Renaissance
An Hour of Play Can Teach a Person to Listen
For Pater, a story read aloud or a masque can free the attention we spend all day on work.
The Renaissance (1893)Bandello’s stories, Venetian festival costumes and a gleam of white linen give Pater’s idea of play a visible form.
Orientation
At a Glance
- Life as listeningPater places a story read aloud, music and the sound of water among the things worth attending to.
- The work of playPlay can call on our best abilities while giving everyday obligations less claim on our attention.
- A costume marks a changeThe masque gives its participants a shared occasion to set aside their ordinary roles.
- White linen catches the lightThe fabric at wrist and throat gives the painter a small place to show what careful looking can see.
The Renaissance · The School of Giorgione, listening, play and costume · Note 232, Bandello’s tales · Matteo Bandello, Novelle II.9, Romeo and Giulietta · Carpaccio, Arrival of the Ambassadors, Gallerie dell’Accademia
Pater sums up Giorgione’s favorite subjects in one sentence that does a lot of work. In them, he says, “life itself is conceived as a sort of listening,” and he lists the things people listen to, “music,” “the reading of Bandello’s novels,” “the sound of water,” and “time as it flies.” Matteo Bandello was the Italian storyteller whose tales circulated in adaptations across Europe. His version of the story of the lovers of Verona lies behind the English poem Shakespeare used for Romeo and Juliet. You can picture people sitting in a garden while someone reads such a story aloud. Pater’s own readers knew the scene from their parlors, since reading novels aloud in the evening was one of the great Victorian pastimes. That’s an ordinary way to spend an afternoon, which is exactly what makes it interesting to Pater.
Then he makes a bigger claim, this time about play. “Often such moments are really our moments of play, and we are surprised at the unexpected blessedness of what may seem our least important part of time.” He gives two reasons, first that play is often what “people really apply their own best powers” to, and second that “at such times, the stress of our servile, everyday attentiveness being relaxed, the happier powers in things without are permitted free passage, and have their way with us.” The second reason is the deep one, since it says relaxation isn’t the opposite of attention but a different kind of it, a way of letting the world in that work-mode keeps out.
Anyone who’s had an idea in the shower or on a walk knows what he means. Focused, servile attention is good at the task in front of it and bad at everything else, like a flashlight that lights one patch of floor and darkens the room. Relaxed attention is more like turning on the overhead light, less intense but able to take in a sound from the garden or a line from the story that you wouldn’t have noticed while working. Pater’s word “servile” is pointed, because it implies that most of our attention belongs to somebody else, our employer or our worries, and that play is when it comes back to us.
The masque is where Pater’s idea gets its clearest form. From music, he says, the school passes “to those masques in which men avowedly do but play at real life, like children ‘dressing-up,’ disguised in the strange old Italian dresses, parti-coloured, or fantastic with embroidery and furs, of which the master was so curious a designer.” Venice had a tradition of organized festivity in the Compagnie della Calza, the “Companies of the Stocking.” The young men who put on these entertainments could be recognized by distinctive dress. The Gallerie dell’Accademia identifies elegantly dressed members of one company at the left of Carpaccio’s Arrival of the Ambassadors.
So why would a costume help anyone listen better than before? A disguise announces that the ordinary rules are off for a while, and that announcement frees attention from its usual jobs, like defending your status or looking busy. Inside the masque everyone agrees they’re only playing, so they can afford to notice things, the music, the faces, the way the evening light falls, and the parti-colored hose become a sign hung on the body saying “not working.” It’s the logic of a costume party, where people who’d be stiff at a meeting suddenly become good company because they’ve been given permission to be someone else.
Pater ends the sentence on a detail only a painter would choose. The master painted these clothes, he says, “and which, above all the spotless white linen at wrist and throat, he painted so dexterously.” White linen at the wrist and throat is the edge of the costume, the place where clothes meet skin and where light catches most brightly, and it can be hard to paint well, since a white that’s too flat looks like paper and a white that’s too busy looks dirty. A painter who loves those edges is a painter of attention, giving the most care to the smallest bright margins, which is exactly the kind of noticing that Pater says play makes possible.
There’s an obvious objection, that play isn’t always relaxed. Games have rules, masques had rehearsals and budgets, and the young men in their striped hose were competing hard for status, so the idea of play as a passive opening to “the happier powers in things without” can look a bit dreamy. Pater actually covers this with his first reason, that play is where people “apply their own best powers,” so his picture is of effort freed from servitude rather than effort abandoned. The masque is the right image for that, since it’s carefully made and freely entered at the same time.
So I think Pater is right that an hour of play can teach a person to listen, as long as we understand play the way the masque shows it, structured, chosen and set apart from the business of the day. The costume gives that condition a visible form, marking the body as off duty so the senses can come back on, and the painter’s care for white linen at the wrist is the same attention turned on the picture itself. It’s a humane idea, that the least important part of our time may be where we hear the most, and I’d add only that it takes some practice to play well enough to hear it. Venice had whole institutions for such occasions. Pater’s masque gives the pleasure of playing a part a place in the painter’s repertoire.
Test your understanding
Question 1 of 3
How does the article distinguish relaxed attention from ordinary work-focused attention?
Guided Inquiry
Questions for Socrates
Explore these questions with Socrates, with this Feature as your reading context.
- If focused attention excludes some parts of experience, how might a person decide when narrow focus is useful and when it becomes limiting?→
- Does adopting a costume genuinely free people from concerns about status, or can it create new roles and pressures? How would this affect the article’s argument?→
- What might it mean to practice playing well enough to listen, and can such practice remain freely chosen rather than becoming another task?→