Renaissance
An Elixir for the Most Delicate Effects
Leonardo’s methods kept a painting open to revision. Pater follows the cost of that freedom from the enduring glazes of the Mona Lisa to the failing wall of the Last Supper.
The Renaissance (1893)Pater’s elixir was a painter’s wish to preserve subtle effects. Leonardo’s experiments show why the support was as important as the paint.
Orientation
At a Glance
- A wish to preserve an effectPater imagines Leonardo trying to give painting’s most delicate effects a long life.
- A dry wall in MilanFor the Last Supper, Leonardo worked on a dry preparation that let him return to passages but began to deteriorate early.
- A different wall in FlorenceThe unfinished Battle of Anghiari supplies another example of Leonardo taking a risk with a wall technique, although the technical details are uncertain.
- A panel that kept its shadowsMeasurements of the Mona Lisa reveal how thinly layered Leonardo’s glazes could be on a wooden support.
The Renaissance · Pater on the painter’s elixir · Pater on painting and the decay of the Last Supper · Diotimos editorial note on the Last Supper · Pater on the Battle of Anghiari · Museo del Cenacolo Vinciano on technique and early decay · De Viguerie and colleagues’ study of Leonardo’s glazes
Pater’s picture of the young Leonardo looks like a scene from an alchemy movie, the painter “poring over his crucibles, making experiments with colour,” and trying “by a strange variation of the alchemist’s dream” to find the secret, “not of an elixir to make man’s natural life immortal, but of giving immortality to the subtlest and most delicate effects of painting.” It’s a lovely swap, because the alchemists wanted to keep bodies alive forever and Leonardo wants to keep a shadow under a cheekbone alive forever, which is roughly the difference between a fountain of youth and a really good archival ink. The question is whether those two wishes, to get the effect exactly right and to make it last, can live together in the same paint, and Pater’s own book supplies a sad test case.
The test case is the Last Supper, which Pater handles briefly but with the right instinct. Leonardo painted it, he says, “not in fresco, where all must be impromptu, but in oils, the new method which he had been one of the first to welcome, because it allowed of so many after-thoughts, so refined a working-out of perfection,” and then comes the blunt admission that “it turned out that on a plastered wall no process could have been less durable.” The museum in Milan now describes the technique more precisely, as a fat tempera bound with egg yolk and applied over a white preparatory layer on a dry wall, but Pater has the logic exactly right. As early as 1517 a visiting canon, Antonio de Beatis, noted that the picture was beginning to decay, and Vasari’s 1568 edition describes the image as badly deteriorated.
The reason is chemistry, and it’s worth spelling out because it shows the conflict wasn’t bad luck. In true fresco, buon fresco as the Italians call it, the painter brushes pigment in water onto wet lime plaster, and as the plaster sets the color is locked into the wall itself, which can make a fresco highly durable, though damp can still damage it. The price is speed, since you only plaster what you can finish that day, a patch called a giornata, a day’s work, and later touches on dry plaster do not bind in the same way. What makes fresco last is exactly its refusal of afterthoughts, and afterthoughts were the whole point of Leonardo’s method, because a painting built up slowly, figure by figure and layer by layer, can’t be finished one wet patch at a time.
Florence gave him a second chance at a wall and the same result. When he started the Battle of Anghiari in the great council hall in 1505, early accounts tell different stories about the method and its failure. One anonymous Florentine account links the experiment to a recipe from Pliny and tells of fires used to help it dry. Leonardo’s own note records that on a Friday in June 1505, just as he began to paint in the palace, the weather broke, the cartoon tore and a vessel of water spilled, which reads like an omen in hindsight. The battle itself belongs to another discussion, but as a technical story it repeats Milan, with a wall asked to behave like a panel and refusing.
The other side deserves its due here, because the case for a built-in conflict has a big hole in it. Several of Leonardo’s panels preserve the kind of subtle shading Pater describes. When researchers used X-ray fluorescence to examine faces in seven Louvre paintings in 2010, they found that on the Mona Lisa he’d laid glazes one or two thousandths of a millimeter thick, building shadows no more than thirty or forty thousandths deep, layer after layer, which is Pater’s elixir in working order. Oil on a poplar panel allowed endless after-thoughts and has held for five centuries. And much of what happened to the Last Supper wasn’t Leonardo’s doing, since the refectory was low and damp, a door was cut through the bottom of the picture in 1652, taking Christ’s feet with it, and an Allied bomb in August 1943 brought down the roof around it.
There’s a famous anecdote that shows how all this looked from outside. In Rome, Vasari says, when Pope Leo X gave Leonardo a commission, he immediately began distilling oils and herbs to make the varnish, and the pope sighed that this man would never get anything done, since he was thinking about the end of the work before the beginning. Leo meant it as a put-down, but it’s also a precise description of Pater’s elixir, a painter who starts by worrying about the surface that will protect the finished effect. On a panel that worry pays off, and the Mona Lisa is the proof, while on a wall it led him to choose the wrong beginning for the sake of the end.
So does the wish to keep an effect alive push a painter toward incompatible choices? It does, I think, once you notice that keeping an effect alive means two different things that can pull apart. While you’re painting, it means keeping the picture open, able to take one more touch and one more correction, the “after-thoughts” Pater praises. Once you’re done, it means keeping the picture fixed, safe from damp and time, which is what fresco does by refusing correction from the start. On panel the oil medium serves both meanings at once, because it stays workable for days and then hardens into something durable, but on a wall the two meanings split, and every time they split Leonardo chose the first.
My verdict is that Pater’s elixir was a real goal and a reachable one, and that the incompatibility he half notices is local rather than built into the dream. It belongs to the particular wager he made on walls, where fresco calls for speed within each patch and the refinements he wanted needed time. Pater’s phrase “it turned out” makes the ruin of the Last Supper sound like bad luck, but Leonardo made a similar bet twice, in Milan and again in Florence, each time preferring the open picture to the permanent one. The Louvre panels show how well his refinements could survive on a support that let him take his time, and on the walls he kept choosing the dream over the wall.
Test your understanding
Question 1 of 3
Why does the article describe true fresco’s durability as a “refusal of afterthoughts”?
Guided Inquiry
Questions for Socrates
Explore these questions with Socrates, with this Feature as your reading context.
- If artistic refinement depends on leaving a work open to revision, when should an artist decide that further improvement threatens the work’s survival?→
- Does Leonardo’s repeated preference for a revisable image over a durable wall painting seem like a technical mistake, a deliberate artistic value judgment, or both? Why?→
- How does the survival of Leonardo’s panel paintings change the way we should assign responsibility for the deterioration of the Last Supper?→