Renaissance
Can Beauty Bring the Gods Back?
Pater asks what happens when the stories of the Greek gods become beautiful enough to take seriously again.
The Renaissance (1893)From Plato’s account of visible beauty to Pico’s reading of pagan hymns, this essay asks how far the experience of beauty can take a person toward belief.
Orientation
At a Glance
- Three ways to receive a mythIn Pater’s account, the Greek gods are feared as evil powers, enjoyed as figures in stories, and eventually considered as possible rivals to Christianity.
- Beauty invites a second lookPlato’s account of beauty gives Pater a way to explain why art can carry religious weight.
- Pico takes the old stories seriouslyPico reads pagan hymns and oracles for truths he believes they can share with Christianity.
- Attention and beliefA beautiful story can make its claims worth hearing. Deciding whether those claims are true is a further step.
The Renaissance · Pico della Mirandola, from feared gods to divided allegiance · Pico della Mirandola, Pico entertains the claim of the older religions · Pico della Mirandola, the ascent toward unseen beauty · Plato, Phaedrus 250d–e in the Diotimos Library · Plato, Symposium 211c–d in the Diotimos Library · Augustine, Confessions X.27 · Pico’s 900 Theses, including the Orphic hymns and Chaldean theologians
Pater packs about a thousand years of religious history into one paragraph, and it moves in three stages. First, “An earlier and simpler generation had seen in the gods of Greece so many malignant spirits, the defeated but still living centres of the religion of darkness,” so in Pater’s first stage Christians treat the gods as dangerous powers. Then, “Little by little, as the natural charm of pagan story reasserted itself,” the gods lost their religious meaning and became “the subject of a purely artistic or poetical treatment,” the way Ovid’s myths were moralized and illustrated for medieval readers. Finally some minds were “deeply enough impressed by its beauty and power to ask themselves whether the religion of Greece was indeed a rival of the religion of Christ; for the older gods had rehabilitated themselves, and men’s allegiance was divided.”
What’s striking about this story is that the middle stage is the one with the least belief in it. The demon stage took the gods dead seriously as beings, and the third stage takes them seriously again as possible bearers of truth, while the poetry stage in between treats them the way most of us treat them now, as terrific material for stories. That puts us in an odd spot, since the Olympians today star in bestselling kids’ novels, blockbuster movies and video games, and many readers or viewers enjoy the stories without fearing Zeus or praying to him. Pater’s real question is how a culture could get from that comfortable middle back to the third stage, where beauty starts to feel like a claim on you.
Pater’s answer for the fifteenth century is that it was “an impassioned age, so ardent and serious in its pursuit of art that it consecrated everything with which art had to do as a religious object,” and that Plato had given it a way of talking about the old gods with “something of the warmth and unction of a Christian hymn.” Then comes the line that carries the whole argument, that the age “was too familiar with such language to regard mythology as a mere story; and it was too serious to play with a religion.” Notice that the logic runs through seriousness rather than through evidence, since nobody had dug up proof that Apollo exists, but people who already treated art as sacred couldn’t treat the subject of their art as a toy, so the gods got promoted by association.
The other side deserves a real hearing here, because there’s a long tradition that says beauty is evidence. In the Phaedrus Socrates says that beauty shines more clearly through sight than the other things the soul once beheld, and Diotima’s ladder in the Symposium climbs from one beautiful body all the way to beauty itself. Christians walked the same road, and Augustine famously addresses God as a beauty both ancient and new that he came to love too late. On this view, if the stories of the Greek gods are lovely enough to move serious people the way a hymn does, that loveliness is a sign that something true is shining through them, and dismissing them as “mere story” would be a failure of perception.
Pico is the test case, and Pater describes him with a carefully chosen verb. “He is one of the last who seriously and sincerely entertained the claim on men’s faith of the pagan religions,” Pater says, and he is “anxious to ascertain the true significance of the obscurest legend, the lightest tradition concerning them.” To entertain a claim is to let it into the house and give it dinner and a hearing without handing over the keys, and that’s what Pico did. He read the Orphic hymns and the Chaldean oracles as carrying fragments of a truth that ran through every tradition, which is a way of taking the old religion seriously without worshiping anybody, and when he died he was buried in the hood and white frock of a Dominican friar, still a Christian.
So what can beauty actually do for an old religion, then? It can do quite a lot, as it turns out, starting with reversing the old moral verdict, because a song that makes someone weep can make the singer harder to dismiss as a demon. That helps explain the movement from Pater’s first stage to his third. It can also earn a tradition the kind of attention we give only to things that might be true. What it can’t do is settle the question of existence, since the loveliness of a story about Apollo tells you a great deal about the people who told it, and Plato’s argument that beauty points upward can’t say on its own whether the summit it points to is Apollo, the Christian God or an impersonal Form.
That’s why I think the divided allegiance of the fifteenth century was the honest position rather than a muddle. Pico let the old gods make their case, studied every scrap of their legends, and decided they were witnesses to the truth rather than its owners, and you can see a version of the same posture today in the person who never misses choral Evensong at the cathedral, for the music and the old words, without being sure she believes a line of the creed. Pater’s own century tended to collapse that position one way or the other, either into the polite agnostic who treats myth as pure ornament or into the convert who goes all the way to Rome, and his remark about an age “too serious to play with a religion” reads partly as a rebuke to his own time.
So can a beautiful old religion become credible again? It can, in the sense Pater cares about, which is credible enough to be entertained, studied and allowed to change the way you see, which is more than our culture grants the Greek gods when it sends them to the toy aisle. It can’t, in the stronger sense of credible enough to pray to, because beauty is a reason to keep listening and never by itself a reason to kneel. Pico exemplifies the first kind of credibility while remaining a Christian, which strikes me as more serious than either the demon-hunters who believed too much or the decorators who believed too little.
Test your understanding
Question 1 of 3
Why does the author describe Pater’s middle stage as having the least belief in the Greek gods?
Guided Inquiry
Questions for Socrates
Explore these questions with Socrates, with this Feature as your reading context.
- If beauty makes a religious tradition feel worthy of serious attention, what additional grounds would be needed before belief or worship became reasonable?→
- Does Pico’s position—treating pagan religions as witnesses to truth while remaining Christian—show intellectual openness, or does it prevent those religions from making their strongest possible claim? Why?→
- Why might treating myths purely as entertainment amount to believing “too little,” and what risks arise when a culture treats their beauty as religious evidence?→