Philosophy

Back from the War, Straight to the Gym

The city wants a war story. Socrates wants to know what keeps its young people—and their minds—safe.

Two young men in warm red, softly blurred light, one in profile on the left and the other seen from behind on the right.

Socrates gets home from a brutal campaign, and all anyone wants is the casualty report. What he does with that hunger tells you what the whole dialogue is about.

Orientation

At a Glance

  • The SettingCharmides 153a–154a; 176c–d
  • The Central QuestionSocrates gets back from the siege at Potidaea one evening, and the very next day, instead of sleeping in, he heads straight for his old hangout, the wrestling-school of Taureas, wh
  • A Closer LookIt’s a fair thing to ask, because word had just reached Athens that there’d been a big fight at Potidaea, very heavy, with a lot of people they knew among the dead.
  • The Wider ViewThe crowd obviously wants more, so Chaerephon sits him down next to Critias and tells him to give them everything, because they “still haven’t got the whole story straight,” and So

Socrates gets back from the siege at Potidaea one evening, and the very next day, instead of sleeping in, he heads straight for his old hangout, the wrestling-school of Taureas, which was basically the neighborhood gym. The place is packed, and half the room spots him and starts shouting hello from across the floor, while his buddy Chaerephon, “madman that he is,” as Socrates puts it with real affection, jumps up, sprints over, grabs his hand and asks the only question anybody cares about, “Socrates, how did you come out of the battle alive?”

It’s a fair thing to ask, because word had just reached Athens that there’d been a big fight at Potidaea, very heavy, with a lot of people they knew among the dead. Socrates confirms it about as dryly as a person can, telling him “The word is reasonably accurate,” and when he’s asked how he himself made it out, all he says is “Like this, as you see,” which is the entire war story he’s prepared to tell. We know from Plato’s Symposium what Socrates actually did out there, because Alcibiades tells us he walked barefoot through the northern winter, saved Alcibiades’ life in battle, and then lobbied the generals to give the prize for bravery to Alcibiades instead of himself. The man has a legit hero story, and what he gives the room is “as you see,” standing there being alive and letting that be the answer.

The crowd obviously wants more, so Chaerephon sits him down next to Critias and tells him to give them everything, because they “still haven’t got the whole story straight,” and Socrates ends up doing a kind of press conference, answering whatever anyone asks while everybody asks something different. What’s wild is that Plato gives this entire Q&A a single sentence. If you came to the Charmides for a war story you’re out of luck, because all you get is the shape of the scene, questions flying in from every side and answers on demand, until Socrates wraps it up with the line “When we had had our fill of all that, I asked them my own questions in turn about things here at home.”

Hold on to that “had our fill,” because the Greek is the expression you’d use for eating until you’re stuffed, which makes the war news something the room consumes. Plato isn’t sneering at them for it, since these guys have friends on the casualty list and of course they want details, but watch what happens a few minutes later when the hottest kid in Athens walks in. The same crowd that swarmed Socrates now swarms the boy, everybody on the bench shoving the guy next to him to make room until one man has to stand up and another gets knocked off the end sideways, which is the same energy pointed at a new target. Attention in this room works like an appetite that chases whatever’s newest and shiniest until it’s full, and it’s worth keeping that in mind, because the virtue this dialogue is about, sōphrosynē, temperance, is pretty much the virtue of not being run by that appetite.

That’s when Socrates flips the conversation, asking how philosophy is doing these days and whether any of the young guys have turned out outstanding “in wisdom, or in beauty, or in both.” It looks like a change of subject, as if the philosopher got bored with the war talk and wanted to get back to his own thing, but I don’t buy that reading. Go back to Chaerephon’s first question, “how did you come out of the battle alive,” and you’ll find that the Greek verb is about being kept safe, and that it comes from the same root, sōs, “safe” or “sound,” that sits right inside the word sōphrosynē. Plato plays on this himself in the Cratylus, where temperance gets explained as the safekeeping of good sense. So the room asked who made it home safe, and Socrates is asking the same thing about the city, namely what’s been kept sound back here while everybody was off fighting.

The answer walks right in the door. Critias looks over, sees a bunch of young guys coming in trading insults with a whole crowd behind them, and tells Socrates that as for the beautiful ones, he’s about to find out, because these are “the advance guard and the lovers” of the boy who’s thought the most beautiful, “at the moment, anyway.” That word “advance guard” was the army’s term for the scouts who rode out ahead of a column, which is a cheeky thing to say to a guy fresh off the front, and “at the moment, anyway” is doing a lot of work too. Beauty in this town runs like the news cycle, with a top story and a top boy, both spread by rumor, both devoured by the crowd and both replaceable by next week. Socrates has just handled one kind of report with total calm, and now he’s going to put the other kind under the microscope.

Plato’s first readers would have felt the next part in their stomachs. Critias, the guy Chaerephon so politely seats Socrates beside, will turn out to be the leading figure among the Thirty, the oligarchs who ran Athens by terror in 404/3, and Charmides, the kid with the entourage, will become one of their Ten in charge of the Piraeus. Xenophon tells us both of them died at Munychia in 403, fighting the democrats of their own city. The dialogue never says a word about any of it, and it doesn’t have to, because it opens with a battle that has just killed a lot of people the room knew and closes with a joke about force, Charmides telling Socrates, on Critias’ orders, that he can “count on force” if he tries to resist.

So the war at the start isn’t background noise you skim to get to the philosophy, since it’s what sets the stakes for everything after it. A man comes home from a war and the city asks what cities always ask after a war, who survived and how they made it. Socrates takes that same question and aims it at the future, asking which of these kids are turning out well and what it would actually take to keep a mind safe. The room got its fill of the first question in one sentence, and the rest of the dialogue is about how much harder the second one is to answer.

Test your understanding

123

Question 1 of 3

Why does the author reject the idea that Socrates simply changes the subject when he asks about philosophy and the young men of Athens?

Choose one answer

Guided Inquiry

Questions for Socrates

Explore these questions with Socrates, with this Feature as your reading context.