Renaissance
After the Dates Come Apart
Amoretti unsettled the dates and stories Pater inherited from Vasari. Pater asks what a critic can still learn by attending to an impression.
The Renaissance (1893)Pater gives specialists the job of correcting the record and reserves a place for looking closely. The essay tests how well the two kinds of work can be kept apart.
Orientation
At a Glance
- Amoretti makes Vasari’s story open to challengePater says the 1804 biography left the inherited dates and anecdotes unsettled. It made them questions for further study.
- The Preface gives the critic another taskA critic can attend to the quality of an impression in front of a work. A document can explain its history while leaving that experience to be described.
- Pater lets facts enter selectivelyHis corrected legend can support an impression. He keeps parts of Vasari’s story when they still help him describe what he sees.
- Attribution can change what an impression provesA picture can still give a reader the experience Pater describes after its attribution changes. It then provides different evidence about Leonardo’s own work.
The Renaissance · Preface, p. 2, knowing one’s own impression · Leonardo da Vinci, p. 69, Amoretti and the corrected legend · Leonardo da Vinci, note 169 · Leonardo da Vinci, note 170 · Leonardo da Vinci, pp. 69–70, the divisions of the life · Leonardo da Vinci, p. 73, the letter to Ludovico Sforza
In 1804 Carlo Amoretti, a librarian of the Ambrosiana, published an early critical biography of Leonardo with an edition of the treatise on painting. He compared inherited stories with the evidence available to him, including material earlier scholars had copied from the manuscripts. The result, Pater says, was a criticism of Vasari’s famous life “which left hardly a date fixed, and not one of those anecdotes untouched,” and after it, the story of Leonardo could never again be told as a string of charming tales. The anecdotes now had to stand beside what the documents could establish.
Pater takes the blow gracefully, without a word of regret for the lost anecdotes. The questions Amoretti raised, he says, have become “subjects of special study,” and “mere antiquarianism has in this direction little more to do.” What’s left he hands to other people, “the editing of the thirteen books of his manuscripts, and the separation by technical criticism of what in his reputed works is really his, from what is only half his, or the work of his pupils.” Then he carves out a territory of his own, in a sentence that sums up his whole approach. “But a lover of strange souls may still analyse for himself the impression made on him by those works, and try to reach through it a definition of the chief elements of Leonardo’s genius.”
That’s the method of the whole book in miniature. The Preface says that in aesthetic criticism “the first step towards seeing one’s object as it really is, is to know one’s own impression as it really is,” and here Pater applies it to a man whose biography has just collapsed. The scholars get the archive, and the critic gets the experience of standing in front of the pictures. It’s a bit like a music critic who leaves the session logs and recording dates to the discographers and just listens hard to the record, which is a perfectly respectable division of labor.
The really interesting sentence is the one that comes right after that. “The legend, as corrected and enlarged by its critics, may now and then intervene to support the results of this analysis.” Look closely at the verbs and qualifiers Pater chooses in that sentence. The corrected biography may intervene, not must, and “now and then,” not always, and its job is “to support,” which makes the facts a character witness for the defense rather than a judge. Pater has let the scholars fix the record, and then told them to wait outside until he calls them.
You can watch him call them in, and the pattern is consistent. In the very next paragraph the corrected skeleton of the life appears, three neat divisions, “thirty years at Florence, nearly twenty years at Milan, then nineteen years of wandering.” A little later he notes that the date of Leonardo’s move to Milan is “fixed” by a draft letter to Ludovico Sforza. The letter shows how Leonardo presented his skills to the future duke. Its date is an estimate. Facts like these come in when they give the story a firm frame. When they threaten a favorite anecdote, Pater lets the correction in only halfway, saying that Vasari’s tale of Verrocchio giving up painting is “true only in sentiment,” and keeping the sentiment.
There’s a lot to be said for this, and it deserves a fair hearing. Amoretti’s dates are dull without someone to say what the pictures feel like, and Pater’s impressions are often startlingly exact. He’s also mostly faithful to the corrections he does use, in the broad outline of the life. The exact year of the move is a reminder that one document rarely settles every part of a chronology. A critic who refused to write anything until every attribution was settled would never write at all, and Pater’s honesty about what he’s leaving to others is more than many critics manage. His essay first appeared in 1869, and the chronology he leans on was itself the product of sixty years of the specialist work he describes as finished.
The trouble lies in one of the jobs he so politely gave away. “The separation by technical criticism of what in his reputed works is really his” sounds like something for specialists, but an impression of a picture is only an impression of Leonardo if the picture is by Leonardo. Several of the works Pater reads closely in this very essay have since been reassigned to other painters, which shows that the critic and the connoisseur were doing a single job all along. Pater kept saying, even in his 1893 edition, that the editing of the manuscripts “remains” for others, a decade after Jean Paul Richter had published a large selection of them in 1883, which suggests how firmly he’d closed that door.
So what remains for a critic after the dates come apart? The impression remains, and Pater is right that nobody else can supply it, since no document can tell you what it’s like to stand in front of a painting. But the corrected biography deserves a bigger role than he gives it. It shouldn’t just turn up “now and then” to support the critic’s results, because its real use is to test them, to tell him when the face he’s analyzing belongs to someone else’s hand. Pater’s word was “support,” and the honest word would have been “check,” which would have cost him a few beautiful pages and saved him a few mistakes.
Test your understanding
Question 1 of 3
How does the article characterize Pater’s preferred relationship between documentary scholarship and aesthetic criticism?
Guided Inquiry
Questions for Socrates
Explore these questions with Socrates, with this Feature as your reading context.
- When, if ever, is Pater justified in preserving the “sentiment” of an anecdote after its factual basis has been weakened?→
- Can a critic meaningfully separate the experience of a work from questions about who created it? Why or why not?→
- How might criticism change if documentary evidence were treated as a check on interpretation rather than as occasional support for it?→