Greek Antiquity
Can Death Be Common to All and Unjust to Some?
Everyone is subject to Thanatos, yet the hymn calls him unjust when he cuts short the prime of the young.
The Orphic Collection, Volume I: The HymnsThe hymn gives each mortal a holy span of time and calls death common to all. Its charge of injustice concerns the point at which that span comes to an end.
Orientation
At a Glance
- Life is given a holy spanThanatos keeps his distance while the time allotted to a person lasts.
- Death is common to everyoneThe hymn gives all mortals the same exposure to Thanatos’s power.
- Timing is what makes it unjustThe line about injustice leads directly to the young whose prime comes to a swift end.
- The prayer asks for long lifeThe worshippers ask Death to draw near only after a long span, when they have had the chance to reach old age.
Orphic Hymns, LXXXVII.2, 6–12, with the note on LXXXVII.6–7
The hymn to Thanatos contains the boldest line in the collection. Death is “common to all, yet standing unjust toward some, / ending in the swiftness of life the prime of the young,” and the edition’s note calls this “the one place in the book where a god is called unjust.” It explains that Death “is common to all and therefore fair, and takes the young and is therefore not,” and that “the hymn states the contradiction in a single line and does not resolve it.” A hymn is a song of praise, and this one stops in its sixth line to accuse the god it is praising.
The two halves of the line describe different things. What all mortals share is the fact of dying, the certainty that no one is exempt, and in that sense Death is the most impartial of the gods, treating kings and slaves, the good and the wicked, in exactly the same way. What mortals do not share is the timing, since some reach old age and others die in their prime, and there the impartiality breaks down. The earlier line about Death “giving to all a holy span of time” promises each person an allotted measure, and the death of the young is a measure cut short. The note on that line reads the span as the time for which Death stands at a distance from the living, so an early death is Death coming near before his hour.
The Greeks felt the death of the young as a particular wrong. Those who died before their time were called the untimely dead, and popular belief held that their spirits did not rest, so that magicians writing curse tablets called on them as restless ghosts still bound to the world they had left too soon. Epitaphs for young men and women lament a life ended before marriage or before its proper fruit, and the hymn’s phrase, the prime of the young, names exactly the loss that grave poems mourn.
Yet Greek tradition also knew a counter-view, since Herodotus has Solon tell of the brothers Cleobis and Biton, who died in their sleep at the height of their glory after their mother prayed for the best gift a god could give them, and the comic poet Menander wrote that whom the gods love dies young. On this view an early death can be a blessing, sparing a person the losses and sorrows of age, and a god who takes the young in their prime might be acting with kindness rather than injustice. The hymn does not take that view, and its refusal is telling, especially since Homer’s Achilles chose the short and glorious life over the long and obscure one, so that early death could be imagined as an honor.
The line after the accusation complicates it further, since the hymn says, “for in you alone of all is what has been judged brought to fulfilment,” which makes Death the executor of a judgment rather than its author, the one who carries out what has been decided. If that is so, the injustice may lie in the decision and not in the one who enforces it, and Death’s unfairness is the unfairness of an instrument. But the hymn does not draw that conclusion either, and it lets the accusation stand beside the claim about judgment without reconciling them. The edition’s note on the hymn’s first line points out that the word alone, withheld from Death’s title there, arrives twice in these lines, so his exclusive power is asserted just as his fairness is questioned.
So why name injustice within a prayer to Death at all? The answer lies in what the prayer asks, since a few lines later the worshipper begs Death to draw near only “after long spans of life,” and the complaint about the young prepares that request. By naming the injustice of an early death, the hymn makes clear what it is asking to be spared, and it puts the request in terms Death might recognize, the promise of a holy span of time that the early deaths betray. Honest lament becomes the ground of petition, as it so often does in prayer, and Job curses the day of his birth before he asks God to answer him.
The Bible holds the same tension between the fact of death and the timing of it. A psalmist prays, O my God, take me not away in the midst of my days, while acknowledging that God’s years endure throughout all generations, and the Wisdom of Solomon offers a consolation for the early death of the righteous, saying that though the righteous be prevented with death, yet shall he be in rest, and that being made perfect in a short time, he fulfilled a long time. Scripture both laments and consoles, and the hymn, in its single line, chooses to lament.
My verdict is that Death can be common to all and unjust to some because fairness and unfairness attach to different things, the fact of dying and its timing, and the hymn keeps them apart with precision. The injustice it names is the cutting short of a holy span, the prime of the young ended in the swiftness of life, and naming it is not impiety but honesty, the kind of truth-telling that prepares a sincere request. The hymn praises Death for his universality and accuses him for his timing, and then asks him, on the strength of both, to come late.
Test your understanding
Question 1 of 3
How does the article resolve the apparent contradiction that Death is both common to all and unjust to some?
Guided Inquiry
Questions for Socrates
Explore these questions with Socrates, with this Feature as your reading context.
- If everyone shares the same ultimate fate but not the same amount of life, what standard should determine whether death is fair?→
- Does describing Death as the executor rather than the author of judgment lessen his responsibility? Why or why not?→
- How can accusation or honest lament strengthen a prayer rather than undermine its reverence?→