Renaissance
A Visionary’s Kind of Realism
Pater’s Botticelli notices the visible world as sharply as any naturalist. What makes him a visionary is how he rearranges what he sees to share a feeling.
The Renaissance (1893)Pater calls Botticelli both a visionary and a realist. The apparent contradiction clears when we ask what a picture can make recognizable about a person’s inner life.
Orientation
At a Glance
- The visionary begins by looking closelyPater gives Botticelli the same alertness to color, gesture, water and plants that he finds in his Florentine contemporaries.
- Details awaken a private moodPater distinguishes painters who transcribe a scene from a painter who selects, isolates and combines its details to give a feeling a visible form.
- A later critic describes a similar moveEliot’s objective correlative is a group of details or events that evokes an emotion. The comparison helps explain how Pater thinks a private mood can reach a viewer.
- Recognition is the testThe feeling has to become recognizable to someone who never met the painter. For Pater, that shared recognition makes Botticelli’s vision a kind of realism.
The Renaissance · Sandro Botticelli, p. 39, naturalists and visionary painters · Sandro Botticelli, note 93 · Sandro Botticelli, pp. 40–41, sympathy and the true complexion of humanity
Pater begins by granting Botticelli the skills of his time. “Botticelli lived in a generation of naturalists, and he might have been a mere naturalist among them,” with that alert sense of outward things which, in the pictures of the period, “fills the lawns with delicate living creatures, and the hillsides with pools of water, and the pools of water with flowering reeds.” But this, Pater says, wasn’t enough for him, because “he is a visionary painter, and in his visionariness he resembles Dante.” The distinction he draws next is the hinge of the whole essay, and it rearranges the usual ranking of Florentine painters in a way that would have startled many of his first readers.
On one side stand Giotto, Masaccio and even Ghirlandaio, who “do but transcribe, with more or less refining, the outward image.” Pater calls them dramatic painters and nearly impassive spectators. Ghirlandaio’s frescoes in the Tornabuoni Chapel show why Pater might think so. He set figures from contemporary Florence beside episodes in the lives of the Virgin and John the Baptist. On the other side stands Botticelli’s kind of genius, which “usurps the data before it as the exponent of ideas, moods, visions of its own,” and “plays fast and loose with those data, rejecting some and isolating others, and always combining them anew.” The edition’s note explains that exponent here means the visible expression of something inward.
The mechanism Pater describes is precise, and it begins with sight. To Botticelli, “as to Dante, the scene, the colour, the outward image or gesture, comes with all its incisive and importunate reality,” so the visionary sees just as sharply as the naturalist. But the thing seen awakes in him “a mood which it awakes in no one else, of which it is the double or repetition, and which it clothes, that all may share it, with visible circumstance.” There are three steps here, the outward particular, the private mood it kindles, and the return of that mood to the outward world dressed in chosen details, so that a feeling nobody else had becomes a picture everyone can feel.
Half a century later T. S. Eliot gave that third step a famous name. In his 1919 essay on Hamlet he argued that the only way to express an emotion in art is by finding an objective correlative, a set of objects, a situation or a chain of events that will be the formula for that particular emotion, so that the outward facts, once presented, immediately evoke it. Pater’s visionary does something similar. He might choose pale light, a bowed head and a wilting rose because the details together make a mood available to strangers. The realism lies in how precisely those details convey the feeling.
That puts Pater squarely at odds with John Ruskin, the most powerful critic of his day. In Modern Painters, Ruskin reads the phrase “cruel, crawling foam” as an example of grief changing how a speaker sees the world. He allows that the distortion can convey genuine feeling. Pater gives the painter more deliberate control. His visionary can rearrange the visible world on purpose to show what that feeling is like.
So why should selection and rearrangement count as realism at all? Pater’s answer arrives a page later, where he says that Botticelli’s sympathy conveys “into his work somewhat more than is usual of the true complexion of humanity,” and that this “makes him, visionary as he is, so forcible a realist.” The reality in question is human feeling, and especially the uncertain, mixed feeling Pater finds everywhere in Botticelli’s faces. Feelings like that have no single outward form you can copy, since nobody’s ambivalence stands still to be painted, so the only way to show them truly is to select, isolate and recombine, building a face out of the details that carry the mood.
The risk in all this is obvious, and Pater half admits it with the words “a mood which it awakes in no one else.” A visionary realism can slide into mere subjectivity, a private feeling imposed on the world and called truth because the painter felt it. Pater’s safeguard is the clause that follows, since the mood is clothed in visible circumstance “that all may share it.” The test of the visionary’s realism, then, is recognition. If viewers who never met the painter look at his Madonna and know that strange, reluctant sadness from their own lives, the selection has told the truth about them, however freely it treated the outward data.
My verdict is that Pater’s claim holds, once you see that he’s talking about a realism of inner weather rather than of outer fact. The spectators record what a scene looked like, while the visionary records what it felt like to be a certain kind of person in it, and for the uncertain feelings that interest Pater most, rearrangement is the only honest method available. The claim has limits, since it can excuse any self-indulgence that calls itself sincere, and it depends entirely on the viewer’s sense of recognition. But when it works, as Pater thought it did in Botticelli, it gives us a truth no transcription could reach.
Test your understanding
Question 1 of 3
What most clearly distinguishes Botticelli’s visionary method from the method of Pater’s “impassive spectators”?
Guided Inquiry
Questions for Socrates
Explore these questions with Socrates, with this Feature as your reading context.
- If viewers’ recognition is the test of visionary realism, how should we judge a work that deeply affects some viewers but leaves others unmoved?→
- Where should we draw the line between a revealing rearrangement of outward reality and a distortion that merely imposes the artist’s private feelings?→
- Does the article’s distinction between recording what a scene looked like and what it felt like clarify realism, or does it broaden the term too far? Why?→