Renaissance

Can Damage Help Create the Last Supper Pater Sees?

In Pater’s Last Supper, the apostles look like ghosts. Early copies and conservation records help explain how that effect came about.

A nineteenth-century reader of the damaged mural could see both Leonardo’s arrangement of the figures and the effects of time and repainting. Pater’s account leaves room for each.

Orientation

At a Glance

  • The ghosts on the wallPater describes the apostles as faint as shadows and allows that decay might partly account for the effect.
  • What restorers changedSuccessive interventions left repainted areas and other materials that the late twentieth-century restoration worked to remove.
  • An uncertain drawingPater recommends the Brera head of Christ, but Richter questioned the attribution and the Met catalogues it as a heavily worked-over copy.
  • What an early copy preservesThe Royal Academy’s copy shows the organization of the figures and helps explain why Pater could read the scene as a farewell.

Pater’s two paragraphs on the Last Supper contain something close to a contradiction. First he tells you flatly that the painting decayed, “Within fifty years it had fallen into decay,” so that we “have to turn back to Leonardo’s own studies” in order “to trace it as it was.” Then he describes the apostles, in the loveliest sentence of the passage, as “ghosts through which you see the wall, faint as the shadows of the leaves upon the wall on autumn afternoons,” and says the figure of Christ is “the faintest, the most spectral of them all.” The ghostliness he praises is what the decay looks like, the way an old snapshot from the seventies picks up a dreamy glow nobody at the party intended. So it’s a fair question whether damage helped make the picture Pater admires, and whether a critic is allowed to admire it.

Pater isn’t naïve about this, and his own sentence admits as much. “Finished or unfinished, or owing part of its effect to a mellowing decay,” he writes, “the head of Jesus does but consummate the sentiment of the whole company.” Pater leaves open whether the head was finished, left incomplete as Vasari claimed, or given some of its effect by age. Each possibility lets him read the faint face in the same way. Whatever the cause, the effect serves his reading, that Leonardo lifted the Eucharist out of its usual associations and painted it “not as the pale Host of the altar, but as one taking leave of his friends,” and a Christ already fading into the wall suits a farewell perfectly.

The trouble is that the mural Pater wrote about in 1869 wasn’t the one Leonardo left, or even the one the damp alone had produced. Michelangelo Bellotti and Giuseppe Mazza both worked on the damaged mural in the eighteenth century. Later interventions added more material. A report from Italy’s heritage ministry describes the 1978–1999 campaign that removed old repaint, glues and other materials to recover what survived of Leonardo’s original. That record makes it difficult to assign any one effect Pater noticed to a single cause.

Pater’s route back to the original runs into the same problem. The drawing he recommends, “one drawing of the central head at the Brera,” with its “union of tenderness and severity in the face-lines,” had been worked over so often that Jean Paul Richter, publishing Leonardo’s notebooks in 1883, said he could no longer judge whether it was genuine. The Metropolitan Museum’s catalogue describes the drawing in an early photograph as a much reworked and restored copy by an unknown artist. Its softened, monumental look, which reminds Pater of the sculptor Mino da Fiesole, may owe as much to retouching as the mural’s ghosts owe to damp. Even his comparison piece, the Last Supper at Sant’Onofrio in Florence that he credits to “the young Raphael,” is now attributed to Perugino.

The case for letting the decay count is stronger than it first sounds, and it deserves a fair hearing. Leonardo’s whole art leans toward the half-seen, the softened edge and the shadow that swallows a contour, and Vasari reports that he left the head of Christ unfinished on purpose, because he despaired of giving it the heavenly divinity it required. If that’s true, a faint Christ doesn’t betray the design at all. The paint was already deteriorating in the sixteenth century. Later viewers have seen the wall in different states, so a critic who claims to see its pristine appearance has to reckon with that history. Honest criticism describes the object in front of it, and the object in front of Pater was a wall of ghosts.

Still, it matters which parts of Pater’s reading need the damage and which don’t. His big claim, that the scene shows a man saying goodbye to his friends rather than an altar ceremony, rests on the composition, the twelve apostles breaking into four groups of three as the news hits them and the still figure at the center with his arms spread across the table. That design survives in the early copies, among them the Royal Academy’s large canvas of about 1515–20, attributed to Giampietrino and Giovanni Antonio Boltraffio, and the cleaned wall bears it out. What does need the damage is the feeling of transparency, the faces you can see the wall through and the leaves on autumn afternoons, which the early Royal Academy copy gives us little reason to treat as a feature of the original design.

That gives a critic a way to admire Pater’s ghosts without being fooled by them. You can treat the decay as a collaborator, the way a gardener treats moss on old stone, as long as you keep track of who did what, so that the farewell is credited to Leonardo and the transparency to time, damp and restorers. Pater half does this, which is why he slips “a mellowing decay” into his list of causes, but his prose then fuses the two so smoothly that the reader comes away thinking Leonardo painted ghosts. As far as we can tell he painted thirteen men at a table reacting to a betrayal, and the wall has been fading around them ever since.

So yes, damage helps create the Last Supper Pater sees, and the damage is part of what made his account memorable. The ghost sentence is first-rate criticism of a ruin, an account of the wall’s effect in an essay first published in 1869, while the farewell sentence is first-rate criticism of Leonardo. Where Pater goes wrong is in letting the first borrow its authority from the second, as if the spectral faintness were part of what Leonardo meant. A critic who wants to know what the medium originally allowed should go to the copies and the cleaned wall, and one who wants to know what five centuries made of it can still go to Pater, who described the ruin better than anyone.

Test your understanding

123

Question 1 of 3

Which aspect of Pater’s interpretation does the article argue can be credited most securely to Leonardo rather than to the mural’s deterioration?

Choose one answer

Guided Inquiry

Questions for Socrates

Explore these questions with Socrates, with this Feature as your reading context.