Renaissance
Catching a Smile on Its Way Past
Pater sees a smile passing over a child’s face in a relief that stays still. The artist’s small cuts give light and the viewer’s eye room to finish the gesture.
The Renaissance (1893)The corner of a mouth and the shadow along a cheek can suggest a smile just beginning. The passage asks how a fixed shape can let a viewer imagine what happened before and after it.
Orientation
At a Glance
- Pater describes eventsA child’s smile passes and a curtain ripples. The two examples make the duration of an expression part of what sculpture can suggest.
- The carving gives small cuesA lift at the mouth and a slight swelling of the cheek can leave it open whether a smile is arriving or fading.
- Light makes the cues more or less visibleShadows in a shallow relief change with the direction of the light. From a different viewpoint, the same marks can appear softer or more distinct.
- The viewer imagines the rest of the gestureThe stone gives the eye a shape between moments. We supply the movement that could have brought the face to that point or carried it beyond it.
The Renaissance · Luca della Robbia, p. 48, the passing smile and moving curtain · Luca della Robbia, note 117
Pater’s definition of what these sculptors were after is one of the loveliest sentences in the book, and it’s also a riddle. “The whole essence of their work is expression,” he writes, “the passing of a smile over the face of a child, the ripple of the air on a still day over the curtain of a window ajar.” Both of his examples are events rather than things, small changes that happen over a second or two and are gone, and he’s attributing them to an art made of marble and fired clay, the two materials least capable of changing at all, which is a little like describing a photograph as the sound of someone laughing.
Start with what’s actually carved, because it’s not nothing. Florentine sculptors learned from Donatello how to suggest depth in very shallow carving, or rilievo schiacciato. At the scale of a face, a slight lift of the mouth or a small change of contour can make a difference. The parted lips of Desiderio da Settignano’s young boy suggest a passing expression by similarly economical means, though the bust itself is carved in the round. When the sculptor holds back from a full grin, what you get is the beginning of a smile or the end of one, a shape that sits between two moments rather than nailing down either of them.
The contrast that makes the point is the archaic Greek smile. A late archaic marble head of a youth gives the mouth a regular upward turn. Its effect can be read as a smile held in place, whatever the convention meant to its first viewers. Pater’s Tuscans did the opposite, keeping the cues so faint that no single reading wins, and that’s the difference between a smile that’s been declared and a smile that’s still happening, between a sticker on a face and weather moving across it.
So how much does the viewer bring to this, and how much is really in the stone? The skeptic says all of it, and he has a point, since people see smiles in clouds and faces in electrical outlets, and Pater himself was the critic who read whole centuries into the face of the Mona Lisa, so the passing smile might be nothing more than a reverie projected onto a still surface. Ernst Gombrich gave this contribution a name in Art and Illusion, calling it the beholder’s share, and on the skeptic’s account the sculptor carves a shape while the motion lives entirely in the mind of the person standing in front of it.
But there’s a physical side to the passing, too, and it gives the sculptors more credit. A shallow relief changes as the light changes, so the faint shadows at the corners of a mouth deepen and fade as the sun moves across a church through the day, and they shift again as you walk past and look from a new angle. Margaret Livingstone proposes that the Mona Lisa’s smile is clearest in low spatial frequencies, which peripheral vision registers well. That offers a comparison for relief, where the direction of the light also changes how easily a faint cue can be seen.
That suggests why restraint is the key to the whole effect, since a fully carved grin freezes, the way a snapshot caught mid-laugh looks fake because it pins the face at one instant that never felt like a pose from the inside, while an almost-smile stays compatible with several moments at once, the one just before and the one just after. The mind does what it does with any ambiguous cue and runs between those possibilities, like a flipbook with only two pages, and the result feels like motion even though nothing moves, which is exactly the experience Pater describes as a smile passing over a face.
The curtain makes the same point with less to look at. A window ajar on a still day lets in only the faintest breath of air, so the ripple Pater imagines is motion right at the threshold of stillness, the smallest change you can still notice, and that’s a precise description of what low relief does best, registering differences so slight they almost aren’t there. He’s defining expression as the art of thresholds, and his two images ask you to notice how much feeling can live in a change too small for a camera to bother with, as long as the artist knows where to stop.
My verdict is that the motion is a collaboration, and the sculptor’s half of it is the restraint. Stone holds a shape that sits between moments, light and the viewer’s moving eye make that shape flicker, and the mind supplies the before and after, so the skeptic is right that the passing happens in us and wrong that the sculptor has nothing to do with it. The restraint that keeps the smile from freezing is exactly what allows us to imagine it moving, and the more a sculptor carves, the less there is left to pass.
Test your understanding
Question 1 of 3
Why does the author describe Pater’s definition of sculptural expression as a riddle?
Guided Inquiry
Questions for Socrates
Explore these questions with Socrates, with this Feature as your reading context.
- If the viewer’s mind supplies the moments before and after an expression, how should we divide credit between the artist and the beholder?→
- Why might ambiguity communicate change more effectively than a precisely defined expression?→
- How does Pater’s image of a curtain rippling on a still day deepen the article’s idea of expression as an “art of thresholds”?→