Renaissance

Adam Can Barely Lift a Finger

Michelangelo brings two hands almost together. Pater looks at the weaker one and sees a body on the verge of waking.

The gap between Adam and God concentrates the drama into a small gesture. Pater’s account of expectancy helps explain why the figure already looks so complete as he waits to receive life.

Orientation

At a Glance

  • The gap holds the actionGod stretches toward Adam with a firm right arm. Adam’s left hand rises only a little, leaving a narrow gap between their fingers.
  • Adam looks complete and dependentPater compares Adam with the figures of the Parthenon. He sees the same bodily beauty without their look of self-sufficiency.
  • The finger makes the breath visibleGenesis describes God breathing life into the man he formed from the ground. Michelangelo gives that gift a gesture the eye can follow.
  • The figure seems ready to wakePater describes the beginning of Adam’s life in the language of recovery. His whole body looks gathered into the effort of receiving what it cannot supply.

The two hands at the center of the Creation of Adam are among the most familiar details of Western art, echoed in the poster for Steven Spielberg’s E.T. and in countless later images. Everybody remembers the gap, the sliver of empty plaster between God’s finger and Adam’s, and most people assume the drama belongs to God, who sweeps in fast with a whole crowd of figures packed under his billowing cloak. Pater goes the other way and looks at the weaker hand, the one that can hardly be bothered to rise, deciding that the real action of the picture is happening on Adam’s side of the gap, where at first glance almost nothing is happening at all.

He starts with a comparison that would have felt fresh to his readers. “Fair as the young men of the Elgin marbles, the Adam of the Sistine Chapel is unlike them in a total absence of that balance and completeness which express so well the sentiment of a self-contained, independent life.” The Elgin marbles had been in the British Museum since Parliament bought them in 1816, and one figure worth setting beside Adam is the reclining nude from the east pediment of the Parthenon, usually identified as Dionysos, who leans back on a rock spread with a cloak and an animal skin and looks perfectly at ease. He’s beautiful and he doesn’t need anybody, which is Pater’s point about the Greek type, a body so complete in itself that nothing has to happen to it.

Adam is built from the same kind of body and runs on a completely different battery. “In that languid figure there is something rude and satyr-like, something akin to the rugged hillside on which it lies.” That last detail is smarter than it looks, because in Genesis God forms man “of the dust of the ground,” and the Hebrew plays the name adam against adamah, the word for ground or soil, so a figure who seems half made of the slope under him is good theology as well as good painting. Michelangelo props him on his right elbow along a bare slope, left knee raised and left arm resting on it, and the whole pose belongs to a man who has been poured out of the earth and hasn’t quite set.

Then comes the sentence the whole picture hangs on. “His whole form is gathered into an expression of mere expectancy and reception; he has hardly strength enough to lift his finger to touch the finger of the creator; yet a touch of the finger-tips will suffice.” Read the grammar, because it moves from present to future, from what Adam can’t do to what will be enough, and the picture sits exactly in the hinge between those two tenses. God’s right arm is fully extended and his index finger is straight and purposeful, while Adam’s left hand dangles from a wrist propped on his knee, the finger curving down as if it’s still deciding whether to bother. Pater calls this expectancy, and he means it as the figure’s real action, the thing Adam is doing with his entire body.

It’s worth asking why Michelangelo used a finger at all, since Genesis says God “breathed into his nostrils the breath of life,” and a breath is hard to paint across a gap like this one. The old hymn Veni Creator Spiritus (Come, Creator Spirit) calls the Holy Spirit digitus paternae dexterae, “the finger of the Father’s right hand.” The hymn gives the gesture a resonance without establishing what Michelangelo had in mind. In both, the image is of the Father’s right hand. Either way, the choice moves life from the face to the fingertip, which puts the entire event at the farthest reach of two bodies.

Pater’s reading of what the touch will do is the most original thing in the passage, because he sees a recovery more than a creation. “With him the beginning of life has all the characteristics of resurrection; it is like the recovery of suspended health or animation, with its gratitude, its effusion, and eloquence.” That’s Adam as a patient coming round after anesthesia, heavy and warm and not yet able to lift his arm off the blanket, but plainly alive and about to be grateful for it. It explains why Adam looks so finished, with an athlete’s body and none of the fresh-from-the-factory stiffness you might expect of the first man ever made, since nobody is assembling him and the touch will simply switch him back on, like a phone at one percent that lights up the instant the cable reaches it.

A red chalk study in the British Museum lets you see Michelangelo working out Adam’s pose. He studies the torso and the weight of the reclining body before the figure takes its place opposite God. The hand that seems barely able to rise gets its effect from the whole pose, from a body at rest doing as little as it can.

Modern viewers have tried to find the secret of the picture on God’s side, most famously in 1990, when the physician Frank Lynn Meshberger argued in the Journal of the American Medical Association that the cloak and figures around God trace the outline of a human brain. It’s an interpretation of the shape around God. Pater looks to Adam, where he makes the subject of the picture reception, a body so complete that it needs only the smallest contact to come alive, and the gap is how Michelangelo paints that smallness. You can’t show the touch without ending the suspense, so he shows the instant before and leaves Adam forever with “hardly strength enough to lift his finger,” which turns out to be all the strength the story needs.

Test your understanding

123

Question 1 of 3

According to the article, what is the central difference between Pater’s Adam and the Greek type represented by the reclining Dionysos?

Choose one answer

Guided Inquiry

Questions for Socrates

Explore these questions with Socrates, with this Feature as your reading context.