Renaissance
Can the Laocoön Do Painting’s Job?
Pater admires the marble group and thinks its subject strains the limits of sculpture. A rediscovered arm lets us see the group differently.
The Renaissance (1893)The Vatican Laocoön puts the violence of a single moment into stone. Comparing the old restoration with the recovered arm helps distinguish the subject from the sculptors’ way of handling it.
Orientation
At a Glance
- Pater’s double judgmentThe group overcomes a difficult subject through skill, while its crisis brings it close to what Pater assigns to painting.
- A unity made from partsPliny praised the group as a single block, but the surviving sculpture is made of joined pieces.
- The arm changes the outlineThe raised restoration extends the gesture outward, while the ancient bent arm draws it back into the cluster of figures.
- A sculptural means of telling the storyThe twisting torso and interlocking bodies give the action force without the color or setting a painter could supply.
The Renaissance · Winckelmann, what painting can do with a particular situation · Winckelmann, the Laocoön at the edge of sculptural restraint · Note 313, the Vatican Laocoön and the debate over suffering · Vatican Museums, Laocoön · Pliny the Elder, Natural History 36.37, on the sculptural group · Vatican News, the recovery and reattachment of Laocoön’s arm
Pater’s sentence on the Laocoön is a compliment with a warning folded inside it. “The Laocoon,” he writes, “with all that patient science through which it has triumphed over an almost unmanageable subject, marks a period in which sculpture has begun to aim at effects legitimate, because delightful, only in painting.” The famous marble group, a Trojan priest and his two sons crushed by sea serpents, is a technical triumph by his account and also a sign of the art drifting out of its lane. The question for discussion is whether a sculpture this successful forces Pater to revise his theory of what sculpture can do, or whether it actually shows his theory working.
The case for revision is strong, and it starts with the statue’s reputation. Pater’s whole account says sculpture should present types in repose and leave “the special situation” to painting and poetry, and the Laocoön is nothing but situation, a single moment of agony in a story with a plot. Yet it has been one of the most admired sculptures in Europe since the day it came out of the ground in Rome in 1506, when it was immediately identified with the group praised by Pliny the Elder. Pliny had called it a work to be preferred to every other in painting or sculpture, and if a statue can win that verdict while doing painting’s job, maybe the job wasn’t painting’s alone. Pliny also believed the whole group was carved from a single block, which modern study has disproved by finding multiple pieces of marble fitted together, but the mistake shows how miraculous its unity seemed to ancient eyes.
Pater would answer that success isn’t the same as suitability, and he says as much with “almost unmanageable.” The group triumphs over its subject, which means the subject fought back, and the triumph took “patient science,” his phrase for the anatomical knowledge, the calculation of balance and the sheer carving skill that let three Rhodian sculptors make struggling bodies stay legible in stone. On this reading the Laocoön proves his point by showing how much effort it takes to make sculpture do what painting does easily, the way a pianist can play an orchestral score brilliantly while everyone can hear the strain. The comparison with Michelangelo’s twisting bodies shows what is at stake in calling the subject painterly. The body under strain can be a sculptural means of expression in its own right.
The statue’s history complicates both sides, though, because the Laocoön Pater knew wasn’t quite the ancient Laocoön. The priest’s right arm was missing when the group was found, and the restorers made a fateful choice. In the sixteenth century Giovannangelo Montorsoli supplied an extended arm, flung up and out in a theatrical gesture. That’s the arm Pater and everyone else saw for four centuries. Montorsoli also restored missing parts of the Apollo Belvedere, so two of the statues that shaped Europe’s idea of Greek art carried a Renaissance sculptor’s notion of a heroic gesture for most of their modern lives.
In 1905 Ludwig Pollak identified a marble arm bent at the elbow. The Vatican returned it to the group during the restoration led by Filippo Magi in the 1950s. The real Laocoön reaches back toward his own head, pulling at the serpent behind him, and the effect on the group is huge. The outflung arm had burst out of the block like a gesture in a painted battle scene, while the bent arm closes the composition back in on itself, so that the whole knot of bodies stays inside a compact, sculptural mass.
The restored arm may help explain why the group struck Pater as painterly. The restorers, working in the age of Raphael, gave the statue the open, rhetorical gesture of Renaissance painting, and generations of viewers read that gesture as the ancient sculptors’ ambition. Even without the arm, the group is composed to be seen mainly from the front, like a relief, which does give it a pictorial quality, and the moment it shows is still a moment of crisis rather than a type at rest. But the original is more self-enclosed, more like a single body of stone in torsion, than the version that shaped two centuries of criticism, Pater’s included.
That suggests the best answer to the discussion question. The Laocoön’s real achievement lies in means that belong to sculpture, the rendering of muscle under strain, the twisting mass that holds three bodies and two serpents in one block-like silhouette, the way pain shows in the whole torso rather than in any painted detail of color or setting. It does a job Pater assigns to painting, the depiction of a special situation, but it does it with sculpture’s own tools, and the more sculptural the original turns out to be, the clearer that becomes.
My verdict is that the Laocoön clarifies Pater’s account rather than overturning it. His theory said sculpture works best through its own limits, and the group shows that even when a sculptor takes on a painter’s subject, the success comes from those limits, from mass, anatomy and the closed form of the block. The restorer’s extended arm made the outline more theatrical for the audience Pater belonged to. The ancient group still makes its drama out of the movement and mass of bodies.
Test your understanding
Question 1 of 3
Why does the article treat Pater’s phrase “almost unmanageable” as evidence for his theory rather than simply as criticism of the sculpture?
Guided Inquiry
Questions for Socrates
Explore these questions with Socrates, with this Feature as your reading context.
- If the Laocoön depicts a subject that Pater considers better suited to painting but succeeds through sculptural means, does that strengthen the boundary between the arts or make it less stable? Why?→
- How should knowing that Pater saw Montorsoli’s theatrical replacement arm affect our assessment of his judgment that the group was aiming at painterly effects?→
- What matters more when judging whether an artwork suits its medium: the kind of subject it represents, the techniques it uses, or the effect it produces on viewers? Apply your reasoning to the Laocoön.→