Renaissance
Bodies That Sink Into Their Tombs
Pater reads a quiet withdrawal from life in Tuscan tomb sculpture. A comparison with Canterbury shows how differently a tomb can ask viewers to look at a dead body.
The Renaissance (1893)Luca’s bishop lies still within a border of glazed flowers. Pater’s account of shallow carving helps explain how that stillness can feel like a body receding from sight.
Orientation
At a Glance
- Pater starts with depthHe sees habits of low relief in Tuscan sculpture even when the effigy itself is more fully carved. To his eye, the restraint makes the body feel as if it is receding.
- Luca sets stillness inside a living borderThe marble bishop lies beneath a relief of the dead Christ. The glazed flowers around him make the difference between the body and its setting more visible.
- Canterbury stages a sharper contrastHenry Chichele’s tomb presents the archbishop in his robes above a cadaver. It brings bodily decay directly into view.
- Quiet and individuality can coexistIn the tomb of Medea Colleoni, Pater singles out the length of her throat. The detail gives the effigy a particular character within its repose.
The Renaissance · Luca della Robbia, p. 47, effigies and the wasting of death · Luca della Robbia, note 116 · Luca della Robbia, pp. 50–51, tombs and subdued repose · Luca della Robbia, note 124 · Luca della Robbia, note 125
Pater’s sentence on Tuscan tombs is one of the most suggestive in the Luca essay. These sculptors “worked for the most part in low relief,” he says, “giving even to their monumental effigies something of its depression of surface, getting into them by this means a pathetic suggestion of the wasting and etherealisation of death.” The edition’s note reads “pathetic” in its older sense, moving or full of pathos rather than pitiful, and the claim is that a technical habit, keeping carved surfaces close to their ground, carries over into full-length figures of the dead and makes their bodies seem to be thinning out on the way to becoming spirit.
The Florentine wall tomb of the period gives the claim its test cases. An influential example is Bernardo Rossellino’s monument to Leonardo Bruni in Santa Croce, where the dead man lies on a bier tilted toward the viewer beneath a classical arch, holding the book he wrote, while the epitaph by his successor Carlo Marsuppini announces that since Leonardo left this life history mourns and eloquence has fallen silent, and the pattern spread through the city’s churches over the next decades. These effigies are carved as full figures, but Pater’s point is that the carving stays restrained even there, with the body’s forms kept close under the drapery, so the dead look less like sleepers about to wake than like figures quietly settling into the marble.
Luca made one tomb of this kind himself, and it’s the natural place to look. His monument to Benozzo Federighi, bishop of Fiesole, was commissioned in 1454 for San Pancrazio and moved to Santa Trinita in 1896. It shows the bishop in a restful pose on an antique-style sarcophagus, where two angels hold a wreath around the inscription, with a half-length relief of the dead Christ between Mary and John above him. The whole marble ensemble is framed by flat glazed tiles painted with flowers and fruit against a gilded ground, so the stillness of the white bishop sits inside a border that never stops blooming.
What the Federighi tomb shows is that the “wasting” Pater sees is a matter of handling rather than horror. Nothing in the effigy decays and nothing is emaciated, and yet the figure is laid out so evenly and calmly that the body reads as something already half withdrawn from the world, while the painted flowers around it do the living. The tomb has lost some of its gilding and its original high base. The contrast between figure and floral border is still clear, with life crowding the edges and the person in the middle growing faint.
A fifteenth-century tomb at Canterbury gives a different treatment. The monument to Archbishop Henry Chichele shows the dead body under a second effigy, with the archbishop in his vestments above and his naked, shrunken corpse below. Those monuments make death visible by showing decay outright, as a sermon on vanity you can’t look away from, while Pater’s Tuscans make it visible by subtraction, letting the restraint of the carving suggest a body thinning toward spirit, so the same subject gets a shout in Canterbury and a whisper in Florence.
Pater’s own examples, glossed in the edition’s notes, show how far the method reached. Mino da Fiesole’s tomb in the Badia of Florence for Ugo, a margrave of Tuscany who’d been dead for nearly five hundred years, gives a medieval founder the same quiet Renaissance effigy, and the tomb of Medea Colleoni, carved by Giovanni Antonio Amadeo and now in her father’s chapel in Bergamo, shows the effect working on the body of a daughter. Pater praises monuments like these for their “suggestions of repose, of a subdued sabbatic joy,” which tells you the wasting he sees isn’t grim, since it comes wrapped in a kind of Sunday calm.
The technique works because of how people read depth. A figure carved deep, with strong shadows under the arms and around the face, looks solid and present, like a living person lying down for a nap, while a figure kept close to its ground, with soft transitions and little shadow, looks lighter and less there, the way a face seen through gauze looks farther away than it is. By reducing projection, the sculptor makes the body seem to retreat from you even though it’s right in front of you, and that retreat is what Pater calls etherealisation, a body visibly on its way out of the physical world without any sign of physical ruin.
My verdict is that Pater’s claim holds, as long as you read it as a description of deliberate restraint rather than an accident of style. Reduced projection makes the approach of death visible by letting the dead fade instead of rot, and the Tuscan tomb, from Rossellino’s Bruni to Luca’s Federighi, makes Pater’s idea of etherealisation a question of how deep the chisel goes. It’s a gentler theology than Canterbury’s corpse, and maybe a less honest one about what death does to flesh, but it’s the reason these monuments still move people who walk past them without reading a word of their inscriptions.
Test your understanding
Question 1 of 3
According to the article, how does reduced projection create the impression of “etherealisation” in a tomb effigy?
Guided Inquiry
Questions for Socrates
Explore these questions with Socrates, with this Feature as your reading context.
- Does the Tuscan method of making the dead appear to fade rather than decay offer a deeper understanding of death, or does it avoid death’s physical reality? Why?→
- How does the contrast between the still white bishop and the blooming floral border shape your interpretation of the Federighi tomb as a whole?→
- If sculptural depth can make a figure seem either present or withdrawn, what does that suggest about the relationship between artistic technique and theological meaning?→