Renaissance

Can a Type Still Be Somebody?

Pater says the Greek sculptor finds a type by looking closely and choosing what to keep. What does that leave of the person whose body the sculptor studied?

Francis Galton’s composite photographs make a useful contrast with the sculptor Pater describes. A figure can have a distinct shape without telling us the history of a particular life.

Orientation

At a Glance

  • A composite faceGalton superimposed portraits to find common features, making the resemblance to any single person less important.
  • Pater’s more deliberate selectionPater says sculptural breadth comes from repeated, careful observation and a decision about which features to emphasize.
  • Small differences surviveThe turn from one curve to the next can distinguish one figure from another without requiring a strongly marked expression.
  • What the type leaves outPater’s young figures can retain a distinctive bodily shape while giving the viewer few clues about a particular life.

In an 1878 paper, Francis Galton described a way to expose several portraits on the same plate to bring out what he took to be a group’s typical features. He found some of the composite faces better-looking than the individual ones. The method produced an average image without requiring a photographer to decide which contour mattered. Galton’s method is a perfect example of what Pater says Greek generality is not. Hellenic breadth, he insists, has “nothing in common with the lax observation, the unlearned thought, the flaccid execution” of art that calls itself broad, because it comes “of a culture minute, severe, constantly renewed, rectifying and concentrating its impressions into certain pregnant types.”

So the claim is that breadth is earned by close attention rather than by blurring. Sculpture, Pater says, can’t build elaborate situations the way poetry can, so it chooses “types intrinsically interesting” and presents them “in their broad, central, incisive lines,” and “This it effects not by accumulation of detail, but by abstracting from it.” Everything “accidental” and every trace “of the commonness of the world” gets purged away. The question this raises is whether a type made that way can keep any individuality, or whether purging the accidents also purges the person.

The skeptic’s case is easy to make, and Pater supplies some of it himself. Greek ideal heads can look alike, with the same straight profile, the same calm mouth and the same unseeing eyes, and he admits that “To all but the highest culture, the reserved faces of the gods will ever have something of insipidity.” He also says the victorious youth in Berlin is “characterless, so far as character involves subjection to the accidental influences of life.” If character comes from the accidents of a life, the scars, habits and expressions it leaves behind, then a type without accidents seems to be a type without character, and calling it an individual looks like a trick of words.

Pater’s answer comes in his treatment of restraint and of youth. The Greek ideal “keeps passion always below that degree of intensity at which it must necessarily be transitory, never winding up the features to one note of anger, or desire, or surprise.” That avoids the opposite failure from Galton’s average, which Pater calls the grotesque, the face that wears “the sharp impress of one absorbing motive,” like a caricature that shrinks a person to a single trait. The comparison with caricature cuts both ways for Pater. A difference from the average can make a face recognizable, while exaggerating that difference can make one trait swallow the person. Pater wants the type to keep some of the distinction without making it the whole point.

The youthful figures Pater describes show how that balance works in practice. Greek sculpture, Pater says, deals mostly with youth, “where the moulding of the bodily organs is still as if suspended between growth and completion, indicated but not emphasised,” where the shift “from curve to curve is so delicate and elusive” that Winckelmann compared it to a quiet sea, moving and calm at once. That’s individuality pitched as fine variation, the particular way one body’s contours turn, and it takes exactly the “minute, severe” attention Pater demands to see it or to make it. Two youthful marble bodies that look identical at a glance can differ in a hundred small transitions, the way two good recordings of the same song differ in breath and timing.

So Pater’s demand for severe attention does real work in this argument. A sculptor who simply averaged would produce Galton’s composite, and a sculptor who simply copied a model would produce a portrait full of accidents, while the Greek procedure, as Pater describes it, involves looking at many bodies with great care and then concentrating what’s essential in them, the way a writer revises a sentence until every word carries weight. The result is a type in the sense of a concentrated example, and a concentrated example still has a shape of its own.

What gets lost in the process is biography, and Pater doesn’t hide it. His types have bodies that are individual in their modulations and faces that tell you nothing about anyone’s history, and he says so when he calls the Berlin youth “characterless.” That’s a real cost, and it helps explain why Pater values painting and poetry for what they can show of grief, habit and circumstance. A novelist can spend three hundred pages showing how a marriage hardens a woman’s mouth, while the sculptor Pater admires would put a different kind of information into a face.

My verdict is that generality can preserve individuality of one kind but not another. Breadth earned by close attention keeps the particular form, the specific curve and balance that make one body unlike another, while it gives up the particular life, the scars and expressions that make a person somebody in a story. Pater is honest about the trade, and his distinction between concentration and averaging is the key to it, since the Greek type stays a someone in its body, even after the sculptor has removed every trace of where that someone has been.

Test your understanding

123

Question 1 of 3

Why does the article contrast Pater’s Greek type with Galton’s composite image?

Choose one answer

Guided Inquiry

Questions for Socrates

Explore these questions with Socrates, with this Feature as your reading context.