Philosophy

Case Open, Meeting Adjourned

Charmides will come back, Critias has given the order, and Socrates agrees to go along. The question they met to discuss is still open.

The dialogue settles what the characters will do and leaves them unsure what temperance is. Its last joke about force makes that difference hard to miss.

Orientation

At a Glance

  • The plan is settledCharmides wants the charm every day. Critias orders him to continue, and Socrates agrees to go along with them.
  • The question is still openThe plan answers what the three people will do next. They still haven’t found a definition of the temperance they hope to cultivate.
  • Socrates asks for a hearingThe two have made their plan without him. Socrates’ joke about being denied a hearing calls attention to how quickly this decision was reached.
  • What a reader takes awayThe final exchange distinguishes an agreement about what to do from a discovery about what temperance is. Only the first has been reached when the scene closes.

Charmides 175b–176a, 176a–d · Euthyphro 15c–d, 15e · Lysis 223a–b · Laches 201b–c · Xenophon, Hellenica 2.4.19

The last page of the Charmides moves fast, almost like a comedy racing toward its curtain. Charmides says he doesn’t know whether he has temperance but wants to be charmed every day, Critias orders him to do it, and the boy promises, “Then I’ll do it,” adding, “starting from this very day.” When Socrates asks what the two of them are plotting, Charmides answers, “Nothing,” and then, “We’ve finished plotting.” Socrates protests that he’s being railroaded, Charmides tells him to count on force, and Socrates, observing that when Charmides uses force “no man alive will be able to oppose you,” gives in. The final words of the dialogue are his, “Then I won’t oppose you,” and with that the scene is over, every practical question answered and the philosophical one still wide open.

The endings of other dialogues help show what’s special here. At the end of the Euthyphro, Socrates wants to start again, and Euthyphro says he is in a hurry and must go. In the Lysis, the boys’ tutors come to take them home, and Socrates jokes that they think they’re friends without having found what a friend is. The Laches comes closest to the Charmides. Lysimachus asks Socrates to come to his house at daybreak to consult about their education, and Socrates says he will come, God willing. The invitation leaves Socrates room to give his own answer.

The Charmides closes quickly on a plan. A guardian gives an order, a pupil promises obedience, and Socrates yields. It’s like the end of a play where everyone knows whom they’ll see tomorrow and the central question is still in doubt. Critias has told Charmides what to do. Charmides has told Socrates to expect force. We can see how each of them will behave when they meet again, even though nobody can say what would make that behavior temperate.

There’s an irony in how they reach the decision. The Greek verb behind Socrates’ question about plotting can mean to take counsel. Charmides says their deliberating is already done. Socrates asks whether they’ll use force without giving him even a preliminary hearing, borrowing the language of a legal examination for a dispute about who will get a say. Their decision to continue examining temperance has been made in a hurry, and the person who will do the charming hears about it after the fact.

The final line is another concession. A page earlier, Socrates listed claims they had conceded before the argument gave them reason to. Now he says, “Then I won’t oppose you,” giving way to a plan instead of granting a premise. The last line can sound playful. It also gives a reader one more agreement to look at closely, right after the dialogue has taught us how much can happen when somebody says yes and the conversation moves on.

Readers who knew what happened later could hear something darker. Xenophon says Critias was one of the Thirty and Charmides one of the Ten who ruled in Piraeus. He records both men’s deaths in the same battle. That history gives the joking about orders and force an edge. The scene can still play as affectionate comedy. Its last joke asks the two people who will use those powers to wait at least long enough to let Socrates speak.

What the reader carries out of the wrestling school is a difference worth keeping in view. The characters have settled that Charmides will come back. They still owe each other an account of what temperance is and how the charm is supposed to help him find it. It’s like leaving a courtroom after a hearing has been scheduled. You know when to turn up and what you’ll be there to find out.

My verdict is that the Charmides closes decisively as an encounter and leaves the inquiry unfinished. The practical agreement lets Charmides go on asking for help. Its haste gives us reason to watch how the people promising to inquire together reach their next agreement. The curtain falls, and the reader can still ask what temperance would look like in that room.

Test your understanding

123

Question 1 of 3

What central contrast does the article identify in the ending of the Charmides?

Choose one answer

Guided Inquiry

Questions for Socrates

Explore these questions with Socrates, with this Feature as your reading context.