Renaissance

Buried in a Habit He Never Took

Pico dies before entering the Dominican order and is buried in its habit. Pater sets the burial beside Pico’s lasting sympathy for the old gods.

The early biography recalls a vocation Pico put off. Pater gives the white habit another meaning by placing it alongside the learning and the pagan figures Pico carried into the last years of his life.

Orientation

At a Glance

  • The habit comes after deathPico is buried in the Dominican hood and white garment at San Marco. Pater says explicitly that he did not become a friar in life.
  • The early biography tells of a vocationPico tells his nephew of a plan to preach barefoot and later resolves to become a Dominican. The biography reports Savonarola’s view that he put off the call.
  • Pater adapts WordsworthWordsworth asks for his days to be joined by natural piety. Pater applies the wish to the continuity of whole ages, including the passage from pagan to Christian culture.
  • The arrangement makes the tension visibleThe Dominican clothes and the likeness to a pagan divinity belong to the same portrait. Pater’s wording makes them coexist without settling how Pico experienced that tension.

Pater builds his ending from three statements, placed close together. First, “With many thoughts and many influences which led him in that direction, he did not become a monk; only he became gentle and patient in disputation.” Second, “He was buried in the conventual church of Saint Mark, in the hood and white frock of the Dominican order.” Third, and most elaborately, it is because “the life of Pico, thus lying down to rest in the Dominican habit, yet amid thoughts of the older gods, himself like one of those comely divinities,” is “so perfect a parallel to the attempt made in his writings to reconcile Christianity with the ideas of paganism, that Pico, in spite of the scholastic character of those writings, is really interesting.” The life, in other words, is offered as the reconciliation his books never achieved.

An early account gives a more troubled picture. In Thomas More’s translation of the nephew’s biography, Pico tells his nephew that once certain books are finished he means to give his property to the poor and, “fencing myself with the crucifix, barefoot walking about the world in every town and castle,” preach Christ. Later, More says, he resolved instead to profess himself in the order of Friars Preachers, the Dominicans. He died before doing either, and the biography reports that Savonarola preached about a vocation Pico had deferred and said that he was undergoing a period of purgatory.

The reported sermon changes how the white habit looks. For Savonarola, as the biography presents him, the story of Pico’s vocation includes a delay and its consequences. He also credits Pico’s prayers and alms. The habit at burial can be read as the sign of an intention that life left unfinished.

What, then, about the thoughts of the older gods that Pater gathers around the end? His phrase “yet amid thoughts of the older gods” puts them at the deathbed, but the record of Pico’s last years points elsewhere, toward Savonarola, toward the plan to preach barefoot and toward his long attack on astrology, which defended human freedom against the stars. It’s true that he never stopped using his pagan learning, and Pater also recounts Pico’s charitable work through Benivieni, including help with marriage dowries. More’s life says that he asked his friend to relieve needy people on his behalf. But the image of a dying man surrounded by thoughts of Apollo is Pater’s staging, and the record supplies the friars and the sacraments instead.

Pater’s method shows most clearly in his borrowing from Wordsworth. He says Pico was “desirous literally to ‘bind the ages each to each by natural piety’” and the edition’s note points out the change. Wordsworth’s poem “My Heart Leaps Up”, written in 1802, ends with the wish, “And I could wish my days to be / Bound each to each by natural piety,” meaning one man’s hope that his grown-up life would stay faithful to the child who loved rainbows. Pater swaps days for ages, turning a private continuity into a civilization’s continuity with its pagan past, and adds the word literally to suggest that Pico tried to do with history what Wordsworth hoped to do with a single life.

Then look at the image of the body itself, “himself like one of those comely divinities.” The chapter opened with Heine’s exiled gods, hiding in humble disguises after Christianity triumphed, Apollo working as a shepherd until his singing gave him away. Now it closes with a beautiful young man laid out in a friar’s habit and compared to one of those same gods, so the Dominican frock becomes, in Pater’s arrangement, one more disguise worn by an exiled divinity. It’s a superb piece of composition, the chapter folded back on itself, and it’s the clearest evidence that the reconciliation is being made on the page.

The other side has a real case, and it shouldn’t be brushed aside. A life can hold two loyalties without a formal treaty between them, and Pico’s did, since the man who walked toward Savonarola’s cloister still wrote his last major work with all of Plato and the ancients at his elbow and kept bringing his reading of ancient philosophy to bear on the questions that occupied him. Pater doesn’t claim he became a pagan, only that he was “reconciled indeed to the new religion, but still with a tenderness for the earlier life.” Tenderness is a modest word, and it fits the evidence better than the rest of Pater’s grand sentence does.

My verdict is that the reconciliation belongs mostly to Pater’s arrangement, to the juxtaposition of habit and gods, the swap of days for ages and the corpse compared to a comely divinity, while the life supplied something rawer, a deferred vocation and a love of learning that held him in the world a little too long for his confessor’s comfort. Pater turns the story of an unfinished vocation into a portrait with room for both loyalties. The white habit draws them into a single image while the earlier account lets us feel how uneasy they could be in life.

Test your understanding

123

Question 1 of 3

How does the early biographical account most significantly alter the meaning of Pico’s Dominican burial habit?

Choose one answer

Guided Inquiry

Questions for Socrates

Explore these questions with Socrates, with this Feature as your reading context.