuffle, with three different centuries colliding in a single breath. In the painting, he says, “the grotesque emblems of the middle age, and a landscape full of its peculiar feeling, and even its strange draperies, powdered all over in the Gothic manner with a quaint conceit of daisies, frame a figure that reminds you of the faultless nude studies of Ingres.” So the frame is medieval, the subject is ancient and the figure looks modern, and he admits you might conclude that “this quaintness must be incongruous with the subject,” the kind of clash a sharp student would flag in the margin, before he turns around and argues that the clash is the whole point of the picture.
Start with the daisies, because they’re real and specific. The young woman waiting on the shore holds out a rose-colored cloak scattered with flowers, which Pater calls daisies. The flowers recur on her light dress, and his word “powdered” suggests a surface strewn with small repeated forms. That’s the Gothic manner he means, pattern laid flat across fabric with little interest in the folds underneath, the way the millefleurs tapestries of the next generation, like the Lady and the Unicorn set in Paris, spray tiny flowers over an entire background, and a “quaint conceit” in his English is a clever decorative idea rather than a cute one.
The winds at the left give us one way to imagine Pater’s “grotesque emblems.” Their puffed cheeks recall the wind-heads on old maps, though the Uffizi also points to a classical gem as a source for the pair’s embrace. Pater uses “grotesque” in an older sense, for the odd and fanciful rather than the horrifying, and the landscape “full of its peculiar feeling,” with its small dark orange trees and tidy promontories, has the clipped, pattern-book look of fifteenth-century tapestry and book painting rather than the hazy distance a later Venetian would give it. Pater sees the visual habits of Botticelli’s own world everywhere around Venus, and Botticelli doesn’t hide those habits or apologize for them, which is exactly the feature Pater is about to build his argument on.
Then comes Ingres, and the comparison is sharper than it looks. Jean-Auguste-Dominique Ingres, who died in 1867, was the great French keeper of the classical line, and his nudes, from the Valpinçon Bather of 1808 to The Source, finished in 1856, were famous for contours so clean they look drawn in a single breath. He even painted his own Venus Anadyomene (Venus Rising from the Sea), begun in Rome in 1808 and not finished until 1848, so Pater’s readers had a recent French goddess in their heads when they met the name, and the word “faultless” suggests the finish and control associated with academic drawing.
The joke hiding in “faultless” is that neither painter’s nude would pass an anatomy exam. Critics complained that the back of Ingres’s Grande Odalisque of 1814 had too many vertebrae, and Botticelli’s Venus shows the same cheerful disregard for skeletons, with her neck and torso stretched long, her body leaning into a delicate, unstable pose, and shoulders that flow almost continuously into her arms. So “faultless” means faultless as drawing, a contour without a false note, and Pater has found the real family resemblance, two artists who’d trade a correct body for a perfect line any day of the week.
That’s why the mix isn’t a mistake, since Pater’s claim is that Botticelli’s picture is “a more direct inlet into the Greek temper than the works of the Greeks themselves even of the finest period,” because it gives us “a record of the first impression made by it on minds turned back towards it, in almost painful aspiration, from a world in which it had been ignored so long.” A first impression always includes the person having it, the way your first try at a new language keeps your accent, and the Gothic daisies and map-corner winds are Florence’s accent, the clothes the city happened to be wearing on the morning it met Venus on the beach.
Ingres gives us the other end of the story. By Pater’s day the classical nude had become a staple of European academies, and he says frankly that “long familiarity has taken off the edge of the lesson,” which is what happens when a shock turns into a curriculum. The faultless Ingres nude is antiquity owned and mastered, while Botticelli holds the same perfect line inside a frame that still feels medieval, so you can see the line as new, the way an old song suddenly sounds strange again when a garage band plays it on the wrong instruments and you hear the melody properly for the first time in years.
My verdict is that Pater’s odd company of comparisons is the most exact thing in his account of the picture. The medieval draperies mark where the painting came from, the Ingres-like body marks where the classical ideal would end up, and the painting sits between them as the record of a meeting rather than a possession, which is what it passes on about rediscovery, the feeling of seeing something ancient with eyes trained on something else. I’d only push his phrase a step further than he does, because the nude is faultless the way a drawing is faultless and not the way a body is, and that small cheat is the clearest sign that this Venus was imagined by someone meeting her for the first time.
Test your understanding
Question 1 of 3
According to the article, why does Pater regard the apparent clash between Venus and the painting’s medieval details as meaningful rather than mistaken?
Guided Inquiry
Questions for Socrates
Explore these questions with Socrates, with this Feature as your reading context.
- If the medieval elements reveal how Botticelli’s Florence first encountered antiquity, should they be understood as limitations, creative strengths, or both? Why?→
- How does the article’s distinction between a faultless drawing and a faultless body change the way you evaluate artistic distortion?→
- What might be gained—and what might be lost—when a culture encounters an older tradition through the visual habits of its own time?→