Philosophy

Can Knowledge Spot Its Own Absence?

Critias agrees that knowing knowledge includes recognizing its absence. The promise sounds like Socrates’ own practice until a supposed doctor gives them a concrete case to test.

A doctor’s mistakes are only visible against some idea of what good medicine is. Could a power that knows nothing about medicine still tell when that knowledge is missing?

Orientation

At a Glance

  • The proposal adds absenceSocrates asks whether knowledge of knowledge would also know the lack of knowledge. Critias agrees, giving the proposal its promise of catching mistakes in ourselves and others.
  • What opposites have in commonAristotle gives a reason a single discipline can study opposed things. Plato’s Hippias Minor tests a related idea by asking who can deliberately give a false answer in arithmetic.
  • The supposed doctorA general power might register that someone has knowledge or lacks it. Socrates asks how it could tell what the person lacks if it knows nothing of health or disease.
  • The craftspeople in the ApologySocrates credits them with real skill and objects to the authority they claim in other matters. Their case shows why it matters to ask exactly where someone’s knowledge runs out.

Charmides 166e–167a, 169e–170b, 170b–e, 170e–171c · Apology 21b–d, 22a–c, 22d–e · Aristotle, Metaphysics Γ.2, 1004a · Hippias Minor 366c–d, 366d–367a · Defense Department briefing February 12, 2002

The addition comes in a single quick exchange. Socrates asks, “if it is knowledge of knowledge, it would also be knowledge of the lack of knowledge?” Critias says, “Certainly.” It’s easy to read past, but this is what makes his definition attractive. Recognizing knowledge would be interesting. Recognizing where it’s absent could help us catch a mistake before we take a confident answer for a good one.

Socrates immediately spells out the promise. The temperate person would “know himself, and be able to examine what he in fact knows and what he does not.” He could also look into what others think they know and what they actually know. It sounds like the work Socrates describes in the Apology, where he goes looking for wisdom among politicians, poets and craftsmen. That comparison gives us something concrete to ask of Critias’ proposal. How would the power tell an informed answer from a guess?

The extension has a respectable idea behind it. Aristotle says that one science can investigate opposites and discusses negation and privation in the same connection. And in the Hippias Minor, Socrates has Hippias agree that an expert in arithmetic can both give the correct answer and deliberately give a wrong one. What gives the expert both abilities is a command of arithmetic. That makes it tempting to think one power might recognize knowledge and its absence. It also gives us a reason to ask what the power would need to know.

A spell-checker can flag a misspelled word because it has spellings to check it against. Take those away and it can’t tell which mark in a document needs attention. There’s also a difference between a question you know you can’t answer and one it has never occurred to you to ask. Donald Rumsfeld called these known unknowns and unknown unknowns in a briefing. The distinction is worth borrowing because the second kind gives you much less to work with when you’re trying to spot a gap.

Socrates makes the difficulty concrete with medicine. His bare knowledge of knowledge could tell “that, of these things, this one is knowledge and that one is not knowledge.” But when it comes to assessing a supposed doctor, he asks how you would examine the person without knowing something about health and disease. You might know an applicant has some kind of qualification. It’s another matter to be able to tell whether he’s answering a medical question competently.

That makes the Apology comparison more interesting. Socrates credits the craftsmen with knowing things he himself doesn’t. Their trouble is that doing their own work well leads them to suppose they’re wise about other important matters. He doesn’t need to deny their expertise to make his point. He needs to see where it belongs and ask whether they can answer for the claims they make once they leave that ground.

There’s something right in Critias’ extension all the same. It’s worth being able to recognize that you’re out of your depth. In the Apology, Socrates says he doesn’t think he knows what he doesn’t know, and the inquiry shows him testing that distinction one person at a time. An answer may fall apart when someone asks for a reason. That gives you a particular gap to look into, even when you had no idea it was there at the beginning.

My verdict is that knowledge of absence becomes useful when it can tell us what’s missing. The promise of catching a false claim is what makes Critias’ extension attractive, and the supposed doctor gives us a way to see its limit. A power might tell you that somebody doesn’t know. The examiner still has to work out what he doesn’t know and why he ought to know it.

Test your understanding

123

Question 1 of 3

Why does the article use the example of a spell-checker?

Choose one answer

Guided Inquiry

Questions for Socrates

Explore these questions with Socrates, with this Feature as your reading context.