Renaissance
Can One Society Set the Standard for Every Other?
Pater distrusts abstract definitions of beauty, then says Greece fixed a standard of taste. His examples suggest how a standard can live in works of art.
The Renaissance (1893)Pater’s Preface asks critics to attend to particular experiences. His Winckelmann essay asks how a tradition of admired objects might guide new work without becoming a formula.
Orientation
At a Glance
- The Preface distrusts formulasPater asks critics to describe how beauty appears in a particular work before trying to say what beauty always is.
- An artist belongs to a timePater agrees with Schiller that an artist is formed by an age even when that age gives the artist reasons to look elsewhere.
- Works pass on a standardPater locates the standard in a tradition of works that direct the attention of later artists.
- Where the claim reachesA Greek reference point explains an important part of European art history. It leaves open what might guide artists in other traditions.
The Renaissance · Winckelmann, p. 130, Hellenism as a conscious tradition · Winckelmann, pp. 130–131, time, place and a standard of taste · Preface, p. 2, particular expressions of beauty
Sound engineers keep a few reference tracks on hand, records they know so well that they can play them against a new mix and hear at once whether the bass is muddy or the vocals are buried. Nobody writes down a formula for a good mix, and nobody needs to, because the standard lives in a handful of recordings that keep proving themselves in room after room. Pater makes a claim of exactly that shape near the middle of the Winckelmann essay, when he says that “The standard of taste, then, was fixed in Greece, at a definite historical period,” and it’s a claim that seems to clash head-on with the Preface he wrote for the same book. The question is whether a set of exemplary objects from one society can really carry a standard for every age after it, and whether Pater can say so without contradicting himself.
The Preface is blunt about formulas, and it doesn’t seem to leave much room for a Greek exception. Critics who try “to find some universal formula” for beauty get nowhere, Pater says, because “the definition of it becomes unmeaning and useless in proportion to its abstractness,” and the real task is to find “not its universal formula, but the formula which expresses most adequately this or that special manifestation of it.” Then in the Winckelmann chapter he warns that criticism must never forget that the artist is the child of his time, and in the next breath he adds “an element of permanence, a standard of taste, which genius confesses.” That looks like having it both ways, with relativism in the front window and a Greek absolute in the back room.
The phrase about the artist being the child of his time is borrowed, and its source settles more than Pater lets on. It comes from the ninth of Schiller’s letters on aesthetic education, published in 1795. Schiller says the artist is a child of the age and warns against becoming its pupil or favourite. He imagines a god rearing that child under a distant Greek sky. The artist can then take material from the present and learn how to shape it from an earlier age. Schiller already puts the two pressures side by side.
Pater also makes clear that the standard isn’t a rule at all. It “is maintained in a purely intellectual tradition,” and it acts on artists “through those artistic products of the previous generation which first excited, while they directed into a particular channel, his sense of beauty.” That’s the reference-track model, a standard carried by things you can look at and compare, and it fits the Preface’s demand for concrete formulas perfectly well. The great works of each age, he says, form “a series of elevated points,” like peaks catching light from a source below the horizon, and nobody needs to define that light to see which summits it reaches.
David Hume’s “Of the Standard of Taste” offers a related test. Hume notes that readers still admired Homer in Paris and London after the passage from ancient Athens and Rome. He also insists on practice, comparison and the judgment of practiced critics. A work’s long appeal matters, and so does the quality of the attention it receives.
The other side has a strong case, though, because Pater’s “fixed” is a much harder word than Hume’s slow accumulation, and it makes one historical society the source of light for everybody, though different traditions can choose different works to test themselves against. A reference set can change as new works give artists reasons to hear or see old ones differently. Pater’s own book is evidence here too, since its heroes include a French romance and a Venetian school of painting that would have puzzled the Greeks.
Pater’s defense is in a sentence he wrote a page earlier, where he says that Hellenism, unlike other forces from the past, “is a conscious tradition” in modern culture, one that keeps getting dragged back to the surface so that culture can be “clarified and corrected” against it. Pater’s own examples take their force from European history, from Renaissance painters to Winckelmann and the nineteenth-century critics who read him. Read that way, “fixed in Greece” means that one tradition chose its reference tracks long ago and keeps checking its mixes against them, and the choice tells you about that tradition rather than about every possible one.
So my verdict is that a tradition of exemplary objects can carry a lasting standard, and that Pater’s version of it is consistent with his Preface, since the standard works through concrete things rather than definitions. Where he overreaches is in the word “fixed” and in the hint that all later art takes its light from one place. The more defensible claim, and the one his own evidence supports, is that Greek art became the reference set for one long and self-aware tradition, which kept testing new work against it and kept finding the old work still holding up.
Test your understanding
Question 1 of 3
How does the article reconcile Pater’s rejection of universal formulas with his claim that Greece established a standard of taste?
Guided Inquiry
Questions for Socrates
Explore these questions with Socrates, with this Feature as your reading context.
- What is gained—and what may be lost—when a culture treats exemplary artworks rather than explicit rules as its standard of taste?→
- If later works cause artists to perceive older works differently, in what sense can a reference set still be called “fixed”?→
- Does interpreting Greek art as the reference set of one conscious tradition fully resolve the tension in Pater’s argument, or does the language of permanence still create a problem?→