Philosophy
Back Through the School Day
Socrates goes from copying letters to playing the lyre to wrestling. The examples take Charmides through a familiar education and put its lessons in competition.
The Platonic Dialogues: CharmidesA boy can learn to walk quietly to his lesson and play the lyre quickly once he gets there. Socrates’ list makes those two lessons pull against each other.
Orientation
At a Glance
- A familiar sequenceSocrates starts with writing and reading, then brings in the lyre, wrestling and other athletics. The sequence echoes the schooling Protagoras describes.
- Why the questions are easy to answerCharmides can readily say which performance he admires at a writing lesson or on the wrestling floor. Those familiar judgments give Socrates something to build an argument from.
- Schooling has two aimsProtagoras says parents ask teachers to put good behavior ahead of letters and music. Charmides’ orderly manners fit that aim, while Socrates’ examples reward quickness and skill.
- The class moves inwardSocrates turns from the body to learning, memory and deliberation. He finally asks Charmides to look within himself, where a list of accomplished performances can only take him so far.
If you read Socrates’ examples quickly, they sound like a random pile of activities, but the sequence has a familiar shape. It takes you from a writing lesson to music and then athletics. The first stop is the writing-master’s, where Socrates asks whether it’s finer “to copy out the letters quickly, or quietly,” and then comes reading, then playing the lyre and wrestling, then boxing and the pancration, a combat event that combined the two, and then running and jumping. It’s something like an Athenian boy’s schooling, from the letters teacher to the music teacher to the coach at the wrestling school. Socrates walks Charmides through it room by room.
Protagoras describes a similar education in the dialogue that bears his name. Once boys have learned their letters, they read and memorize the poets. Music masters teach them the lyre and another set of poets. A trainer prepares their bodies to carry out what their minds decide, so they can hold up in war and other duties. Protagoras adds that the wealthiest families can provide the most schooling. Charmides is sitting in a wrestling school while Socrates quizzes him about wrestling. Even without a record of the boy’s own lessons, we can hear how close the examples are to his world. When Socrates asks whether reading is better done quickly or slowly, the boy is ready to answer. “Quickly.”
That familiarity is what makes the argument run so smoothly. Socrates usually builds his arguments out of what the other person already believes, and here the examples take him through activities the boy can readily picture. The nimble wrestler lands the move and the fluent reader gets through the line. The questions are easy to answer at first. By the time the list reaches the mind, it’s asking about learning easily, teaching, remembering and “understanding what is said, at the writing-master’s and the lyre-master’s and everywhere else,” and the boy goes on agreeing. The argument even circles back to the classroom near the end, after moving from physical skill to the work of the mind.
There’s an irony buried in this, because Protagoras gives the teachers another task alongside letters, music and athletics. In Protagoras’ account, parents told the teachers to care much more about the children’s good behavior, their eukosmia or orderliness, than about their letters and their lyre playing, and the lyre teachers in particular were supposed to look after the boys’ temperance, settling rhythm and harmony into their souls so they’d grow gentler and better tuned. So when Charmides says temperance is doing everything “in an orderly way and quietly,” he sounds like someone who has taken the lesson in orderly conduct to heart. Socrates tests that answer with a set of equally familiar lessons in skill.
You can see why the boy’s manners lose that fight. A lot of these skills give you something plain to judge. A letter is copied well or badly, a wrestler throws his opponent or doesn’t, and a boy remembers his lines or forgets them. Walking quietly to the lyre teacher’s house has no finish line and no opponent. Socrates’ choice of examples makes it easier to see what quickness can do than to say what orderly conduct is for.
That’s the restriction the schoolroom frame puts on the whole discussion. Many of the opening examples are things a teacher or a judge could watch. Even as Socrates turns to memory and deliberation, he asks Charmides to say which sort of performance people praise. Think of temperance at a dinner where the wine keeps coming, or in the decision to wait when you badly want to act. Those cases ask what a person chooses, even if nobody is watching to say how he did.
To be fair to Socrates, starting from the familiar is good teaching, and he doesn’t stay there. After the body he turns to the soul, and after the soul he asks the boy to “pay closer attention and look within yourself,” so the schoolroom is a starting point rather than the whole story, the way a good teacher opens with examples a student already knows before asking for something harder. The schoolroom examples also teach a real lesson, which is that a virtue can’t be tied to one tempo, since some of the actions he lists are admirable when they’re done quickly. Familiar lessons let Socrates show Charmides where his answer runs out. Now he can ask what all those lessons were meant to cultivate.
My verdict is that the schoolroom order is both the argument’s secret weapon and its blind spot. It makes the boy’s agreement come easily, because the early questions ask about things he can picture. Socrates can turn judgments about skill against judgments about manners. It also puts the weight on the things people can see and praise. The school in Protagoras’ account meant to cultivate temperance all along. In the wrestling school, it turns out that doing well at the lessons still leaves Charmides with a question no report card can answer.
Test your understanding
Question 1 of 3
Why does the article describe the schoolroom sequence as Socrates’ “secret weapon” in the argument?
Guided Inquiry
Questions for Socrates
Explore these questions with Socrates, with this Feature as your reading context.
- If familiar examples make an argument easier to accept, how can a learner tell whether those examples illuminate the subject or quietly narrow it?→
- What would Charmides need to examine within himself that could not be measured by a teacher, judge, or report card?→
- If schools aim to cultivate temperance as well as skill, what kinds of examples or questions could reveal whether that aim has been achieved?→