Renaissance
Beauty, Defined One Painter at a Time
For Pater, a definition should help you see what curiosity and a desire for beauty do in Leonardo’s work.
The Renaissance (1893)Pater exchanges the universal formula for a description of one kind of beauty. Leonardo shows how a critic can make such a description precise enough for another viewer to test.
Orientation
At a Glance
- A formula for one kindThe Preface asks critics to describe a particular kind of beauty in terms precise enough to use. Pater thinks a universal definition is too abstract to help with that work.
- Two forces in LeonardoPater sees curiosity and the desire for beauty working together in Leonardo. He calls the grace that results subtle and curious.
- A description readers can testWhen curiosity crowds out grace, Pater thinks the work can look strained. Other viewers can use that claim to compare paintings and drawings for themselves.
- A limit to comparisonThe formula can help readers compare works by Leonardo. A different painter’s work may call for a different account of what makes it beautiful.
The Renaissance · Preface, pp. 2–3 · Preface, note 3 · Introduction, p. iv · Leonardo da Vinci, p. 74 · Leonardo da Vinci, p. 76
The Preface’s opening paragraph ends with a goal that sounds like a contradiction. “To define beauty, not in the most abstract but in the most concrete terms possible, to find, not its universal formula, but the formula which expresses most adequately this or that special manifestation of it, is the aim of the true student of æsthetics.” A formula is usually the opposite of a particular, since chemistry writes formulas for water, not for this glass of water, and a definition is supposed to cover every case. Pater wants both at once, a formula with the precision of science aimed at one kind of beauty, and the discussion question is how concrete you can make a definition before it stops being one.
His reason for trying comes in the sentence just before. “Beauty, like all other qualities presented to human experience, is relative; and the definition of it becomes unmeaning and useless in proportion to its abstractness.” So the more general your definition, the less it can tell you about anything you actually love, and the edition’s note on that sentence draws out the consequence, that a critic asks what a particular object does in a particular encounter and describes the effect closely enough for others to examine it. The introduction says the same in plainer words, that an impression is only a beginning and the critic still has to point to something another reader or viewer can check.
So what would one of these formulas look like? Pater gives you a clean example in the Leonardo chapter, where he names “Curiosity and the desire of beauty” as the two forces in the painter’s genius, “curiosity often in conflict with the desire of beauty, but generating, in union with it, a type of subtle and curious grace.” Look at the structure, because it has two ingredients, a relation between them that can go two ways, and a product with a name. That’s a formula in a real sense, concrete because it lists parts and says how they bond, and particular because it describes Leonardo’s kind of beauty and nobody else’s. It works the way a scouting report on a pitcher works, useless as a definition of pitching, but very good at telling you what this guy throws.
A good formula of this kind can also be tested, because it predicts where things go wrong. If Leonardo’s grace comes from curiosity and desire in union, then his weaker moments should be the ones where curiosity wins, and that’s exactly what Pater reports, saying that “sometimes this curiosity came in conflict with the desire of beauty,” and that “often the expression of physical beauty at this or that point seems strained and marred in the effort.” Another viewer can take that to the drawings and the paintings and check it, picking out where the grace is subtle and where it looks overworked. A definition that sorts its own subject’s work into better and worse is doing something no universal formula of beauty has ever managed.
That also answers the worry about the single encounter. Pater asks for the formula of a “special manifestation” of beauty, and a manifestation in his sense isn’t one Tuesday afternoon at the Louvre, since it can be a kind of beauty that keeps showing up across a body of work. On that reading, Leonardo’s formula gives us something to look for in the drawings, the Last Supper, and the Mona Lisa. A formula for one encounter would just be a diary entry. The other side has a point, though, because the Preface keeps stressing how unique each impression is, and a reader could fairly ask whether Pater’s formulas sometimes smuggle in a generality he officially rejects.
I’d answer that the generality is limited and earned. Leonardo’s formula generalizes over Leonardo, not over beauty, and that’s the sweet spot, wide enough to be tested on many works and narrow enough to tell you something about each. Go any narrower and you can’t test it, because there’s only one case, and go any wider and you’re back to the universal formula that tells you nothing about any picture you care about. The skill Pater is asking for is finding the right level, the way a good friend can describe your sense of humor in one sentence that fits a hundred of your jokes and wouldn’t fit anyone else’s.
There is one thing the concrete formula can’t do, and Pater knows it. His first paragraph complained that abstract theories don’t help us “to discriminate between what is more and what is less excellent,” and the concrete formula fixes that only within a manifestation. It tells you which Leonardo is better Leonardo, but it can’t tell you whether Leonardo beats Botticelli, because each formula only measures its own kind of beauty. Pater accepts that cost openly a page later, when he says the critic treats every period, type and school of taste as equal in itself, which means the ranking his method gives up is the ranking across kinds.
So how concrete can a definition of beauty be? About as concrete as a scouting report, naming its ingredients, saying how they combine, pointing to where you can see them and predicting what failure will look like. At that level Pater’s “formula” for one manifestation is legit, and I think it’s more useful than the universal kind, since you can actually walk into a gallery with it. It loses its value only if it shrinks to a single encounter, which Leonardo’s formula has room to avoid, and the price of the whole approach is giving up a master ranking of all beauty, a price Pater pays without flinching and most of us should be willing to pay too.
Test your understanding
Question 1 of 3
Why does the article consider Leonardo’s formula concrete without reducing it to a description of a single artwork?
Guided Inquiry
Questions for Socrates
Explore these questions with Socrates, with this Feature as your reading context.
- What should determine whether a formula is specific enough to illuminate an artist’s work but broad enough to remain testable?→
- If every kind of beauty must be judged by its own formula, on what grounds—if any—could a critic meaningfully compare different artists or schools?→
- Does requiring critics to point to features that others can examine adequately address the uniqueness of individual impressions? Why or why not?→