Philosophy
Burned Up and Fired Up
A glimpse sends Socrates reeling. When Charmides agrees with him about medicine, he feels himself catch fire again.
The Platonic Dialogues: CharmidesSocrates catches fire twice in the opening pages, once from desire and once from confidence. The second fire echoes the first, and the change from one fire to the other shows what a conversation can do with a man’s energy.
Orientation
At a Glance
- The first fireSocrates has already lost his confidence when he glimpses inside Charmides’ cloak. He describes the rush of desire as being set on fire.
- The second fireCharmides agrees that a good doctor treats a part together with the whole body. Hearing him assent, Socrates says his courage gathers again and he is rekindled.
- A change in directionSocrates can now tell the story of the Thracian doctor and his cure for the soul. He still praises Charmides’ looks later in the conversation.
- Heat that helps wings growIn the Phaedrus, a beautiful face warms the lover and helps the soul’s wings grow. The image gives another way to understand what desire’s heat can do.
The first fire comes as Charmides is about to ask about his headache. Charmides sits down, gives Socrates a look, the gym crowds round, and Socrates sees inside the boy’s cloak and tells his friend, “I was on fire, and was no longer in my own possession,” and the verb makes it sound like a blaze that takes over a building. A moment earlier, he says, the boldness he walked in with, “sure as I was that I would talk to him with the greatest of ease,” had been knocked clean out of him, so this first fire comes after a collapse of confidence and makes it worse, scattering him so thoroughly that he’s no longer, in his own words, his own.
The second fire comes a little later, and it’s easy to read past. Socrates explains to the boy the principle that good doctors follow, that you can’t treat the eyes without the head or the head without the whole body, and asks whether that sounds right, and Charmides says, “Absolutely.” Then Socrates tells us, “When I heard his approval I took heart again; little by little my boldness began to gather itself together, and I was rekindled.” The Greek verb for “rekindled” means to blow on embers until they flare back into flame, so the second fire calls the first one to mind.
What restarted the fire is the key detail, and Plato is careful to spell it out. The first blaze came from a glimpse, from looking, while the second comes from a yes, from the boy agreeing with an idea, and what returns with it is the very boldness Socrates had lost just before the first fire. In the first scene Charmides was something to look at, and in the second he’s someone thinking alongside Socrates, and that small shift is enough to turn panic into purpose. It’s the feeling every teacher knows, of standing in front of a class flustered and off balance until one student nods at the point you’re making, and suddenly you’ve got your footing back and you’re off.
The second fire is a rekindling. It calls the first one to mind even as Socrates gets his footing back. Socrates keeps complimenting the boy, telling him a little later that “as for what can be seen of your looks,” he falls short of none of his ancestors, so the heat of attraction still seems to be there in the room, even as his energy goes into the conversation. Plato makes the link between the two fires impossible to miss, since a reader who has just watched Socrates go up in flames can hardly hear the word “rekindled” without remembering what the first fire was about.
Plato has a famous picture of exactly this in the Phaedrus. There, when the lover sees a beautiful face, the stream of beauty pouring in through his eyes warms him, and that warmth softens the hardened places where the soul’s wings once grew, so that the wings start sprouting again, which is painful and thrilling at the same time. Desire’s heat, in the Phaedrus, isn’t something to be put out but the fuel the soul needs to grow its wings and rise, and the Charmides shows a small, comic version of that, a man burned by beauty whose heat gets rerouted into the energy to think out loud.
The two fires also do opposite things to the man they burn. The first one scatters Socrates, leaving him beside himself and grabbing for a line of verse to hold on to, while the second one gathers him, since his boldness, as he puts it, “began to gather itself together.” It’s the same heat working in two directions, like the nervous energy before a performance that either freezes you in the wings or turns into presence the moment you step on stage and start doing the thing you came to do. The first fire takes Socrates out of himself and the second gathers him back in, which is the difference between a fire that burns a house down and the fire in its hearth that keeps it warm.
You can see the second fire in what Socrates says next, because he takes off. He launches into the story of the Thracian doctors of Zalmoxis, “who are said even to make one immortal,” and their teaching that everything good and bad flows from the soul, and that the soul is treated with charms made of “beautiful words.” It’s one of the most confident and eloquent speeches in the dialogue, and it comes from a man who moments earlier couldn’t find his own head. Even the subject of the speech, a doctor who heals the whole person, fits a man who has just been put back together himself.
My verdict is that Plato doesn’t stage a cure from desire, he stages a conversion of heat. The philosopher doesn’t get colder as the conversation starts, he gets better aimed, and the hint is in the word “rekindled,” which lets us hear the second fire as an echo of the first. Conversation, on this showing, doesn’t put a man’s energy out, it reorganizes it, and the Charmides is honest enough to leave the first fire smoldering in the background while the second one does the talking. Anyone who watches both fires learns that the real question isn’t whether a person feels the heat but what he does with it.
Test your understanding
Question 1 of 3
What most directly causes Socrates to be “rekindled” after his initial loss of confidence?
Guided Inquiry
Questions for Socrates
Explore these questions with Socrates, with this Feature as your reading context.
- Why does Charmides’ agreement restore Socrates’ confidence when Charmides’ appearance had previously overwhelmed it? What does this suggest about the role of mutual participation in thought?→
- Is the article justified in treating both episodes as forms of the same “heat,” or could the first fire and the rekindling represent fundamentally different experiences?→
- If philosophical conversation redirects desire rather than eliminating it, what might distinguish a successful conversion of heat from a failed one?→