Philosophy

Coming Home Safe Isn’t the Same as Living Well

Socrates comes home alive from a battle. Later, he imagines a city whose generals keep people safe and asks what else it would take for them to live well.

Socrates’ homecoming gives his later dream of expert generals a concrete point of comparison. Survival makes a good life possible and leaves its purpose open.

Orientation

At a Glance

  • Chaerephon asks who came backThe first question in the wrestling school is how Socrates survived. The room wants news of a battle that killed people they knew.
  • The dream promises safe passageSocrates imagines real generals and pilots in charge. The dream gives their skill its due and leaves open whether the people they save will be happy.
  • Military skill has a scopeIn the Laches, the general judges how to use the seer’s forecast in war. The Charmides asks the further question of what makes the result worth pursuing.
  • The homecoming moves onSocrates gives the crowd the news they ask for and then asks after philosophy and the young. The two topics mark different questions about the life he has returned to.

The first question anyone asks Socrates in the Charmides is about survival. Chaerephon rushes over and asks, “how did you come out of the battle alive?” and Socrates gives his famously dry answer, “Like this, as you see.” The room wants the war story, and the news that “many people we know were killed” hangs over the scene. Much later, in the dream of a world ruled by temperance, Socrates promises that with genuine experts in charge we would “come through safe when in danger at sea and in war,” and when he tests the knowledge of good and bad, he asks whether without it “generalship in war” would protect us any less. The two passages sit at opposite ends of the dialogue, and a reader who notices the echo can feel the whole conversation suspended between them.

It’s a reading, not a certainty, that these passages speak to each other, but the connection is hard to miss. The opening scene is a homecoming from a campaign where the dialogue’s first concern is who survived, and the dream offers a world where competent generals would make survival much more likely. If we put them side by side, the dream answers the opening’s anxiety, and then Socrates refuses to grant that answering it would make us happy, which is a sobering thing to say to a room full of people who have just lost friends in battle. Socrates never draws the link himself, and Plato never underlines it, so it remains a proposal about how the parts of the dialogue fit together rather than a claim about what Plato meant.

The distinction is between preserving life in danger and knowing what makes collective life good. Generalship is the craft of the first kind, and a good general brings his men through, wins battles and keeps losses down. But a general doesn’t decide whether the war should be fought, what the city should do with victory or how its citizens should live once they get home, and in Socrates’ thought experiment, Critias agrees that generalship would protect us just as well if the knowledge of good and bad were missing. The army would come home safe, and nobody would know whether it had been worth sending.

In the Laches, Socrates notes that the law puts the general in charge of the seer. Generalship is better placed to judge what matters for a military operation. The dream in the Charmides includes both genuine seers and genuine generals. Its later test asks another question about both of them. What would make the outcomes they secure good for the people concerned?

The distinction matters to a city at war. Imagine a general who brings everyone home from an expedition safely. The result is worth having, and it still leaves the city with the question of whether the expedition should have been sent. The skill that gets an army out of danger has done its work before that larger question is settled.

Alcibiades’ account in the Symposium adds something to the homecoming. He remembers Socrates enduring the cold at Potidaea, carrying him to safety after he was wounded, and keeping his wits on the retreat from Delium. In the wrestling school, Socrates gives his listeners the news they ask for. Once they’ve had their fill, he asks how philosophy is doing and what the young are like now. The soldier has other things he wants to find out about the city he’s come back to.

There’s a quiet gentleness in how the dialogue handles this. It never says the men who died at Potidaea died for nothing, and it never sneers at military virtue. It simply observes, through the shape of its argument, that coming through safe is a condition of living well and not the same thing, so that a city could master every craft of survival and still not know how to live. For an audience that had lived through a long, ruinous war, that observation would have carried weight that no lecture could.

My verdict is that the link between the opening’s battle and the dream’s promise of safe passage through war is a reading worth proposing, and that it sharpens the dialogue’s central distinction. Preserving life in danger is the work of crafts like generalship, which the dream rightly honors, while knowing what makes collective life good belongs to a different knowledge that no general, as such, possesses. The man who came home safe from Potidaea spends his first visit to the wrestling school asking about the second kind, and that choice is the dialogue’s best argument for which kind matters more.

Test your understanding

123

Question 1 of 3

What limitation does the article identify in generalship, even when it succeeds perfectly at protecting an army?

Choose one answer

Guided Inquiry

Questions for Socrates

Explore these questions with Socrates, with this Feature as your reading context.